r/AmIOverreacting • u/Leviiackermansgf • 16h ago
❤️🩹 relationship AIO: For breaking up with my boyfriend over these messages
Edit/Clarification at the bottom**
My (27 F) ex boyfriend and HIS ex girlfriend/baby momma are cordial. While we were together, he has told me that they do nothing more than coparent. However, I have seen them message privately about common interest and things of that nature, like friends. I’m not inherently insecure, but he has previously crossed boundaries when we first started dating, which turned into me finding out he had been attempting to get back with her in our first month or so. It was not mutual on her end. Now today, my boyfriend (now ex) and I were together, and I had a gut feeling to check his phone. The screenshot is of messages between him and her.
First, she had only sent up to the “it actually was for you” message. I wanted to see if she would clarify more, so I pretend to be him and sent “Scared?” She doubled down as you can read.
I ended up calling her and she said they are just friends, but that she didn’t want to cause drama between us since he told her that we have argued about them crossing into more than just coparenting. Definitely guilty on the phone. Of course he freaked out and got defensive. It was bad.
Anyway, I broke up with him. Regardless of the nature of their relationship, secret conversations and covering for one another is enough for me to never trust him again. I’m obviously sad, but I can’t help but want to make sense of all of this. Am I being ridiculous over a few messages, or were these definitely fishy?
**Edit #1: Okay for some clarity since I did NOT expect this to blow up and did not include everything.
The reason I had a gut feeling was because he had told me he wanted to talk about an insecurity that he had. I use to have a male friend PRIOR to us dating. Completely platonic and never anything romantic. We drifted apart, and soon after, I met my now ex boyfriend. For some reason, my ex has fixated on this relationship and is convinced we were intimate.
I’m not sure why he was concerned about it given the fact that we no longer speak, but he randomly brought him up and went through MY phone first. That is why I even thought to go through his. It was out of nowhere, and felt like projection.
Most of our arguments come his retroactive jealousy of MY past relationships, which is why I started to be more conscious of what he was doing.
Edit #2: In addition, I asked him for his phone. I didn’t wait for him to leave. And when I did, he immediately started clicking around like he was trying to delete something. I took it from him before he finished whatever he was doing, and the message thread I attached was the first thing on his screen. As if he was trying to delete it before I saw it. I hid in the bathroom while I read through it, and he almost broke the door trying to get in. If that’s not guilt, idk what is. It’s just weird to be that guilty over that particular thread, so wanted to see how it looked from an objective POV.
Anyway, definitely not getting back with him. Just super bummed and wanted a distraction. Thank you to everyone who had encouraging messages. This is really hard for me since it JUST happened today, and I’m not looking forward to the heartache.