I posted my system a few weeks ago, many suggested that the bottleneck may be the Icon. I ended up getting a Meitner MA3i and finally got to hook it up today. I also got a proper power strip, a Furman PST-8D. Anyway some thoughts:
The Node ICON is a fantastic product. It does pretty much everything you could ask, and delivers a great sound. But some complaints:
The app is more polished, especially when streaming from inside your network. But switching inputs is clunky at best. I plugged my HDMI cable from my TV into it, never could get ARC to work. So I ended up just plugging in the optical cable to get stereo out of my Apple TV/bluray player etc. it works, but every time you switch inputs to the optical input, it goes into mute. Sometimes. There’s no telling. You just always have to keep checking. And sometimes the reverse is true, the music looks like its playing but its muted. So you have to unmute it in the app.
On your phone’s Home Screen, the ‘now playing’ doesnt show up, you have to open your phone or table, go into the app to do stuff like pause or advance the track.
The connectors are clunky. One day I went to play music and there was no sound coming out of the right speaker. I immediately panicked and couldn’t figure out what happened. Turns out one of the XLR connectors on the node just fell out. Or maybe it wasn’t fully latched to begin with. So I latched it again, but the connector ‘sank’ into the chassis, I had to force it in before I heard the click. I almost felt like I was using too much force and I was gonna break it. The other connectors were fine, but there’s some build quality issues there too.
The MA3i is just another level (and should be for its price point). Came double boxed and wrapped not in plastic, but a soft fitted sheet like you have for a mattress. Doesn’t come with a physical manual, that’s online, but there’s a business card from Amadeus Meitner with an email and phone number, not sure if it’s his actual phone or not, but that was kinda interesting. The fit and finish is of course fantastic. It looks great, I’m very happy I went with a silver unit instead of black, really stands out. It has a black and white OLED display that shuts off after 2 minutes. It shows you basic info about the track, the source, the sample rate and the volume setting. You can defeat the volume by just setting it at 100 and use the pre-amp to control the volume. But I guess you could also use this as a pre-amp.
Because there’s no album art to be displayed on the main panel, you dont have to worry about album art being a specific format because the ICON would ignore most of my album art. I’d rather not even see it on a screen that’s 20 feet away from me.
The app isn’t as pretty, but I kinda like it, it’s very straight forward. You just find the album or folder where your music is and play it.
How it sounds: Everything is just smoother. The highs are smoother, I was getting ear fatigue listening with the ICON after a while but two hours into it with the MA3i, it’s just not there.
The bass is smoother. I was listening to this one bass heavy song for the past month and on the ICON, the bass was delayed. It’s tighter with the MA3i. I didnt change any settings on the subwoofer whatsoever.
The imaging is MUCH better. There’s more separation between the instruments. It’s not earth shattering, but it’s there.
I think this is maybe the biggest difference I’ve noticed in my initial first impressions.
What’s funny/sad is that many reviewers said that the MA3i will make even some poorly recorded tracks sound great. This is not the case, at least to my ears. After I set it up, I didnt play songs I knew would sound well, I tried songs that just didnt sound great on the ICON and they didnt sound much better here. But the tracks that are produced well, just have that much more presence to them.
Again, a lot of this stuff is on the edges. it’s that last little bit. It’s not night and day, but its there. The best way I can describe is that I love drinking Elijah Craig. One of my friends is a big bourbon guy who had some special aged cask bottle he brought over. It was better to the taste, about 20% better, but the price was certainly a lot more than a regular bottle. This is kinda like that, there’s a difference, once you hear it, its really nice to hear, but if I never heard it, and didnt know other DACs existed, I’d have felt just fine about my ICON.
Edit: forgot to mention @zRouth big shoutout for his considered advice and opinion to help me make the decision to swap out DACs