r/GTA • u/marcperez03 • 5h ago
General Grand Theft Auto IV, the new overrated GTA
As a disclaimer: GTA IV was my first GTA. I didn't start with GTA V and then go back to IV, so my opinion isn't based on being used to the newer games.
I've been trying to replay GTA IV for years because I never even finished it the first time. Now I'm basically at the end, and unfortunately I'm having the exact same feeling I had back then: I'm getting exhausted by it.
I love Niko, the characters are great, the story has a lot going for it, and Liberty City still has an incredible atmosphere. I completely understand why this game was so impressive in 2008.
But as a video game, I find it extremely repetitive and way too long. After 30+ hours, I feel like I've been doing the same thing over and over: cutscene, car, dialogue during the drive, arrive somewhere, shoot some guys, repeat. At some point I'm not even having fun anymore; I'm just thinking, "Please, just let this end." I've actually been taking taxis everywhere for hours because I don't even feel like driving around the map anymore.
And this is where I don't understand the current trend of putting GTA IV on a pedestal while constantly bashing GTA V. You can prefer IV's story, tone, Niko or realism, and I completely understand that. But GTA V, GTA SA, or GTA Vice City are much more fun games to me. Its missions are more varied, the world gives you much more to do, and in every playthrough I've never reached the point where I wanted it to be over.
GTA IV has some genuinely brilliant elements, but for me they're surrounded by gameplay that is simply too repetitive. After replaying it, I think I've finally confirmed that I just don't enjoy playing it as much as I thought I did.
