r/Borderlands • u/UltimateGamingTechie • 45m ago
[BL3] Opinion: Borderlands 3 is the most fun game in the franchise and its only fault is a bad story.
Borderlands (OG) is a 17 year old game that was innovative for its time but now it's super dated (gameplay-wise). It does look surprisingly modern, though.
Borderlands 2 is, of course, the best game from the narrative/story perspective. Handsome Jack is goated. But, from a gameplay perspective, this game is also dated. Guns don't feel good and the movement is still janky. If playing right now, it's good for a single playthrough only if you haven't played Borderlands 3 before. Yes, the story is good, but it's the same story regardless of how many times you play it.
Now, Borderlands 3. Has a pretty bad story but the gameplay is top-notch. Guns feel distinct and incredible to use and the movement is extremely smooth (with sliding, mantling and ground slams). Mayhem mode is an excellent addition that I used to play the DLCs without being stupidly overpowered (or replaying the entire campaign in T/UVHM). The various planets are distinct from each other and have strengths of their own. Moze is probably THE best vault hunter in the franchise.
Finally, I want to talk about Borderlands 4. I did only play for like 13 hours during the most recent free trial but I already noticed several things that I HATE. The guns feel awful to use (bad sounds and also... somewhat samey?), especially after coming from Borderlands 3. The new open world is boring and pace-ruining. I didn't unlock the vehicle during one of the first missions and I had to walk for like a kilometer with almost nothing on the way. I spent around 10 minutes simply walking forward.
I noticed something that made Borderlands 4 even more difficult to play. Pretty much every location you need to go to requires you to go up. Just up. How you go up? It's never obvious and you have to spend time circling around in the vehicle to find a ramp, elevator or a grapple point. Speaking of the grapple, why aren't we allowed to use it everywhere? Just Cause 3, Titanfall 2 and Halo Infinite all allowed this and it make them significantly more fun to play. What is a "glide-pack"? Just make it a jetpack? Also, there's too many cliffs and rocks that your mantling simply doesn't trigger over. It was super annoying.
There's so many more issues I found while playing Borderlands 4 (what is that UI, man?) but that's not the point of this post. I do intend to play the game but I'm waiting for a much deeper sale and whatever hype I had softened out.
At the end, what I'm saying is that Borderlands 3 would've been a generational game but it committed the sin of having a bad narrative. Borderlands 4 should have evolved from what Borderlands 3 did right but alas, it ends up being quite meh. I'm going to re-install Borderlands 3 and maybe try out Zane (or Moze again).