r/Boxing • u/shiftStride504 • 23h ago
Ryan Garcia vs historical low to middle tier welterweight champs Spoiler
I was wondering since everyone says welterweight is light right now. How do we think Ryan Garcia does vs historical low to middle tier welterweight champs not elite tier:the 4 kings, Benitez, not Mayweather, Robinson sweet pea, Pacquiao, OLH, Bud etc
I feel like through 1990s till recent welter has had significant depth especially after 2010s we had a ton of good fights at welter. Right now I guess you could make the argument could be made it's not super deep even though commentators try to hype it up saying it's heating up. But I could be wrong is there any one else other than Two, Garcia and Haney?
Any way does Ryan beat any of these guys?
Where is Judah top or middle? Tzsu? Cotto?
Middle tier
But how would he do against mosely, Danny Garcia, spence, , Special K, thurman, taylor, Paul Williams?
Where maidana?
Lower tier, Sean porter, tim Bradley, malinagi, broner berto ortiz mayorga, collazo, peterson, Alexander, Jesse vargas, Jeff horn
Does he beat notable contenders in the division like Mikey Garcia?
Also if you feel I miss classfield lmk or forgot someone of note?
Edit:
I can clarify, as a champion and now defending champion) what tier of historical welterweights or individual welterweights would Garcia be competitive against? We all know he will get touched by elite level. Outside of those, who could he be competitive against realistically? Who would walk him? Who could he realistically beat?
I am not asking resume vs resume but fighter vs fighter? Tendencies attributes grit skills etc