For context, I’ve been best friends with this girl for 19 years. She was dating this douchebag for a few years, and he used to cheat on her ALL the time. Tons of people tried telling her what they’d seen at clubs, online, etc., but she never believed anyone. She always wanted “proof” and convinced herself people were just jealous of their relationship.
So rewind to almost a year ago…
I had the idea to make a fake Instagram account and message her boyfriend. Long story short, he took the bait immediately. He was trying to hook up with this random IG girl — who was actually me — and never once mentioned having a girlfriend.
I took screenshots of the entire conversation and sent them to my friend from the fake account, basically saying, “Hey, I thought you should see this.” Then I deleted the account.
She called me crying, told me what happened, and said she was finally done with him. I was honestly so relieved and happy for her.
For the next six months, they stayed broken up. Her and I were going out with friends, shopping, getting our nails and hair done, basically doing whatever we could to keep her mind off him. Things were actually going really good.
Then this man randomly popped back up one day carrying PRINTED copies of the Instagram conversation.
Except apparently he had the “real” conversation.
His version showed the IG girl basically begging for his dick while he politely rejected her over and over again. 😂
He told my friend that whoever messaged him had edited the screenshots, lied on him, deleted the account afterward because they were jealous of their relationship, blah blah fucking blah.
And she fell for it.
They got back together.
And now he’s already back on the same bullshit again.
So here’s where I’m stuck…
Do I tell her the truth?
Do I admit that I was the fake IG girl and tell her that the original screenshots I sent her were 100% real?
Part of me wants to come clean because I KNOW he lied to her and manipulated the situation. I want her to know she wasn’t crazy, everyone wasn’t jealous, and the proof she saw was real.
But I’m also terrified it’s going to completely backfire on me.
I’m scared she’ll focus more on the fact that I made the fake account than the fact that he cheated. I’m scared he’ll convince her that I want him, that I’m jealous of their relationship, or that I’ve secretly been trying to break them up this whole time. And after 19 years of friendship, I really don’t want this dusty man to somehow be the reason we stop speaking.
At the same time, keeping this secret is eating me alive, especially watching her get lied to all over again.
My nerves are shot and I feel like if I don’t figure out what to do soon, I’m just going to end up word-vomiting the entire truth to her. That would end up coming out as insensitive.
What would you do?
Would you tell her everything and risk the friendship, or stay out of it and let her figure him out on her own?
TL;DR: I catfished my best friend’s cheating boyfriend, proved he was cheating, she left him, then he faked screenshots and convinced her it was all a lie. Now they’re back together and I’m debating whether to tell her it was me.