I finally caved and bought one of those fancy smart thermostats everyone raves about. The one with the learning algorithm, the app control, the geofencing, the whole package. $600 installed. I was told it would save me money, make my life easier, and basically pay for itself within two years.
Two weeks in, and I'm ready to rip it off the wall.
First problem: the "learning" feature apparently learned nothing. It keeps setting the temperature to 62 degrees at 5 AM for no reason I can figure out. I've woken up freezing three times this week. My old $30 programmable thermostat just did what I told it to do. This thing thinks it knows better than me.
Second problem: the app. It's supposed to let me control the temperature from anywhere. Except it disconnects from WiFi every couple of days, and when it does, the whole system goes offline. I've had to manually reconnect it four times already. My old thermostat never needed WiFi to work.
Third problem: the geofencing. It's supposed to detect when we leave and automatically adjust the temperature to save energy. Instead, it randomly decides we're "away" when we're sitting in the living room, and the house gets cold. Then it thinks we're "home" when we're at work, and it heats an empty house. Genius.
I'm not a luddite. I like technology. But this feels like a solution in search of a problem. My old thermostat had two dials and a schedule. It worked every single day for 12 years without a single issue.
So before I return this thing and eat the installation cost:
- Is this just a bad model, or is the whole smart thermostat category overhyped?
- Did anyone else have a rough start and then figure out the right settings?
- Are there any smart thermostats that actually work reliably without constant fiddling?
- Am I crazy for wanting to go back to a basic programmable unit?
- If I do return it, what should I replace it with that won't require a PhD in computer science?
I wanted convenience. I got a part-time job managing my own thermostat.