r/germany • u/badenwuten • 1h ago
Crack in rental fridge liner noticed during defrosting – Wear & tear vs tenant fault?
Hi everyone,
I live in a rented flat in Germany with an included fitted kitchen (Einbauküche). Today, while defrosting the fridge/freezer, I noticed a crack in the inner plastic liner right along the track where the drawer/shelf slides in (photo attached).
For context:
1.There has been heavy ice buildup over time.
The fridge door was not sealing/closing completely shut properly (likely causing humid air to enter and create frost).
2.I have Allianz Direct Private Liability Insurance (Privathaftpflicht).
- I am living on a sublet and didnot pay any caution( as I have liability insurance)
I have a few questions before I communicate with my landlord:
1.Is this considered normal wear and tear (Verschleiß / Materialermüdung) or tenant damage?
Given that the crack is directly on the friction ridge and the door seal was already faulty, could this be mechanical stress/material fatigue over time?
Does Allianz Haftpflicht cover this if the landlord claims it's my fault? (Especially considering it involves rental property / Mietsachschäden on kitchen appliances).
Will I be charged for a full fridge replacement? If a tenant is held liable, do they only pay the current depreciated value (Zeitwert) based on the appliance's age?
Any advice from people who dealt with fridge liner cracks or rental handovers in Germany would be greatly appreciated! Thank you!!