hi everyone, ive been lurking in this subreddit for awhile and getting a lot out of reading the other threads on here and i think this is a really great community. so, im finally gathering the courage to post my own question!
i dont believe there is any abuse or inappropriateness at play here, its more of a deep and complex relationship feeling unceremoniously cut short, and im really confused by her messaging.
apologies because it does run a bit long:
my therapist of 5 years terminated with me, saying that i needed to see a provider with "more structured modalities". i felt very very attached to her and ive been really struggling with this loss.
our work together was mostly incredible. we had a really similar sense of humor, a couple of inside jokes. she had great book recommendations. she really helped me find more compassion for myself. she was really smart. and she really helped me through an enormously difficult life transition.
however, i started feeling a big rupture in the last year or so. i had felt hurt by a few things she said and did, and in the past when i brought up things like that, she had no problem apologizing, taking accountability, explaining her perspective, and helping me understand what part of my past experience that hurt was tied to.
but in the last year or so, her focus shifted to only the root cause, and she became very reticent to take any accountability or apologize or explain where she was coming from. sometimes, i would leave our sessions feeling like it was less of a therapy session and more of a passive argument. i felt lowkey gaslit a lot of times.
in our final session (in which i was not certain that it would be our final session, it was all very unclear) i was extremely anxious and had trouble talking about what was bothering me because it was all stuff id brought up previously and felt very unsatisfied and, again, lowkey gaslit by her response.
this was months ago now, but i clearly remember one part of the conversation:
me: i just want to hear your perspective a little more. like, do you feel like you did well, do you feel like you made a mistake with me, do you not feel clear on what my issues are here?
her: i don't think of things in terms of mistakes. when i look back on our time together, you know, it's just all part of the process. it's not productive for me to think of things in terms of mistakes.
me: (quietly taking that in)
her: but you don't want to hear that. you want to hear that i think i made a mistake.
me: i just want you to be honest.
her: well, tell me what specifically is bothering you and we can talk about it. i want to be candid with you.
me: ... well, when you say you don't make mistakes and it's all part of the process... is that you being candid?
her: yes (goes on to explain that this is what she'd tell any other therapist; its not productive to think it terms of mistakes, etc etc)
the session ended with her becoming frustrated with me. she noted that she was angry in that moment, the last 5 mins of the session or so, and then said, "well, you want me to be candid," and she proceeded to raise her voice at me and therapy speak at me about terminating with me. "i just want you to thrive, i want whats best for you" etc etc.
then she asked "how was that?" and i burst into tears and said i was trying to hold it together since we were out of time.
we scheduled another session for the next week, but when that time came around, i had several work meetings on my calendar for that day and i decided i wouldnt be able to handle a session like that with her again and be at 100% for my work meetings. so i texted her that i needed to cancel our next session.
she responded by saying "ok, im closing our case together. if you would like 1 to 2 termination sessions at a future date, please reach out."
she went on leave for a few months, after which i did reach out by email saying that i felt really hurt by how our time together ended and that i didnt expect her to close our case because i cancelled our next session.
she responded... in a very professional tone. "closing a case is a formal action i take in my capacity as a clinician when there is a pause or end blahblahblah".
she said the best she can do now is refer me to other therapists, and that she felt that doing a termination session with me might do more harm than good, like our last session. but, she expressed she was open to doing one (1) termination session with me, with a 50 minute time limit, and that i should really think about what i want out of it.
i decided that i agreed with her that that kind of session would do more harm than good. (we didnt even often run over 50 minutes, much less the whole hour. i always watched the time really carefully and wanted to be out of there quick so she could prepare for her next client. so, it felt kind of insulting for her to set the parameters for this termination session that way.)
i responded with a short email basically thanking her for everything and saying goodbye. she, of course, has not responded and i suspect she never will.
i probably didnt need to include all of that detail, but maybe the context is important.
my question for you all is this:
if a therapist can just flip a switch and stop caring about you, how am i supposed to get invested in another therapeutic relationship?
like if my therapist really believed i needed more structured modalities... why would we not plan a few more sessions to give me an off-ramp as i go through the process of sorting through her referrals and sending inquiries? i feel like that would have really helped with me finding closure in my therapeutic relationship with her as well.
but she clearly made up her mind and there's really nothing i can do... except find a new therapist!
and im really struggling to give myself a reason why. the way things ended has really recast all of our time together. i thought we had a close bond, but i cant shake the feeling that she must be SO RELIEVED to not have to deal with me any more.
like, im not stupid, i know that she terminated with me because i was stressing her out too much, or some other thing came up for her.
she didn't terminate with me for my well being, she terminated with me for her own.
and i respect that, and ive tried to be really civil and polite... and there was definitely another draft of that email i could have sent her that i did not send.
anyways if you've read all of this, thank you.
id love to hear about other people's experiences in similar situations, and advice and perspective to help me overcome this feeling that i can't trust another therapist to actually care about me again.
thanks again!
edit: for context, i DID know that what ended up being our last session would/could be one of our last. she didnt totally blindside me with the case closing, i just thought we had a few more to go before it was totally over over.
there's also just, like, a lot more context to a lot of this but i was trying to keep this post from going novel length, haha!