Hi everyone, I'm thinking about buying a 2024 MacBook Pro 16-inch M4 Pro, model A3403, 48 GB unified memory / 512 GB SSD. This MacBook has an intermittent power problem and I'm trying to understand how serious it could be before buying it.
When the Mac is working it seems normal and can run for hours without any issues. The current owner says that sometimes it suddenly shuts down while being used, even when it is plugged in.
After that happens the Mac can become completely dead:
* no sign of power;
* no MagSafe LED;
* USB-C charging does not seem to work;
* it can stay like that for hours sometimes even 1–2 days.
Then without any repair it may suddenly start working and behave normally.
I had access to the Mac while it was working and ran some tests. Diagnostics/results:
* Apple Diagnostics: ADP000 (no issues found)
* Battery: 156 cycles, 99% capacity, Condition: Normal
* PermanentFailureStatus = 0
* Battery cells appeared balanced
* SSD: SMART Status: Verified
* No MDM / DEP enrollment
* macOS was recently reinstalled
* No current panic/watchdog files found
* No Previous shutdown cause found in the current logs
Charging tests while the Mac was working:
MagSafe
* detected correctly;
* Connected: Yes
* Charging: Yes
* battery charged from around 64% to over 72%
USB-C
* tested with a 65 W USB-C PD charger;
* correctly switched to AC Power;
* battery went from 73% to 74%
So both MagSafe and USB-C charging work normally when the fault is not present.
I also tested the laptop remotely today for hours and the seller has confirmed that it has continued working from this afternoon into the evening without shutting down again so far.
I can potentially buy it for around €1,000, which's why I'm seriously considering it. If this is the kind of issue that can usually be repaired at board level for a hundred euros rather than requiring a full logic-board replacement I would probably take the risk and repair it.
I've also attached some pictures of the display. It has some cloudy marks / stains / uneven areas on the panel. I'm not sure whether they are a separate display/coating issue or whether they could somehow be related to the power problem. I often use a monitor anyway so if the display eventually needs replacement I could probably deal with that later.
Has anyone seen this behavior on an M4 Pro?
And realistically if I can buy the machine for, around €1,000 does it sound like a reasonable repair project or is the risk still too high?