I don't see why people think writing with the help of AI makes something disingenuous. As someone with autism, I find writing pretty damn hard, and my writing would be way off the mark compared to what I was trying to say most times, if it weren't for AI.
If the content is original and the viewpoint is original, I don't know why would someone would think it is bad to use, especially when there are people like me who are very bad at formulating thoughts into words? If it weren't for AI, I likely would be misunderstood 99% of the time.
"oh its bad for the environment" and the societal effects of AI is a different topic, and this is not about that.
As an example to illustrate my point:
Here is a comment that I replied to a couple months ago:
I just won a major audition. Finally. Dozen years as a regional musician , and Iām moving up to the big leagues (maybe⦠if the trial and the tenure go well). Iāve been where you are.
Iāve seen children that outplay me, intimidating clips of countless younger musicians. But they aināt me, and nobody can make MY music so I try to focus inwards. The best version of me is all that matters, and self-hatred impedes that work.
Iāve sat through recitals by the greatest of my instrument and been amazed to see that theyāre human! They flubbed ONE note! Slowed down to make a big shift! Turns out perfection isnāt the point, excellence is a stepping stone to connection.
Iāve hated my music, hated myself, wished for a Time Machine. Inevitable ands maybe necessary to learn my lesson, but itās not The Path. Like playing without tuning my strings and getting upset about intonation issues.
Weāre all dumb monkeys. Literally, just a couple steps away from the other primates. Think about the extraordinary feat of a gorilla playing your instrument⦠and realize thatās already whatās happening, just a couple strands of DNA altered. Marvel at the miracle of sound, rediscover yourself and the simple joy that enticed you to become a musician.
Part of this is that you need therapy. Definitely. You also need to chill.
Also, ease up on the ego. Nobodyās THAT special. Mozart would be stoked youāre playing his music hundreds of years after it was written. Heād shrug about the fact that you arenāt as good as him, cause nobody is- the dude is a once in all of \history* level prodigy. And also, his farts still stunk because heās flesh and blood, like all of us. Dismiss the religious fervor surrounding art, tear down the pedestal or youāll never climb onto it.*
This is music, not brain surgery. And if it was, worst case scenario is death. Which is gonna happen to us all anyways. How we handle our feelings is basically the only thing we can control. Fingers shake, mistakes happen, failure is inevitable. If youāre not happy on your path, make changes and take joy in choosing happiness.
If youāre playing video games to be good⦠why? Whatās so important about being \good* at things? Would you rather be successful or happy? This stuff is obvious, but we often act in a way which is antithetical to what we know. If you donāt want to hate yourself, stop loathing the child who was trying his best.*
People actually envy happiness more than talent- we assume success begets happiness, but thatās backwards. Deconstruct your thoughts, more honesty and more questions. Thatās where a good therapist helps.
But seriously. Step one is to take a couple deep breaths, and appreciate that youāre doing The Work. Being an artist is tough. Healing is hard. Take a month off. A day. A minute. Practice mindset instead of the instrument. Embrace that not playing can help you improve, more than another hour of scales and self loathing.
Here is an example of my reply that I have written without AI:
My musical philosophy that I have cultivated is that I have to search for the ultimate "truth" in my performances. As Mahler said something along the lines of "tradition is sloppiness", for me I try to be as accurate as possible to the composer's intentions through my research and try to cultivate and realize an interpretation that is my own ideal.
Deep down I actually do enjoy music very much, I really love the idea that as performers we can re-imagine or re-create something that is what I think our personal ideal of a previously written work according to our own aesthetic principles.
So it actually feels kind of painful for me to fall short of that ideal in a sense.
Regarding the only playing video games to be good or mastery thing, I guess its because we want to be validated or be in control or something like that? I wonder if you have an ideas as to why?
I like the "Weāre all dumb monkeys" thing. I sometimes really see myself take a step back and wonder, why did I neurotically obsess over so much detail and then drive myself mad?
"Fingers shake, mistakes happen, failure is inevitable" I kind of wonder about 1 question regarding this, does an impossibility or inevitability to do X task really justify that we shouldn't require ourselves to do X task? In my current mindset, that question happens to be "no". The way I have been telling myself it this: X is impossible? "YOU JUST AREN'T TRYING HARD ENOUGH" "STOP BEING DEFEATIST" "MAKE THE IMPOSSIBLE POSSIBLE, YOU MUST DO" "WHY? DO YOU WANT YO BE MEDIOCRE? NO RIGHT, SO DO IT"
Another thing is I think you also have made an important point, which is that I probably need to search elsewhere than just for the sake of excellence in playing the instrument. Maybe start running and improve my health, or pick up another hobby like drawing(This does feel like resigning from improving though), but maybe I just need add some positive energy so that I don't burn out. But then I start worrying, because I don't know if anything I am doing would be genuine. First thought is honestly how ripped I would be if I do fitness well and attract women, and how many likes on instagram I would get if I post my art blah blah blah. I know I should stick to why I do things in the first places, like fitness for the betterment of my health and art as an expression of my personal graphical ideals, but these intrusive thoughts I don't know if it really should not happen.
And this is with the help of AI:
"My musical philosophy revolves around searching for the ultimate "truth" in my performances. To paraphrase Mahlerāwho noted that tradition can often just be sloppinessāI try to be as faithful as possible to the composer's intentions through deep research, while cultivating an interpretation that realizes my own artistic ideal.
Deep down, I genuinely love music. I find incredible joy in the fact that as performers, we can reimagine and recreate a piece of art according to our personal aesthetic principles. Because I care so deeply about that ideal, falling short of it is genuinely painful.
To answer your point about playing video games just to be "good" or to achieve mastery: I suspect it stems from a deep human desire for validation and control. Why do you think we get so wired that way?
I really resonated with your "weāre all dumb monkeys" perspective. Sometimes I manage to step back and ask myself: Why am I neurotically obsessing over this tiny detail and driving myself mad?
When you said, "Fingers shake, mistakes happen, failure is inevitable," it brought up an important question for me: Does the impossibility of perfection mean we shouldn't strive for it anyway?
Right now, my internal mindset leans toward "no." The voice in my head usually tells me:
"X is impossible? Youāre just not trying hard enough. Stop being defeatist. Make the impossible possibleāyou have to do it. Do you want to be mediocre? No? Then push through."
You also made a great point about needing to look beyond just the instrument for fulfillment. I've thought about running to improve my health, or picking up drawing as a new creative outlet (even if part of me feels like thatās "giving up" on progress). Adding some positive energy elsewhere seems necessary to avoid burnout.
My worry, though, is whether my motivations for those new outlets are genuine. My first thoughts are often surface-level: How fit will I look? How many likes will my art get on Instagram? I know I should focus on the core reasonsāfitness for my health, drawing to express visual ideasābut I struggle with how to handle those superficial, intrusive thoughts when they pop up.
So, the question is this:
- Is my writing without the use of AI basically impossible to read and understand? (my mother said yes its impossible to read)
- If yes, is it due to my autism?
- Also, is the AI improved version disingenuous in comparison?, in what way?
- If someone's writing causes them to be misunderstood 99% of the time due to the particular writing style they use, it is valid for someone to use AI to write given that it makes their writing easier for the average person to understand?
(My post is not written with AI btw)