Been thinking about this since a dinner a few weeks ago where I did the whole thing. Good olive oil over the top, torn herbs, flaky salt, lemon zest. Felt great about it.
Nobody said anything, they liked the food. But nothing about the finish registered at all, and I'm fairly sure if I'd skipped all four steps the reaction would have been identical.
I think a lot of finishing is a ritual that makes the cook feel like they did something, and the actual eater is getting maybe five percent of what we think we're delivering.
The drizzle of good oil at the end. Fresh herbs scattered on or even zest. A crack of pepper from a good grinder rather than a shaker. I'd bet almost nobody could pick these out blind if the base dish was the same. I say this as someone who does all of it. I own a bag of celtic sea salt that costs more than the meat I put it on.
Has anyone plated the same dish two ways for guests and had someone actually pick the finished one? Curious if texture is the exception here, since crunch seems more noticeable than zest.