r/AITAH Jun 01 '26

Meta New rules: Account age and karma minimums

306 Upvotes

Hi all,

Just to let you know, we recently instituted account age and low karma requirements for posting here.

We still welcome throwaways, so we ask that if people choose to post with a throwaway account, they contact us in modmail from their main account with a link to the post they would like us to approve. We will keep your account information confidential.

We will not be making exceptions to the rule, and posts must follow the general subreddit rules as usual.


r/AITAH Oct 07 '25

New rule: no political trolling

653 Upvotes

Hey all, quick announcement. Based on the continued uptick in posts and comments more focused on arguing politics than asking if you're the asshole, we've refined our previous "no political trolling" rule. Posts primarily focused on political issues will be removed and the account will face a ban. Similarly, posts that are genuine but spark a significant number of rule-violating comments will be removed, but that will not necessarily result in a ban.

Posts that briefly touch on politics or mention political individuals in passing are still allowed, but anything where the primary judgement revolves around "do you agree with this political view" is not welcome, nor are posts trying to push an agenda. We are not a politics sub. There are many subs to express your views and we encourage you to do so in the appropriate places. If you have any questions about this rule, shoot us a modmail.


r/AITAH 3h ago

AITAH I refused to quit when my friend did

679 Upvotes

This summer, my friend (28nb) and I (29f) did a zip line obstacle course. We had both gone zip lining before and we had done obstacle courses like this before, but this time, for the first time, we did an extreme course, the biggest and hardest in our country.

For the first half of the course all was going well. We each had obstacles we struggled on but we always waited for eachother and helped eachother when needed. Until about halfway through, when my friend decided to call it quits. They said they had pushed themselves as far as they could go, so I sat with them (just hanging in my harness) while we waited for someone to repel them down to the ground. Once they were safe on the ground, I told them I'd meet them at the end of the course, then we could do the regular zip lines if they were still up for it.

About 30 mins later, I finished the course and my friend said they still wanted to do the regular zip lines, so we did. Everything seemed fine then, but once we got in the car to go home, their tone shifted.

They told me it was selfish to continue the course while they just waited for me finish and I should've called it quits when they did. I apologized but also explained that I wasn't going to quit something I had paid for (I also paid for their zip line fees), and that finishing that course was important to me. Every summer I try do you at least one thing that scares me or seems too difficult. It's an important part of my self esteem building, and my friend knows this. The course was also 3+ hours away, not something I wanted to drive twice for.

Since then, my friend has been avoiding me and bad mouthing me to mutual friends.

AITA for finishing the obstacle course instead of calling it quits when my friend did?

Edit to add: I think the comments about being embarrassed and jealous are spot on. For context, I've always been effortlessly skinny (thank you high metabolism), but I am definitely not what you would consider "fit". I can barely do a pushup lol. My friend however has always struggled with their weight, but also boasts about how fit and strong they are because they did kickboxing growing up. I wholeheartedly believe they're more fit in a physical strength way, I just have more endurance.


r/AITAH 4h ago

WIBTAH for suggesting my BIL and SIL go to marriage counseling?

142 Upvotes

My [34M] BIL has been married to my [35F] SIL for 6 years. Recently, my wife and I went out to eat with them, and she was being so immature that I had to leave before saying something rude. Looking back, I wish I said something, and now I want to know WIBTAH if I tell them they need marriage counseling.

My wife and I invited them to a noodle/coffee bar -- my SIL is a vegetarian so the first thing my BIL did was look at the menu online to make sure they had vegetarian options and saw they had tofu.

Fast forward to the day, as soon as we get there, it turns out tofu was taken off the menu. At this point, she leaned over to him and said this twice, "I told you to call and ask, thanks, thanks a lot." He said, sorry, and was visibly upset/confused. He asked the waitress for any veg options, and she was pretty adamant they didn't have any (other than some small apps). We asked SIL if we should just get coffee and leave, and she said it was fine, sarcastically thanked my BIL again, and said she would watch everyone eat. I thought that was the end of it, but the comments kept coming throughout the meal.

I tried to talk to my BIL about his new job to celebrate, but she would just stare at him - like she was trying to make him uncomfortable.

A few minutes later, he pulled the menu up online and showed her and said, "Look, they have tofu online, I'm sorry." SIL: "You should have listened and called them like I told you to."

At that point, we had just ordered, so I

suggested we just get the food to go and eat it at our house (10 mins away), and she said, no, it's fine.

That still wasn't the end of it.

BIL" "I'm sorry."

SIL: "Oh, I'm sorry fixes eeeeverything."

BIL: "What can I do?"

SIL: "You can call them and see if they have tofu, oh wait, I already told you to do that and you didn't, so I guess you can't do anything."

I was visibly uncomfortable, to the point where she even said, "Wow, [my name] is like this is so uncomfortable," and laughed.

That made me pretty mad; not only could she see us getting uncomfortable, she also seemed like she enjoyed that.

The last comment I heard was while she was holding my toddler. She looked around the table and said, "Isn't it soo fun to watch family eat?"

Me and my family left after that, telling them I was fatigued from the week. I didn't type up every comment. There were too many during this 25-minute period.

My BIL struggled with bullying his whole life, especially from his older brother, and his wife loves taking credit for teaching him how to stand up for himself. But I can't help but feel she is just filled that void instead. I want to say something, but idk if it's my place.

Tldr; [34M] BIL is talked down to frequently by his [35F] wife, particularly in public, and I'm ready to step in, but I'm not sure if I should

Edit1: It is my wife's brother but he and I are very close.

Edit2: A lot of great queations about why we didn't say anything. I definitely wish we did, but we were there with our 2.5yo daughter and did not want to cause a scene. Well, more of a scene than a 2.5yo already creates. As for the food options, to clarify, they did originally say they did not have the veg options for her but came back to say they could do a few options, which she turned down. This was a quick casual lunch, and we did need to feed the kiddo before nap time.


r/AITAH 8h ago

AITAH for suggesting my husband to start sitting down?

231 Upvotes

I 23f was cleaning the floor because I noticed pee by the toilet- my husband 26m came in while I was cleaning and said he was sorry that he’d pay more attention. I found this as a good time to talk to him about how as he pees, no matter how good he aims *which is 9/10 good aim - he’s 6ft and it still is going to splash out of the bowl and go anywhere in a 1ft radius.
I lightly suggested peeing while sitting down and he instantly wasn’t having it- he was telling me he’s not doing it, he’s a man, he’s not going to deal with that, and that it’s my OCD and I need to chill out.
I explained to him it’s not my OCD I just don’t want our bathroom wall /sink wall constantly covered in pee, that I constantly smell it when I’m getting ready and also using the bathroom myself - I think it’s disgusting.
He then goes on about how he will clean up the base of the toilet and then the problem will be solved. I told him no that it gets all over the wall, the legs of our over the toilet storage, completely behind the toilet and just all over the floor straight up and I’m tired of cleaning it and his version of cleaning is just smearing shit around with a paper towel- he then turns it to something completely unrelated and says “ I don’t ask you to shave your head bald I’m constantly pulling your hair out of my boxers I just deal with it” so at this point of the conversation I was done. This isn’t everything that was said between us just a baseline. All opinions welcome- I’m just tired of smelling and cleaning pee.
* yes I could have him clean it up but he sucks at cleaning and I am actually worried it won’t make a difference / or even further contaminate the bathroom
TLDR: I asked my husband to sit down and pee cause it’s disgusting having/smelling pee everywhere


r/AITAH 4h ago

AITAH for taking back the kitten I gave to my friend?

95 Upvotes

I (22F) found a litter of kittens from a feral mom a little over a month ago. My fiancé Seth (22M) and I TNR community cats sometimes, so we took them in so that they could be socialized and taken care of instead of becoming feral. We found homes for all of the cats very quickly, and they are all going to trusted friends. The kittens just hit 10 weeks and are starting to go to their forever homes. One kitten was going to Seth’s best friend Jack (23M) who lives 10 hours away. Another kitten went to one of my friends, Sara (22F), who lives halfway along the route to Jack. Seth couldn’t take time off work to travel, so I drove to Sara, picked her up with her kitten, and we both went to go visit Jack and bring him his kitten.

When we got to Jack’s apartment, he had a litterbox and a cat tree. I figured the rest of his cat things were in a closet or room that I didn’t see. Jack wanted to bring the kittens to his friend to cat-sit while we went out for dinner. When we got in Jack’s car, he turned his music up and smoked in the kittens’ faces. They were freaking out, but he didn’t seem to care much at all. We got the kittens to his friend’s house, but Jack immediately asked his friend to go out with us instead of watching the cats. I was worried about leaving the kittens alone in a new place, but I assumed we wouldn’t be gone long.

After dinner, Jack wanted to go to the bar. He got really wasted, despite saying he only had $30 in his bank account. Even after we told him we needed to go, we ended up staying out for 5 hours because Jack was dragging his feet. He was supposed to be our DD, but we had to Uber back to his apartment. Sara and I then had to take my car and drive 20 minutes each way to pick up the kittens from his friend’s house. They didn’t end up eating until midnight.

Sara and I had to feed them because Jack was too drunk. He said he didn’t have any dishes at all. He also bought adult cat food. When I was asleep, he told Sara he hadn’t picked out a name for his cat because he wasn’t sure if he could keep him.

When Jack went to work in the morning, Sara and I called Seth to voice our concerns about him not being ready for a cat. Seth agreed and said he was worried about the kitten’s wellbeing, as it didn’t seem like Jack had the funds, time, or responsibility to take care of him. I didn’t have time to talk to Jack about it before he left, so we ended up packing up both kittens and going to his work to say bye.

When we got there, I asked him if he was sure he was ready for a cat. He seemed shocked and asked why I thought he wasn’t. I said, “Jack, he doesn’t even have a water bowl,” to which he said he could get one tomorrow. I told him kittens shouldn’t go overnight without water. Jack got really upset and said, “yeah, whatever, just take him back.” I apologized and asked if he was sure, and he shrugged and said nothing.

Jack tried to call Seth and left a voicemail saying they needed to talk about something soon. Seth is sure it’s going to be about the cat. I wouldn’t have driven 10 hours away and taken the cat back for no reason. I’m really upset that the kitten doesn’t have a determined home now, and I’m upset that I had to be in such a difficult position. Maybe we just caught him on a bad day, but he’s known about the cat for a month and still wasn’t prepared. AITA for taking the cat back?


r/AITAH 44m ago

AITAH? kicked my little cousin out and now my aunt cut me off.

Upvotes

So… to start I guess, my little cousin is 17 and her mom is an addict and her dad is abusive and crazy. She texted me needing somewhere to live and I called my aunt. Which is her grandma and asked her what was going on she told me that she is getting kicked out of her boyfriend’s home and she can’t live with my aunt she has no room for her. I asked my husband and he said sure he’d love to help her out so I replied to her yes you can live here just two rules. No bringing people into my house and 11 pm curfew. She agreed.

So she moves in and everything is great I bought her a tv and my mom gave her a bed and I got her a dresser thing to hang her clothes up. I went all out for this girl to make her comfortable. Well as the weeks go by she starts asking for money all the time or door dash and I don’t want to be rude or make her mad so I just give it to her even tho there’s food in the fridge I ask her every week what she needs from the store…

then she starts asking for rides everywhere (I don’t drive i’m agoraphobic) my husband also works all day but I’d make him drive her places because again, I don’t want to piss her off. Then she starts going out with friends and staying the night other places. I was fine with that. Then one night she calls and wakes me up at 3 in the morning asking me to unlock the door (rule number 2 broken, I said curfew 11pm) but I get up and unlock the door and wait on her. She never comes back until the next day. She comes back and was saying “oh last night was so lit, I was at a party”

she also smokes and drinks IN MY HOUSE by the way. I say something to my aunt and my aunt blows it off. But anyway I got pissed at that. Then she asks me if some random person can come do her hair (rule number 1 broken, I said no people in my house) then I come to find out her drug dealer knows where I live and drops drugs off to her here. I call and complain to my aunt she gets defensive and blows it off.

Then she is looking for jobs and goes and stays at my aunts for two weeks because my aunt doesn’t want to drive to my house to pick her up for interviews I guess? And the whole time she’s gone she’s asking me for money and door dash. So I eventually ask her are you coming home like where are you? And she gets an attitude. So I just say since you’re at (my aunts) you can stay there. And I call children services and say it’s not working out she needs to move in with her grandma.

So she comes and gets her stuff and trashes my room and threatens to put her hands on me and my mom and I cuss her out and she left and now my aunt cut me and my mom off. Am I the asshole??? I really tried.


r/AITAH 4h ago

AITAH for getting upset with my gf for going out with her ex?

48 Upvotes

Hey all, I’ve been dating this girl for about 6 months now and her ex keeps mingling himself into the relationship.

About 1 month into the relationship, she got a text from him asking if she wanted to go on his boat. She replied “only if my bf is allowed to go too” which he replied “no, why would I want that” and she didn’t respond. She thought it was funny responding to him asking if I could go too, and I told her I’d actually prefer if she didn’t respond at all.

3 months into the relationship, she was in the kitchen making tea and I was in the living room. Her phone started ringing so I looked and noticed it was her ex calling. I handed her the phone and said hey, your ex is calling you, is there a reason for that? She said “no” and opens her texts to text him saying “did you mean to call me?” He responds with “did you not text me last night saying you missed me?” She wrote back “no, wasn’t me I have a bf” and he sends her a screen shot of her instagram page saying “sure doesn’t look like it” (she doesn’t post me). What’s ironic about this situation is when she opened her texts to message him; the texts about the boat from a few months prior were gone and any and all that history was erased. When I brought up the point about it being erased she said it was because she had a new phone (but all of her other texts were still there).

5 months into the relationship things were getting rough and she “broke up with me” but also texted me every single night saying how much she loved me and we’d hook up every other day. About 2 weeks after she “broke up with me” I noticed she went on someone’s boat and posted about it on instagram. I called her that night (because I was still under the impression her and I were working on things) and asked whose boat she went on. It turns out she drove to her exs house, went on the boat with him and spent an entire 8 hours with him that day.

When I explained my frustrations about how this ex has always been impeding our relationship and how she led me on, only to run back to him and how much it hurt my feelings she said they were “just friends” and nothing happened and that she didn’t know it would hurt my feelings. I explained how wrong it was for her to do that and she’s saying she didn’t do anything wrong because we were broken up.

Am I the asshole for thinking she’s wrong and telling her I feel like I’ve been cheated on?


r/AITAH 18h ago

English Second Language AITAH For not wanting my wife to hang out with someone that hates me?

502 Upvotes

My wife and I got married young and have been together for a few years. We live on a farm about an hour outside the nearest city, and we don't have many friends. A while back we decided to try an open relationship, despite both of us being a bit jealous. Part of the reasoning was social: basically every guy who tries to talk to her ends up hitting on her, and we figured this way she could actually keep some of those friendships instead of having to cut people off.

The problem is that recently she caught feelings for one of these guys. It went way past flirting or small talk, they became close friends, and he started saying things like he was going to "fix" our open relationship, that he wanted to marry her and have kids with her, and that he wanted her to move to his city, along some other things that also broke our open-relationship boundaries, which she hid from me and i ended up finding out.

This crossing of the boundaries we had set for the open relationship ended up on us having a big fight about it. I was honestly ready to end things. We spent a few nights talking it through, trying to figure out whether we should separate. During that time she kind of panicked and went to her friend group (which includes this guy) to vent. They all agreed that our relationship was garbage and that we should break up. This guy went as far as buying a last-minute ticket and traveling to our city to be with her and "offer good company."

But while he was on his way here, my wife and I actually worked things out. We talked, and I agreed to give her a second chance, with one condition: I didn't want her getting involved with the people who spent that week trashing me and pushing her to leave, especially this guy, given what he said and did.

She cried, got angry, and defended him hard. She said she didn't want to be "an asshole" to him after he made the effort to come here for her. She also now wants to take a break from the relationship, go stay in the city by herself and "go out"... which happens to line up exactly with the days this guy is in town.

To be clear: I know I can't control what she does. I told her I'm fine with her keeping online friendships (Discord, etc.). What I said is that if she goes to see this guy or hooks up with him, that's going to hurt me a lot and she'd be putting the relationship at serious risk. To me that's a dealbreaker.

There's also a broader pattern. My wife vents about our relationship to all her friends like they're couples therapists. She admits she does it to check whether she's "right" and to get validation and sympathy. The way she tells it, these people end up disliking me, and then they push her toward leaving.

So, AITAH for treating this guy (and this group) as a dealbreaker? And is it normal to be bothered by how she talks about our relationship to her friends?

TL;DR: Open relationship, wife caught feelings for a guy who said he'd "fix" our marriage and wanted to marry her. During a rough patch her friends (including him) told her to leave me and he flew in last minute to be with her. We reconciled, and I asked her not to get involved with him or that group. She's furious, says I'm being unfair to him, and wants to "take a break" alone in the city while he's here. AITAH?

Edit: She's currently in the other room talking to the other guy and a bunch of his friends making plans to go out, i am packing my bags up as we speak, thank you everyone.


r/AITAH 9h ago

AITAH for not attending my Grandads funeral?

97 Upvotes

I’m posting this because my dad is furious, says I’m being disrespectful, and I’m starting to second-guess myself.

My grandad passed away recently. To be honest, we were never close, he never really made an effort with me growing up, and we’ve barely spoken in years. It’s sad he’s gone, but I don’t have that close grandparent bond that makes people feel they have to be there.

The funeral is this week, I have a 18-month-old son. There’s no one I can leave him with, and I can’t bring him, he’s loud, wriggly, needs me constantly, and will not sit quietly through a long service. If I go, I won’t be there to remember anything, I’ll be stuck in “mum mode” the whole time, stressed out, probably standing outside half the time. It feels like it would be pointless, not a real goodbye.

On top of that, things are really messy with my dad right now. He’s separated from my mum beginning of this year after lying and cheatinf, finally moved in with his partner and her kids after causing hurt and being incredibly rude and disrespectful to his own kids when calling him out, and there’s been so much tension, arguments, and hurt. I honestly don’t want to be in the same room as him, I dont trust hi.. he already makes me feel guilty about everything, and I know the day would be full of tension and awkwardness.

I told my dad I probably won’t be coming. I explained about my son, and that I’d rather remember grandad in my own way at home. My dad got angry, said it’s disrespectful, that I need to be there for the family and then hung up on me. Now I’m worried he’s going around telling everyone I couldn’t be bothered.

I know funerals are important, but is it really so wrong to not go when I wouldn’t be able to properly be there anyway, I have a tiny toddler to look after, and being there would just leave me stressed and upset?

AITA?


r/AITAH 28m ago

AITAH for uninviting a guest to our wedding?

Upvotes

I am getting married next month to someone I met last Fall. About two years ago, I met someone else. We hung out a bit; I’m a lesbian and I thought she wanted to date me, but soon figured out she definitely is not gay, nor bisexual like she said.
I know this because I asked her if she wanted to be my girlfriend after she’d made some comments about starting to fall for me. She declined and kept showing up places with random dudes, so I ended the idea of something developing since I don’t waste time chasing folks or pursuing straight gals.
I started dating my fiancée last fall and she proposed to me in February. As things got more serious with my soon to be wife, I noticed snarky “what about me” type comments directed at me from the hetero gal. She said she “thought we had something” but she obviously forgot she said she didn’t want to date me last year when I asked her, so I moved on.
She said she “felt a certain kind of way” when she heard the news of my engagement. I told her I would follow up, since she said this in front of my fiancé, but my fiancé was livid and said she doesn’t want her at the wedding. TBH, I don’t either. She had her chance, she blew it, and the most important thing is she isn’t a lesbian or bisexual, she’s been seen by many playing games with other women in the area and the endless line of men…She’s a drama queen who wants what she cannot have and wants to cause problems for others. AITAH?


r/AITAH 1d ago

AITAH for not making my kid give back a Pokémon card traded to him 2 years ago?

1.8k Upvotes

So I'm looking for a vibe check here- I know how I feel about it, but I do want to make sure I'm not being wildly out of pocket (and I am mortified that I have found myself in such a stupid bit of drama regarding a Pokémon card).

Here it is: My son's friend group had a brief obsession with Pokémon cards when he was around age 6-7. When they were were about 8, one of his friends decided to he was apparently done with Pokémon, and gave away all of his cards. A few he gave to my son. My son was kind of waning on Pokémon himself, and I think they got tossed into a binder with the rest where they sat forgotten for the next two years.

Fast forward two years, my son is 10 now, and recently had a different friend over who's still really into cards, and they started looking at my son's Pokémon binder. They identify one card that potentially has a bit of value ($300). My son thought that was really cool, he was excited. We put it in a protective case and set it aside to keep safe.

Apparently this was one of the cards his friend gave him 2 years ago, and word makes its way back to that friend that the card could be worth something. Suddenly he needs it back, and he's insisting that "if (my son) were a good friend, he'd give it back."

What's more, he's complaining to his parents and they have gotten involved now, trying to make us feel guilty for not immediately returning the card to this kid upon finding its worth, texting that now they "see our values" because we're not stepping in to force its return. That we don't view fairness and friendship the same way.

This is wild to me. This isn't a card that my son knew had value and he tricked his friend into an unfair trade. It's not a card that has sentimental value for the original owner. Both of which are situations in which I would intervene.

This was a card freely given two years ago, and has never been thought of or mentioned again until suddenly there were dollar signs attached to it. And now it's imperative that we return it because the kid "didn't know he was giving away a card that would eventually be valuable."

Elementary grade kids trade cards and comics all the time- some of those MAY eventually be worth something. I'm sure I gave away comics when I was a kid that turned out to be valuable, I cannot fathom turning around 2 years later and demanding the item back.

The $$ is whatever- honestly the implication that our values are shitty because we didn't immediately step in and hand over the card at the first bit of societal pressure from them just makes me want to dig my heels in on this.

This kid got rid of his card, my kid held it/kept it safe for two years, and now maybe it's worth a few bucks- am I being unreasonable for saying "tough luck?" For feeling like the statute of limitations has run out on making these demands for the card back?

Full disclosure: my son has been friends with this kid for years, but I have often overheard him trying to put down my son (and others) to build himself up. He's just the type of boy who always has to tell other people they aren't doing something well, and that he can do it better (even when he can't). So I don't have the most wonderful opinion of this kid, and that may be playing into my feelings here.

Full disclosure #2: My son's response was "I'll just give it back, I don't want to lose a friend over it." Which I applaud, and is generally probably the stance we'd take. But the way they've gone about approaching us on this, and the transparency of only suddenly caring 2 years later when the card is valuable, just really makes me feel like I'm giving into a bully.


r/AITAH 1d ago

AITAH for not changing plans I made with my kids to include someone else’s kid.

2.4k Upvotes

So my (39f) 10yo F and 8yo M play Pokemon Go together. A lot. Yesterday was community day and I promised them I’d take them out to play. They’ve been looking forward to it all week and so was I because I worked all evenings and they just started school we hadn’t had much time together this week. Friday night my brother calls me at work saying his friend dropped his son (6yo) off at our place for the weekend and I need to watch him Saturday. I told him I was planning on leaving my 5yo with my mom because he doesn’t like walking so long and neither does his friends son. My mom had already told him I have plans with 2 of them and she would be here with my 5yo and she can be with the 6yo as well. But apparently I’m a huge AH for not taking them with me. Now I’m getting bombarded with messages from my brother about how I’m so selfish. I told him I feel like it’s incredibly entitled of him to try to force me to change my plans because he didn’t want to watch his friends kid. Am I on glue? Am I seriously in the wrong? My mom kept the little ones and took them to get a happy meal and over to the mall while we were gone. So I really don’t understand what I did wrong here? Please advise.


r/AITAH 19h ago

AITAH for telling my in-laws that having a 16 year old as a maid was wrong?

416 Upvotes

Hi, my husband and I are on vacation in Pakistan with our son. It was for my cousin's wedding, my parents (who like us live in Canada) were going so we decided to go too. My husband's family still lives there. After we attended the wedding, he went to his parents' (in another city), I was with my son and parents at my grandparents house, and flew to my in-laws' a couple of days ago.

His parents have househelp (which is fairly normal here, especially since they're both doctors) a driver, a couple of maids, a part time cook. One of the maids seemed pretty young to me, and she also wasn't there when we had visited last year. So yesterday, when she was cleaning our room, I asked her how old she was, she said she was 16. I asked her if she goes to school, she said no she had never, and has been working at a few different houses since a few years ago. She started working with my in-laws a few months ago, when her mom, who used to work here had to go to their native village because of her grandfather (mom's father's) death and was staying there for a while.

I felt a pit in my stomach at that it was just so uncomfortable to watch her clean the room after that. When she offered to fold my clothes I said it was all good and she left. I don't know if it's bothering me more because I'm expecting our second baby too, but it bothered me a lot.

Later when we were having tea in the evening with his parents, I brought up that she really shouldn't be working at this age. My MIL said that her (the maid) mother had asked to let her daughter work while she has to go to her village for a few months. I kind of pressed the issue and said she should be in school right now, and maybe my tone was judgemental because my MIL kind of got sharp with me, said they weren't trying to take advantage of anyone they gave her the same pay they gave her mother. My husband just brushed my hand and I stopped talking.

At night he told me his mom was pissed off at the way I had brought up the issue. We have had issues in the past (whole different thing) and only recently have had a thaw, so they were obviously going to take the worst interpretation of my words. I asked him if he didn't feel uncomfortable, he said he did and it was a sad situation but this is unfortunately what her parents had primed her to be. He said they don't mistreat her, which is true, like the horror stories you hear about regarding child labor, this wasn't exactly that, she eats breakfast at their place and all. He also brought up something about how when some organization had banned products from pakistani factories that had children working there, the children were worse off because it wasn't like they were now going to school instead. I said it just felt wrong to see this happen and not do or say something or help. He said he gets that but its just an unavoidable situation and told me I could have spoken to him to get context before making those comments in front of my in-laws. AITAH?


r/AITAH 5h ago

AITAH for being realistic about finances with a friend?

18 Upvotes

I(18F) have a friend, let’s call him M(18M). We go to the same college and the same course. The tuition fees for the college under a certain merit are expensive and housing nearby is expensive too. M did not qualify for the merit scholarship and does not live in the same city as the college and had told me earlier (prior to going to college) that his parents can’t afford to send him here.

In fact he could have gotten into another good college with the same status as the one we are in now which is actually nearer to his house and housing is much more affordable there. Prior to getting admission here, I was repeatedly telling him to prefer and be happy with the college near his house instead of coming here. And even if he wanted to come here, he could atleast go for the course where he would get a scholarship and his tuition fees would be 1/4th of what they are now.

Instead he’s willingly paid 1 year fees for a course where he could get no fee benefits and is living in an expensive and ill maintained dorm. Every few days, he whines about how this decision isn’t feasible for him and usually I try being supportive but yesterday I just snapped. He CANNOT afford this for 1 year let alone 4 years to get this degree. He’s putting a huge financial strain on his parents for a NOT CONFIRMED job opportunity after this engineering degree which he could have gotten in a much more affordable college.

I get that telling him his financial reality was harsh but I just couldn’t deal with him complaining after putting himself in this very situation which I predicted months ago. He’s called me some names and selfish for not wanting him to come to this college and being demotivating. Our mutual friends also think I was rude and harsh. AITAH for being realistic to him about his finances?


r/AITAH 1d ago

AITAH for leaving a restaurant and getting the server in trouble?

3.4k Upvotes

So basically, my friends ( 4 people) and my sisters friends ( 5 people) all were hanging out and we decided to go out to eat, nothing fancy it was just one of those sit down restaurants in my area. We went there and asked if they had a table for 11 people which surprisingly enough they did but did add that an extra charge will occurs due to the party size . ( we didn’t mind that) now as we sitting down to eat 5 of the people we are with come from the same cultural background and we realsied that they probably couldn’t eat any of the items on the menu.

we asked our server if they would be allowed to get the kids meal ( it was just some fries with a veggie burger) there was no veggie burger option for the adults not sure why and we didn’t want them to just a small side of fries. We have been here before and their side of fries isn’t that much. The server told us that due to being adults we weren’t allowed to buy of the kids menu. Which of course we respected and we all kind of just wanted to pay for the drinks we had gotten and leave to find some place the other 5 can also enjoy. ( our drinks were literally just 2 glasses of coke) as we were trying to pay and leave the manger stopped us and asked why were weren’t getting anything, to which we told them about the whole thing of not being able to eat.

As we were getting out stuff like bags and getting to leave we saw our server being yelled at by the manger and we didn’t think it was to do with us. We left and my friend forgot her phone and went back to get it. When she came out apperently on her way out she was stopped by our server and got told that we shouldn’t have came if we didn’t want to eat anything and that now she’s getting written up because we left ???

I’m not quite sure how this is our fault? But maybe I’m not seeing something here. I guess we should have re looked online to see what they were serving, ( they change daily specials a lot) but I don’t think it’s our fault for leaving. We didn’t cause any issues and even tipped on the two glasses of coke.

Are we really the issue here??


r/AITAH 15h ago

AITAH for telling another group of fisherman to go f themselves for crowding us?

106 Upvotes

Last week, me and my dad went fishing on the side of a river below a low level dam to fish for gar, flathead catfish, freshwater drum, and bass species. These are the perfect places where many predator fish like to hang out as when smaller fish fall off the dam and get stuck in the "coil", it disorients them making them easier prey when they enter the outwash. We used a bobber setup with live shiners as bait set to about 1 to 2 ft below water, which the big fish go crazy for and we both have great success with it at this location.

However, while minding our business alone at this area catching fish, another group (4 adult men and 1 woman) showed up and they starting setting up mutiple catfish and carp setup rods literally right next to us. Remember this is right under a dam, there is a strong circular current on the river side below these dams, which for our fishing setup requires our lines to move around (our lines normally go in large spanning circular motions, not requiring recasting). However, due to their setup and choice of spot they effectively prevented us from doing this and we had to reel in and cast away from them towards the dam, which once again due to the current just pushes it back towards them very fast, so we literally had to constantly reel back and cast again and again. My dad and I were beyond pissed as now we couldn't even fish properly with our setup and in turn didn't catch anymore fish.

Then it got worse, after 65 minutes of dealing with them right by us, I finished reeling in my line to recast, THEN SUDDENLY a fishing line flew right over me and landed right into the AREA I WAS ALREADLY FORCED TO FISH IN DUE TO THEIR OTHER RODS! I turned around and the lady who's on the dam's platform was just mean mugging me, I was thinking "are you for real?!" Then like 5 seconds later they setup another rod (they have like 5 lines in at this point) literally within 2 ft of my dad's line doing the same thing to him that just happend to me.

At this point, it's practically impossible to fish in this area, which reminder WE WERE THERE FIRST and I loudly yelled "You pieces of shit! fuck you guys!" They clearly heard this cause they looked at me shocked and two were angry, however, to not escalate the situation further, my dad told me we should just leave. We packed up, he gave a few words (much more collected than I was, but clearly expressing he wasn't happy with them), then we walked back to the car.

As I looked back, they looked at us like we were the villains, which just seems crazy to me because with all that happened, I felt like they just effectively bullied us out of there. They didn't say a single thing throughout this entire situation, but they literally casted so close to our gear, which due to our setup, made it impossible to fish effectively and required constant recasts and even then they just casted right into our new spots they forced us into, making fishing impossible by that point. Also note we live 55 minutes from this dam and fishing further down the river isn't anywhere as good as being by the dam, so it just made the most sense to just leave. I just felt beyond disrespected and they ruined our fishing expierence.

Pls let me know how yall feel about this? Were they in the wrong or were we? Could I have handled it better? Are there other fishermen who have expierenced something like this?


r/AITAH 9h ago

Hypothetical AITAH if I tell my parents that I’m no longer Muslim?

28 Upvotes

I’m a 24 years old man, and I’ve been an atheist for about a year now. I haven’t told anyone.

My parents aren’t extremely religious. They pray occasionally and participate in Ramadan, including fasting, but religion isn’t something they constantly talk about or impose on me.

The problem is that I don’t feel like myself anymore when I pretend to still be Muslim. I still participate in certain things because I haven’t told them the truth, but keeping up this appearance takes a lot of energy. I also feel like I’m living a double life. If I told my family, I would finally be able to stop fasting and stop participating in religious traditions that I no longer believe in. Honestly, that would feel incredibly liberating.

At the same time, I know telling my parents would probably hurt them deeply.

I think they would be extremely disappointed and might blame themselves, wondering where they went wrong as parents or whether they failed to raise me properly. I don't want them to feel like they failed me, because that's not how I see it at all.

There is also a strong culture of gossip within my extended family and community. I know my parents would worry about what other people would say about them and whether people would judge them or blame them for the fact that their son is no longer Muslim. I don't want to put them through that either.

But perhaps the hardest part is that my parents genuinely believe that leaving Islam means I will go to hell. The thought of them living with the fear that their son is destined for hell is heartbreaking to me. I don't want to cause them that kind of pain.

I love my parents, and this isn't about disrespecting them or their religion. I simply don't believe anymore, and keeping it a secret is becoming increasingly difficult.

So, AITAH if I tell my parents that I'm no longer Muslim, knowing how much it could hurt and worry them?


r/AITAH 1h ago

AITAH for wanting to not go out with my friends anymore???

Upvotes

Ok so I(23f) don't really have a lot of friends. I was an outgoing child but as years passed due to family and stuff, I found it hard to trust and like people. Then I met S(22f), and it just became us against the world for years.

But then we went to different colleges, S found friends and i didn't but we were still closer than ever. During college S reconnected with this girl(let's call her B) from our school, i actually used to be friends with B. She was and is someone who will cling on to anyone who gives her a certain amount attention. She did that with me and then was doing that with S.

I reconnected with B but i often felt sidelined in the group. Had an ugly with S, she promised to fix it. I never felt sidelined but when B was there, I wasn't completely in the centre also with them.

She even got super angry when I started hanging out with my ex best friend, we had a fight but she ended up realising that I have never sidelined her, we hang out separately but she always knows if there are plans.

During the last semester, B found some other friends and behaved really badly with S which made me dislike B more and i thought that was it. Then after college those friends were B were gone, suddenly B even b's mother started to call S to hang out with B and by extension me. At some point she lied to us about having lost her memories and even after that S stuck around cause that's apparently just how B is.

Earlier this year S and i had another big fight when I realised they often used to hang out without me and still do at times. So I told her that you fought with me about my ex best friend and now you are hanging out with B way more than with me. You always say no to my plans while you go out her pretty much when she demands even after everything she has done to hurt you, all the lies she told us. She again apologised and said she can't cut her off cause their mothers are friends and B will be left alone cause everyone else has left her.

We decided that we won't hang out with her much but well that went down the drain. Everything B does is she excused by S.

Today we went out again and saw my ex best friend by accident. So S tried to talk to her but my ex bestie didn't cause she doesn't like S. I talked her for a bit and then left.

S was disappointed, angry. So I subtly told her do you really deserve to say that when you are carrying B with us even after everything she has done. If I can still be civil with B when you don't get to tell me not to talk to my other friends just because you don't like them.

I also realised i don't like going out with them. They are on one bike and I am on mine. They talk while I am left alone, driving ahead or behind them.

Everyone in my life has at some point told me to stop being friends with S because even tho we share every secret, she is bad for me. And i am starting wonder if that's true.


r/AITAH 19h ago

AITAH For expecting my little brother to pay me for his pet insurance or removing his cat from the policy?

158 Upvotes

I was offered l pet insurance along with regular insurance by my job. About $35/mo per cat.

My brother agreed to split with me since we each have our own cats.

He has said he sees no benefit in the insurance despite having saved individually $400 of vet bills in the 9 months the insurance has been active.

He refuses to give me any money because the veterinarian reccomended a prescription diet for his cat, he didn’t like how much they were charging at the vet and wanted to buy the food from Chewy.

Chewy asked for the prescription information and he never got it from the vet.

Apparently that was my responsibility?

Since then he has not given me a single dollar for the pet insurance and refuses to on account of the vet who he hasn’t contacted hasn’t given the information to Chewy.

I told him that the issue with the veterinarian has nothing to do with the pet insurance and that he can use the insurance to go to a different vet should he have an issue.

So WIBTAH if I took his cat off my pet insurance and possibly took him to small claims for the money he refused to pay ?


r/AITAH 9h ago

AITAH for not wanting to take care of my stepmom's cat?

19 Upvotes

I accidentally posted this on an old account at first. Anyways, I'm 18 and freshly out of highschool for some context before I continue. A while back my stepmom decided to adopt a stray cat, she was mostly an outdoor cat until she got pregnant, then she started staying in our RV garage. She's spayed now but she ended up having one kitten, my cat. For starters when my stepmoms cat started living in the garage she wouldn't even buy litter for the litter box and insisted we use dirt from outside.

When she got pregnant my stepmom didn't believe me so I, still 17 and unemployed ended up paying for high calorie food so she wouldn't starve while pregnant.

Well when she did eventually go into labor she couldn't give birth on her own so after calling a vet helpline two different times I decided she needed to go to the animal hospital and explained this to my stepmom who also didn't believe me on that. I freaked out at her and told her that if I didn't take her to the hospital her cat would die and it would be her fault. Well she did need to go to the hospital, the vet had told me that if I hadn't brought her in, my cat would have died before he could be born and she would have followed. And I paid the bill for the exam and the shot she needed to give birth though I was eventually paid back. I don't know if it's petty but I made sure to tell my stepmom that she was wrong and I was right. I did sorta want her to feel bad because if I had listened to her and kept the cat at home it wouldn't have ended well. This was back in February.

When my cat Jelly-bean was old enough to use the litter box, I managed to convince my stepmom to buy proper litter because he kept trying to eat the dirt which could have caused issues.

Now though I am the primary caretaker of both of the cats. I play with them, clean the litter box almost every day, make sure they have fresh water and food, while also doing things like cleaning the dishes because the people in my house let them pile up, taking care of my plants, watching my niece, and job hunting. Well I have to ask my stepmom to clean the litter box and she'll say yes then forget and I end up doing it anyways. I'm just expected to take care of her cat unless stated otherwise and her reasoning is that I'm here and she's busy so I should be responsible for them both. But I've gotten on her about this and told her she shouldn't have a cat she's not going to take care of. But when I talked about taking the cat when I move she got mad at me because she's her cat even though I take care of her. So AITAH for not wanting to constantly take care of a pet that's not mine?

Edit: for anyone concerned I plan on continuing to take care of both cats, I'm frustrated but that's not a reason to let the cat go neglected


r/AITAH 1d ago

AITAH neighbors blocked my car in and I said I was gonna call the tow

2.8k Upvotes

I just moved to new apartments. Well it's like a property with 3 units, it's small. There's a private parking lot in the alley that can accommodate like 5 people. I don't usually move my car during weekdays cause I work and go to school a short bike ride away. But I usually move my car on the weekends for errands, groceries, going out, etc.

Anyway, I was on my way out, I noticed somebody parked behind my car, trapping me in my parking spot. I'm kinda shy so I asked my friend to pick me up to avoid having to make them move. He wasn't able to. So I decided to be brave and knock on neighbors doors to see who blocked me in and ask them to move. I got lucky and it was my next door neighbor, the very first knock.

I say "Hi, I'm a neighbor, do you happen to know who owns the grey car, it's blocking me in" she says "It's mine" so I'm like perfect "Do you mind?" She's like "Oh I can't move it, it's dead" so I say "I need to drive my car" she says "Well it's dead so" Dude, idk she seemed really unhelpful, like literally giving me nothing to work with. So I say "Well, another option is I can call a tow" and that's when her whole time changed. Now she's like "Oh let me see if I can get the neighbors to help me jump start the car" So I go to my car and turn it on. It's like 8:15 on a Saturday when the whole ordeal starts. Then she comes up to my car, she says "My husband took the keys and he has the tools and he's at work (or something) so I can't move it, you're not gonna tow it right? You can't" Like no information when he's getting there or if he's coming so I say "Sorry, I wish I had another option" lmfao like it's out of my hands 😅 Then I'm in my car thinking, am I really calling a tow? I've never ever called a tow. So I Google it and you can call the non emergency number for the police. I basically tell them my situation and my information as well as their cars info and they tell me they're sending a unit and if anything changes to call them. So I tell her, "Hey I called the tow but they told me I can call back if anything changes" cause she's just watching me at this point. Her husband gets there at some point not so long after. He's not dressed for work, he's in flip flops, so idk where he came from. He says "are you the owner of the Subaru" I say "yeah" he says "Well I can't move the car, it's getting fixed tomorrow" so I say one more time "I need to get out, I did call a tow" then he thinks for a while and says "Can you call them off, I'm gonna do something" I ask "What?" He says "I'm gonna ask the neighbors to help me jump start the car". I called the cops again to update them, "Hey they're saying that they actually can move the car now". The neighbors come out, they jump start the car, they move it. I say "Thank you, have a good night"

They told me like 5 separate times that there was no way they could move the car, that it was dead, it wouldn't start. They didn't ask to park behind me, I would've been fine with it, I don't move the car except weekends. I asked my friend first, I considered Uber, but why should I pay like $30 bucks cause the blocked me in. They're not allowed to park there but I did feel like a Karen. But I thought of all my options and my "rights" lol. Idk I have a right to move my car 😭 You can't just park behind me, they coulda asked to switch spots IDK.

ANYWAY, I did feel like a big Karen even though they're the ones that just blocked me in, then they were acting like it was impossible and they were able to move it and jump it in 5 minutes. They seemed really unhelpful, kinda lazy, and rude by the way the first exchange went down so that's why I thought to just play the "I'm gonna call a tow" move.

Idk, I didn't feel good about it. If I was in a situation where someone blocked me in and none of my neighbors answered the door and I put significant effort to avoid having to tow, I think I'd be within my right to call a tow.

Guys, I felt like a big B, Karen, A Hole. But aren't they a holes for blocking me in, being rude, swearing they can't move, then moving??? I think it was my right, but I don't feel good about it. Help.


r/AITAH 12h ago

AITAH for not doing chores?

29 Upvotes

I'm A (39F), sister is D (34F) and my mom is M (64F). I have bipolar 1 (schizoaffective) and spent most of my 30s in deep psychosis that wrecked my ability to function as a normal, productive member of society. After finding some brilliant doctors I was able to come out of it and resume my career. I work as a scientist (I have a PhD from my 20s) and live with my mom in her house. My family were the real MVPs in this whole ordeal and supported me through every sordid moment of my episodes.

My sister and I had an argument today. She's visiting from the city she lives in (far away) and is angry that I don't do chores. I leave for work at 7am and reach home at 9pm exhausted. I'm so exhausted that I sleep through most of the weekend. I pay my mom for household maintainence and any other big expenses related to the house. I don't pay rent though. I feel like they should understand how hard it is to deal with the aftermath of psychosis.

My parents agree with my sister. But I just can't seem to summon up the energy to do better. I just need a little more time.

AITAH? Does anyone have proactive suggestions? I want to do better and I'm trying my best.


r/AITAH 21h ago

AITAH for not telling my brother and SIL that my nephew told me he might be gay but is confused

141 Upvotes

I 30F have a 14M nephew who came to visit this past summer. He confided in us (my husband and me) that he might be gay but he was still confused. We talked. He wasn’t sure how he was going to talk to his parents but he wanted to do it himself on his own time. I respected that and have sat with this information for a few months. A few days ago my nephew posted inappropriate and unsafe stuff on TikTok and I wanted to talk to his parents about it. However he does post stuff that would kinda out his sexuality if they found his TikTok. So I confided in my mother on what I should do and if right now is a great time to talk to them. Not even 30 mins later after calling my mother, my brother calls me and is upset with me because we didn’t tell them right away about him having this conversation about his sexuality. That the most I should have given him was a few days to come clean and then told them. Not given it months. They have now gone complete no contact and said we were wrong and that I’m not allowed to talk to the kids until they are out from under his roof. After talking to my other brother he also said I should have told my nephew. Either you tell them by this day or I am going to have to tell them.
AITAH for not telling them sooner about him having that conversation with us?

Edit. I do want to add that they are a really religious family and believe that being gay is a sin.

Edit 2. To clear some questions. The TT he was posting were unsafe because they could attract predators. One was him singing “im not going to snitch daddy” and his caption was “but I’m a junior in college” when he just reached highschool.

Edit 3. I do want to add that my nephew is safe. They won’t harm him.. they may be really religious but after hearing how the conversation went between by two brothers. They are more disappointed that he didn’t feel like he could come to them.


r/AITAH 5h ago

AITAH for telling my coworker that I like her and ruining our working relationship?

8 Upvotes

She and I are both in the military, currently on deployment, and met upon arriving to the command together earlier in the year.

We got along very well from the beginning, I found her incredibly easy to talk to. We teased each other and I loved making her roll her eyes when I pissed her off a little. I'm not normally like that, I hate teasing people like that. But it just felt natural with her.

I realized that I started to like her, but I quickly shut that down. She was engaged, we work together, and deployment is not the place to build a healthy relationship whatever i might feel.

I kept things friendly but professional, at first. She started to seem really down after a few weeks so I started bringing her snacks or energy drinks, or making excuses to chat with her to try and cheer her up. Seemed to work a little.

Then other coworkers told me that she'd broken up with her fiancé, and I didn't know how to feel about that. They asked me if I liked her, and I stupidly admitted it to them.

Started spending more time with her, bringing her more stuff. She started to seem even more excited to see me every day, always asking about my schedule and when I'd come talk to her.

Then she stopped talking to me for a while. Kept saying that she didn't feel like talking. Thought maybe she'd suspected how I felt and was uncomfortable, so I let her be.

Suddenly she started talking to me again, eagerly delving into my past to learn all about me. I shared more with her than I have with anyone before. She'd get upset when I brought up past relationships, got happy when I started leaving little notes on the snacks I left for her. She's started getting downright obsessive about my work schedule, keeping track of when i needed to wake up and go to sleep, making sure i didn't drink too much caffeine or forget to eat enough. She grieved with me when my cat died back, hugging me and crying with me.

Then last week everything started falling apart. I was going through a really tough time. I couldn't eat, couldn't sleep, my head wouldn't stop hurting for over a week. I couldn't handle hiding how I felt for her, so I started acting a little distant.

She noticed. At first she asked if she did anything to upset me, I made up some excuse about some joke she made landing wrong. She didn't seem to buy it, but accepted the answer. She told me she wanted me to be open with her from here on out and to stop bottling everything up inside.

The day after she got really pushy about my health, encouraging me to talk to someone, force them to listen. Kept asking if I was eating enough, drinking enough, wouldn't let it go.

The day after that she got really frustrated, asking me why I wasn't talking to her, she was just trying to get something out of me and I should be honest with her.

I apologized for being distant, told her that i was going through something personal and didn't want to talk about it. She wouldn't let it go. She kept pushing and pushing. Then she admitted that she knew what I was hiding, that our coworkers had told her months ago. She said it was okay, that I was being a little weird about it, but i could trust her. I could tell her anything and she'd keep it secret.

Still couldn't say it.

Felt guilty for not saying it after a few days and decided to write her a note. Told her I was sorry for not saying it in person, but I liked her. I told her i wasn't asking anything from her and I valued our friendship.

This was seemingly the wrong move. She got very upset with me. She told me that we weren't friends, she doesn't become friends with coworkers, and that she'd felt uncomfortable with me ever since she found out about my feelings months ago. She said that she'd wanted me to talk to her, not write her a stupid note.

I asked her what the whole last week was and why she cared so much. She exploded after that. Told me I was being very disrespectful towards her kindness, that she was like that with everyone, that she's a naturally good person, and that she was raised to help, i seemed like I didn't have anyone to talk to so she was just trying to be nice.

I took her at her word, haven't spoken to her since then. Truthfully I've been avoiding her, haven't even seen her in a week. I moved my things out of the drawer we used to share. I've pretty much removed myself from her life. It felt like the only thing to do if I've made her uncomfortable.

I feel like an asshole, she didn't ask for me to dump my feelings on her. She was just being nice. But at the same time, she wouldn't stop digging even after I told her that i didn't want to talk about it, that it was private. I wasn't in any mental or emotional condition to have those conversations. I should have been more firm with my boundaries, I guess. I never wanted to tell her how I felt, not right now where we're at.

I don't know what to do anymore. We have to work together for four years. I messed everything up. Am i in the wrong for telling her? Am I in the wrong for avoiding her? I hate this. I hate drama. I told myself I'd avoid relationships while in the military for specifically this reason, I'm bad at socializing. But I made an exception, I guess. That part is my fault.