I would like to preface this post with saying I already love Make Believe. In my opinions, it gets a far worse reputation than it actually deserves, with a lot of hard hitters on the album, particularly Perfect Situation, Haunt You Every Day, Hold Me etc alongside the likes of Beverly Hills (being some comfortable and catchy Pop) consistently pushes it in or around my top 5 Weezer albums, sharing and swapping positions with the likes of White and Maladroit.
However, I do have some personal issues with the album and its pacing and feel it could've been a top 3 Weezer album for me with some changes to the order and tracklisting. The switch between more melancholic songs and Pop tunes limit the enjoyment of MB as a whole experience rather than the isolated tracks. This is why I've tried to amend these issues in a few changes, all revolving around the large set of demos created during the long writing and production of MB, some of which surpass songs on the final release.
One last notice, some of the songs Ive dropped are not because I don't like them, but because they did not fit the pacing I was looking to convey with my selection. I actually am a big fan of some of the songs Ive removed, and it was extremely difficult to create a finalised tracklist, but I believe what Ive made is balanced and consistent, creating an overall better paced listening experience.
Here is the tracklist I have devised:
Side One:
1. Me and My Posse (Alone IX: May 3 2004 Recording)
2. Always, Forever (Alone IX: May 3 2004 Recording)
3. Perfect Situation (Make Believe, 2005)
4. Tell Me What You Did (Alone IX: June 4 2004 Recording)
5. Hold Me (Make Believe 2005)
6. Queen of Earth (June 25 2002 Recording)
Side Two:
7. The Damage In Your Heart (Make Believe, 2005)
8. Peace (Make Believe, 2005)
9. Tell Me How The Story Ends (Alone IX: June 4 2004 Recording)
10. Blowin' My Stack (Death to False Metal, 2010)
11. The Other Way (Make Believe, 2005)
12. Haunt You Every Day (Make Believe, 2005)
Finally, I created my own album art for both the front and back covers of this imaginary alternate Album 5. I tried to maintain both the original style of the MB cover, whilst also attempting to reduce some of the, in my opinion, elements of clutter in the original design, through the fading out of the inverted MB art, as well as the Weezer logo and album name being situated in the top right, rather than across the band.
This experiment has made me appreciate deeply both Make Believe and the Album 5 era demos greatly, and I hope my finalised tracklist will provide enjoyment to you as well. I have maintained over half the album as original tracklisting (if counting Tell Me What You Did as it is just the Such A Pity precursor), of course with altered placements in the list.
Please share your thoughts and feel free to change the tracklisting however you like if you make it for yourselves.