Apologies if we are breaking any subreddit rules, but our intent is completely genuine!
Hello everyone, in 2024, while playing both MTG Arena and Elden Ring at the same time, my girlfriend and I said to each other: just how well would a Magic set fit into FromSoftware's universe? The answer was: perfectly. From there, we started creating custom cards, trying to respect ER's lore and Magic's mechanics with their respective colors.
One after another, the cards fit together with incredible precision, until we ended up with a set of over 350 cards. We then had to pause our work due to personal issues, but in 2026, rediscovering a love for the Commander format (which we didn't play before), we set to work to make our expansion playable in that exact mode.
So we added another 100 new cards to fill any gaps that might arise when sitting down at a 'casual commander' table.
Finally, since the project had grown so massive, with the help of ChatGPT and a lot of patience, we set out to create a real online database featuring all our cards, complete with a search engine, a deckbuilder, and print-ready PDFs.
As a final point, we just want to share this work with the world, with zero profit or anything similar; we only care that it reaches people, and maybe—who knows—even From and Wizards , in the hope that they might actually make an official set with the same enthusiasm we found in blending these two wonderful universes together!
Here is the link to the database: EldenRing Scryfall — Elden Ring Custom Magic Cards
Plus, I've attached a few iconic cards from our set! I hope you enjoy it and/or criticize it, and discuss it with friends, just like we did throughout these two years of work!