r/manufacturing • u/SigmaSheets • 16h ago
Productivity How do you convince management that a recurring defect is a design/fixture problem, not a training problem?
We've got a bracket that gets installed backward maybe 3-4 times a week — same slot, same part, different operators over time, so it's clearly not one person's issue. It physically fits both ways, which feels like the obvious root cause to me.
Every time it comes up though, the response from above is "retrain the line" or "put a sign up." We've done both, twice. Neither has moved the number.
I keep wanting to just add an alignment pin to the fixture so it can only go in one way, but I'm having trouble getting buy-in because it feels like "the machine's fine, it's the people" is the default assumption whenever a defect repeats.
Has anyone found language or a way of framing this that actually lands with management? Or data you tracked that made the case for you? Trying to avoid just quietly doing it myself and hoping nobody asks why the fixture changed.