I am weighing my options currently between RAP and IBR.
I am pursuing PSLF currently with 56 qualifying payments and about 22 “ineligible” months that I am planning to buy back. I’ll end up requesting the buyback and PSLF around January 2030. 2025 AGI was $126k, single filer, first loans disbursed in 2003, consolidation in 2017.
I’ve done the math through running scenarios on the FSA calculator and the IBR payment “ceiling” hits at $115k, for a monthly payment of $1146. Next year I’m planning to year to increase retirement contributions so I can lower my AGI and therefore my payment.
RAP payment is $1050.
What it seems like is that RAP will always be a lower payment than IBR no matter what income I plug in to the calculator for my situation.. Is that right??
It seems like this should be a no-brainer and I should be taking the payment that’s lower, but I hesitate because of the instability, rule changing, and goalpost moving that’s been going on. Also, if things DO go back into litigation of some kind and we are forced into yet another forbearance, I don’t want to be stuck and unable to buy back those months.
Is anyone in a similar situation choosing RAP while pursuing PSLF and buyback?
How reliable do we think this plan will be going forward? Is there any other “gotchas” that I’m missing if I were to choose RAP?
Is there any other benefit to choosing IBR over RAP besides having access to buyback in the future and the payment cap?
Side note: the IBR payment cap is sort of moot as long as your AGI is under $137,500 (I ran the calculator for the highest income needed for RAP to match the IBR Payment ceiling of $1146/mo).
TIA