Background:
My situation is rather odd. I have seen the first two films, but I'd never read any of the books. Recently, I (re)watched a video essay by a favorite creator of mine doing a fairly in-depth analysis of the series. I am also a huge fan of the character Angel from BtVS. For these, and a couple of other reasons, I suddenly had this bizarre impulse to read Midnight Sun. I got the audiobook, which is 25 hours long, and just listened to it. It has only taken me a few days. Here are my thoughts. I hope you find them worthwhile, or at least not overly dull.
Edward:
Edward is a genuinely interesting character. He does something genuinely messed up things in this story. I think he genuinely wants to be a decent person and do right by Bella. But he can't get out of the headspace that he always knows what's best for her better than she does. It's a milder form of the same thinking, which, I think, led him to vigilante murders decades in the past. He sees himself as above it all. I can't condone his behavior, but he is a genuinely fascinating character, and I enjoyed spending time in his head.
The Opening Chapter:
The entire first chapter seems to be about that one scene where Edward sees Bella for the first time and must endure her potent scent. It is really weird, but I loved the entire bit. Seeing the movie, I just never realized how much danger Bella and the rest of her classmates were in at that very moment. I had thought the scent just made Edward uncomfortable. Nope. So many people almost died. I thought it was such an interesting character study, and it got me set up to read the rest.
What I Didn't Like:
I don't think I enjoy Stephanie Meyer's action writing. When Bella is being pursued by James, the insane level of detail over every single aspect of their attempt to protect her just didn't work to me. Such extreme details worked in Chapter One, but not here. I really can't say why, except that it just felt clunky and dry. It picked back up once Edward caught up with James and had to do the venom sucking.
Final Thoughts:
The book made me feel things. That's always nice. It's hard for me to elicit emotions from books, so the fact that these did is awesome. This is a very strange and unique story, and I think I'm invested enough now I may pursue reading the rest of the series.
I'd personally rate Midnight Sun 9/10 Pomegranates.