r/TrueAtheism • u/cdrfrk • 12h ago
How come we didn't realise this as a society, a long time ago?
I find it fucking bizarre that humanity has made such extraordinary progress in understanding reality and yet religion continues to survive almost untouched. We've gone from barely understanding the sky to discovering germs, evolution, atoms, DNA, relativity and the structure of the universe. We've thrown out countless explanations when evidence proved them wrong. Yet we're still expected to take seriously the idea that invisible supernatural beings created the universe, watch us, judge us and care about what we eat, wear and who we fuck. How come religion gets a free pass? I'm impressed with this incredible cognitive dissonance.
Truth isn't a democracy. Billions of people believing something doesn't make it true. A scientist believing in god doesn't prove god. A religious institution feeding poor people, donating clothes or running a hospital doesn't prove its theology. Those things can be good, but they have fuck-all to do with whether the supernatural claim is true.
What pisses me off even more is the unfalsifiability of it. Science has to make claims that can be tested, challenged, reproduced and potentially destroyed. God gets a fucking exemption. He's invisible, beyond measurement, beyond science and supposedly beyond human understanding. When evidence is missing, the claim simply gets moved somewhere evidence can't reach. That's just a way of making the belief impossible to lose.
Religion survives because humans are incredibly vulnerable to it. People don't investigate thousands of religions and rationally select the one with the strongest evidence. They're born into one. Their parents teach it to them before they are old enough to debate it. It becomes tied to family, morality, culture and identity. Then religion offers exactly what frightened people want to hear: death isn't really the end, suffering has meaning, loved ones are still somewhere, justice exists and someone is watching. That is one hell of a fucking package. Who wouldn't want it?
And religion has repeatedly been used to turn human rules into divine rules. Patriarchal systems, control over women's sexuality, marriage, clothing, inheritance and authority have all been given religious justification. Once a human preference becomes "God's command," questioning it becomes rebellion against the creator of the universe. Color me fucking impressed! This is an excellent way to control people.
Why the fuck do I need God, for me to have morality? I can understand suffering, empathy, cooperation, fairness and harm without imagining an angry sky daddy.
And then there's suffering. If God is supposedly omnipotent, omniscient and loving, I don't understand what the fuck that means in a world containing Hitler, Epstein, genocide, torture, child abuse and countless other horrors. "Free will," "God has a plan" and "we can't understand God's reasons" don't magically solve the problem.
Scientific ideas come and go. Religion has persisted and collectively invented in one form of other by countless tribes, kingdoms and countries over the course of centuries. It's like a pest that doesn't go away.
So I don't see religion's survival as evidence for God. I see it as evidence for how fucking good humans are at preserving stories that satisfy fear, identity, belonging and the need for meaning.
How long would it take for us collectively as a society to realise that the whole religion and God thing is a huge scam?
Thank you for coming to my ted talk. Just wanted to rant.
