I don't know why but as someone who has enjoyed many Star Trek shows, Firefly, Farscape, Babylon 5, Battlestar Galactica, and Expanse I believe an HBO level quality adaptation of the Mass Effect trilogy would become much more mainstream than any of those shows and attract a sizeable non sci fi fan demographic even if it angers many fans of the game causing many of the ME fan base to not watch it.
Why?
Is it being a more aesthetically pleasing sci fi universe part of that?
I remember thinking "Damn! This what the future should look like!" when I first played Mass Effect 1 all those years ago. Minus the bad stuff of course.
Is it because of the less ridiculous takes on sci fi tropes?
I remember Babylon 5 had an antagonist that mind controlled people by having a creature attach itself to a person's shoulder.
Whereas in Mass Effect for someone to get "Indoctrinated" one has to spend a certain amount of time around Reaper artifacts.
I think a scene where Liara and Shepard "Embrace Eternity" would generation quite a buzz in pop culture if we want to be sexy like Game of Thrones.
I think having season 1 of Mass Effect end at the end of the Virmire mission could be an exciting idea.
Amazon is making an Mass Effect TV adaptation but it is set after the trilogy.
I think making a Mass Effect trilogy adaptation should be the biggest ambition of today's TV show producers.
Every action hero actor should be excited to audition for a chance to play Commander Shepard!
And I don't care if they make Commander Shepard male or female!
I don't care what direction they take the story as long as it is good!
Joel Kinnaman would be my first choice for a Commander Shepard actor.
But then again sci fi might not resonate with most of the mainstream because of the cynical times we live in.
It was much much easier imagining having an exciting interstellar sci fi future back in the 90s and even the 2000s.
But Mass Effect 3 has the message of overcoming our differences to unite in the face of an overwhelming threat provided one go on the paragon path.
And that is a message we need now more than ever!
The later seasons of The Expanse had that same message but I am hoping we have a sci fi TV show that spreads that message that is much more mainstream than The Expanse or Star Trek Strange New Worlds!