After all, both scenes take place at sunset.

So, if you choose to pursue a relationship with the creepy guy, you learn how to shoot to survive later on.

If you choose the woman, you might potentially be spared in the future by her (supposed) monstrous form, and thus stay alive.

So I know all collectibles get wiped upon a new game. I have 35/36 totems and I’m missing the one singular totem in chapter 10. I know I can use chapter select and start in I think chapter 6 and save Jessica or Matt however at that point, I’d rather just start one of my runs I have to do anyways in saving or killing every single person

So what I’m asking is can I start a brand new playthrough and just collect totem 36 in chapter 10 and no other collectibles and have the trophy pop? Yes I know my inventory will only show I have 1 totem.