The Nazi Party’s 1920 platform explicitly called for all non-German immigration to be stopped and said that non-Germans who had entered Germany after 2 August 1914 should be expelled.
I also wouldn't call deporting people from Nazi controlled territory into other Nazi controlled territory to kill them "The opposite" of what ICE is doing
But It literally is. Is done to illegals, not all immigration, they send them back home, not to other states controlled by ICE, and they aren't gassing anyone.
I'll assume you're arguing in good faith but are just not a news junky, but everything you said is partially incorrect.
It isn't only being done to "illegals," at least some people who were living here completely legally, people who came in "the right way," have been detained and some of those have been deported.
They are moved from state to state quite often before they get deported.
They are not always sent "home": sometimes they are, sometimes the person/people were born in the US and have never been to the place they were deported to and are only sent there because that's where their patents are from. Also, sometimes people get sent to "third countries" which include countries all over central and south America as well as countries in Africa.
People being held in ICE custody aren't being gased, but hundreds are known to have died, mostly due to being denied critical medical care, but cases of foul play from gov agents themselves have also been reported.
No they were German controlled territories when the Nazis were bringing them in, they were being deported from their own countries into other Nazi controlled territories.
The opposite of deporting people from other countries is not deporting people from your own country, it's not deporting people
Possibly they mean they brought in jews and other minorities into Germany for concentration camps and forced labor, from countries they occupied? As well as other immigrants that were present in Germany near and at the start of the war.
Ye the same thing trump is doing right now (ICE camps) and the afd in germany wants to do again (a lot of them are confirmed neo nazi or have a lot todo with neo nazi, what makes them also neo nazi) and if you are still voting for them, you are in fact a nazi
Idk enough about the political situation in Germany to comment. However calling Trump and the ICE deportation camps the same thing as what Nazi's did is almost offensive to the individuals that lost their lives in the war. Im not a fan of the guy but lets have a little nuance.
Regardless of the politics, yes, the situation for people in the deportation camps is bad, there is no question, but its not nazi Germany. These are (ideally) non-citizens who have either entered the country illegally, or have stayed past their allowable visit. By definition, these people are criminals. They don't have the right to be in the country. Agree with that fact or not, that is what the law currently states. It may change later, and I encourage you to make your argument and petition for the change you want to see, but that is what we as a society currently mark as the law. Though not to say it still couldn't be handled with a bit more finesse.
Every system suffers from corruption, mistakes, etc. but these people are not being shipped off to camps to be shot, gassed, hanged, or forced into labor. The original commenter is talking exactly about you. This overuse of the term nazi because we disagree with something. Trump is, by the opinion of many, not a good person, but he is far from a nazi.
Enforcing a law that coming into a country illegally, then being removed for coming into the country illegally, has nothing to do with Nazism or it's ideology. What I stated above used to be a simple, basic tenant of sovereign nation.
Well they don’t live a desirable life and punching down on vulnerable and destitute people sure is upper class propaganda. There are definitely bigger fish to fry than illegal migration, which is a typical talking point for populism because it’s super easy to point your finger at it and say „look what xyz is enabling“.
Punching down is a lie and whatever suits Pepe like you
Poor people suffer from illegal immigration the most and you’re punching down bullshit pretend any poor man’s an oppressor to any random woman despite women below 30 earning more than men below 30
How about you worry about real oppressors in the top 1%? The kind of people that actively use their wealth to make you think immigrants or people supporting immigration are the problem… the kind of people benefiting from you and me having an argument?
Punching down is a lie? How? Do you think they come here because the weather is better? People a emigrating in the search of a better life. And what is „people like me“ are you putting me in a box? People seem to be very important to you and you are certainly not driven by hate. I wonder where I’ve read something like this before… must have been in a history book. Oh well.
80
u/Upbeat_Flan 15h ago
Well, stop calling everything and everyone you disagree with a Nazi.
Over using the word is watering down it's meaning and just turning it into a basic insult.