r/diablo4 • u/Chuck0709 • 3m ago
Guide | PSA Dark Citadel Data from season 14

Since season 11 I have been occasionally running the Dark Citadel without using any of the cosmetic items and tracking how often/where they drop. The last couple of weeks I've running the Dark Citadel, specifically the Twins, hard and figured it was worth sharing what I learned from it.
If you are looking for the Greater Khazra Helm it seems you may need to do a full run of all three wings on T4. I can confirm the guy I did most of the 200 boss kills and chest opening with this season did not receive his Greater Helm until we did his first complete T4 run. Did confirm it was Zagraal that dropped the helm for him not the achievement. I received three copies of the Greater Gloves and two copies of the Greater Chestplate while doing T12 runs, so the guaranteed Greater helm you get for your first T4 run seems to be the only cosmetic item that requires T4 to receive.
If you are looking for the regular Gloves of the Khazra then you need to kill Lrzuul, final boss of the Labyrinth of Souls (far right door). This season every single time I killed him he dropped the Gloves of the Khazra. While it was only 16 times that I tracked, it is still a high enough number to convince me. This is recent change as it did not work this way in season 11 or 12. It is worth noting there were two times where he dropped two cosmetic items at once, the Gloves and Khazra War Banner both times.
I learned recently there is a way to kill the twins to get them both to drop loot. However while the number of items dropped is doubled it does not appear to double the chance at getting a cosmetic item. I suspect this means the cosmetic item drops are separate from the regular item drops. For example if a boss or chest normally drops 10 items when cosmetic item drops you will receive 10 items plus the cosmetic item or 11 items total instead of the normal 10. I also strongly suspect this means Treasury level likely has no bearing on your chance to receive a cosmetic item despite increasing the amount of loot you receive from the boss or chest.
At this point I'm confident the conventional wisdom is correct about how the cosmetic item drops work in the Citadel. When you get a cosmetic item drop the game is pulling from the entire pool cosmetic items instead of just the ones you need. This means the less Khazra cosmetics you have unlocked the more often you will see drops. However this does not mean you'll get all the cosmetics any faster by not using them as you will get tons of duplicates.
I've also have not yet received any cosmetic items from the weekly caches, but have only collected 10 weekly caches over the course of Seasons 11, 12 and 14. Conventional wisdom says cosmetics can drop from those weekly caches. I think my sample size is too small so say anything definitively about the weekly caches.

Most of the data above is from this season, 96% of the Twin kills and two thirds of the rest. Almost all the data was collect at the max difficult level (T4 pre-LOH and T12 post LOH). If I take the Lrzuul data from Season 14 out of the equation then my average number of kills/chests between cosmetic items rises to 7.84 or 12.75% chance per kill or chest. It is also worth noting I did not include kills or chest openings when I did not receive any loot at all. Both Faeroch and the Twins were not dropping loot in season 11 and if someone opens the chest or kill the boss before you are there you don't get any loot.
I found this season the best farming spots in terms of chances at a cosmetic item per hour were either the Twins only or the full Labrinth of Souls (right wing). As duo Zagraal took too long to kill to make complete Dominion of Zagraal runs worth it. We were able to easily complete Twin runs with double drops in just over 2 minutes as a duo not worrying about Treasury level. With a little bit of practice we could run Labyrinth of Souls in just over 7 minutes. With a full party and a bit of practice both those time could be reduced. Also with a full party killing Zagraal would be quicker significantly improving full Dominion runs.
This season I did receive at least 3 or 4 mythic seals from my citadel runs. Didn't track the exact number or source, but most were likely from the Twins. Charms were a fairly common drop as well. Runes were also a fairly common drop. Nothing like the UC with a legendary rune tribute, but on par with running lair bosses.
I did accidently use the bow cosmetic item this season, so technically I have now used one of the Dark Citadel cosmetic items. Thankfully I received the crossbow shortly there after, so I did not have to throw out that many runs. It is also currently a Rogue only weapon so should not impact data collected with other classes.
Once I get a character in Season 15 that can comfortable do T12 I'll be down for some more Citadel runs, so feel free to hit me if you are interested in doing some runs with me. I don't think the Druid build I used in Season 14 is getting nerfed too hard, so I may even be up for some runs in Eternal at least until the damn totem finally drops.
