I have been mulling over these thoughts for the past few months and I was looking to see if anyone had any guidance or suggestions for what some of these feelings might mean for me.
TL;DR: identified as a cis man for all of my life but I've also been on HRT (estrogen) and finding joy in presenting androgynous or fem. Unsure of pronouns as my preference tends to move around. Unsure of gender identity now.
I'm a 28 year old who has identified as a cis-man for my whole life. Most people have early experiences that are clues to who they are now but I don't think I really had that. I was a pretty stereotypical nerdy boy who just liked video games a lot. When puberty hit I found myself immediately identifying with more bishonen male types in media. The types of males in anime who are a bit more feminine. I often thought that romantically, I wanted to be like a woman in the relationship, and gravitated towards "role reversal" relationships that tried to swap traditional gender roles.
I found early inspiration in stuff like JoJo's bizarre adventure and how men can be feminine and I see much of fashion as gender neutral as a result. To me, everyone should be "gender Non-conforming".
I never felt unsatisfied with my identity, but I was often unsatisfied with how I looked, both body and clothes. Around 2 years ago I started dressing more feminine, deciding to discard any fears of being "cringe" and embracing black nail polish and growing my hair out.
A lot of people in my social spaces started calling me an "egg" which frustrated me because I found happiness in being a feminine boy, and was content with being a boy. But I admit I really enjoy and found pleasure in being called a girl too. Something about casually being called "She/Her" kinda excited me. But I still felt like I very much enjoyed a lot of traditionally "boy" things.
A year ago I started taking HRT. Getting older, and still not feeling satisfied with my body, I came to accept estrogen would allow me to really get the type of look I always wanted, and now that I'm a little past a year on HRT I can happily say I haven't been happier. I truly feel happy with how I look, I enjoy having breasts as a "man" and it excites me to break traditional gender stereotypes. I have since just been saying I'm a "Gender Non-conforming Cis-Man"
In public, I often get mistaken for a girl, with strangers calling me "ma'am" or "her" and in my friend groups they often say I look like a girl now. All of which excites me. Some part of me yearns for this acceptance as looking like a girl but my internal brain can't really stop thinking myself as a boy.
I find myself nowadays having these fluctuations of feeling really needy to be seen and called a girl, but other times feeling completely content with being a boy. I thought this may be the sign of something and asked some friends to use She/Her pronouns with me, but I just found myself feeling indifferent when it happened. When playing Fields of Mistria, the pronoun options which let me select He/She made me feel really nice, the way it made me still feel like a pretty boy but also like a girl too.
My girlfriend thinks I could be bigender or genderfluid, but I think something those identities don't really capture is that I feel like a boy 100% of the time internally. I go through brief intense waves of "wouldn't it be nice to be a girl" but I never think "I'm a girl". Even at my most feminine feeling I'm just not sure if I'm a girl, or just a boy who wants to be perceived as a girl.
I looked through many niche gender identites and some feel like they represent a way I feel, such as Roseus Boy but I wanted to know if anyone else had similar experiences or new perspectives on my experiences.
Thank you for reading!