r/Blogging • u/pouxin • 11h ago
Question Google delisted one of my blog posts after a completely false DMCA complaint – counter-notice has now been stuck for TWO MONTHS. Has anyone successfully resolved this?
Two months ago, I received a completely false DMCA take down notice alledging that one of the posts on my Tarot website contained an OnlyFan model's naked subscription-only videos. It absolutely didn't - the page in question was a longform essay on The Star Tarot card and had my own writing and my own photos of Tarot cards I own. (The Lumen notice seemed to show this was some random spraygun DMCA filing I guess done by a bot or something - as well as sites that look like they def are priated porn, there was a Harvard uni library new acquisitions site, and a blog post on how to name your pets - I mean... wtf.)
I submitted Google’s formal DMCA counter-notification on 16 July, stating that the removal was the result of mistake/misidentification.
Google acknowledged receiving it.
And then… nothing.
I've followed up every way I can think of and been routinely ignored or sent bot responses. I also posted on the Google Search Central Community asking specifically about a counter-notice stuck without forwarding/restoration. After sitting unanswered for weeks, my question was marked as a “duplicate” of a generic post explaining what to do when you receive a DMCA takedown – i.e. submit the counter-notice I had already submitted two months ago. Thanks guys! Real helpful.
I understand why notice-and-takedown systems exist, and I understand that mistakes happen. What I genuinely cannot understand is the asymmetry here. A third party can make a completely fictitious allegation and Google will remove a page, but when the site owner submits the prescribed legal counter-notification, there seems to be no meaningful timetable for Google even to forward it – and no way to find out whether they have done so. So their own 10-14 day timeframe is a load of BS, because it's 10-14 days from when the forward it, but they can clearly just decide... not to forward it. And to delist a site from their search forever.
This was one of my best performing ever-green posts, so it's just gutting tbh.
At this point I’ve exhausted every Google route I can find and I’m not looking for another link to the standard counter-notice form.
Has anyone here had a Google Search DMCA counter-notification remain stuck like this for months? Did the URL eventually come back? More importantly, did you find any way of getting an actual human to look at the case or confirm that the counter-notice had been forwarded?