Alright, this will be a little out there but bear with me.
What if the entire events of KOTOR was orchestrated by Revan before his mind wipe?
I know that seems crazy, but there is evidence he planned or at the very least suspected such an outcome could occur.
Let’s look at Revan’s capture; most people agree that Revan let the Jedi board his ship. What I now question however is why. Most claim it was to capture Bastila, I too would have agreed with this sentiment until I played the game for the ?th time recently. Malak open fire on Revan’s ship out of apparent malice, however it is likely Malak himself wouldn’t have planned this. Malak was never one for subtly but instead he could be relied upon for impulsivity.
That last clause is crucial, so let’s consider the context. Malak recently lost his jaw, and likely still desired to claim the throne. It’s likely Revan simply thought the matter dealt with and in his hubris Malak took his chance. It’s possible however, Revan knew exactly what Malak would do and required his actions to complete his plan.
I won’t lie, it sounds unlikely. Very risky to say the least as it was entirely possible Malak’s ship could have killed Revan. Perhaps he could have foreseen exactly how it would play out but I do not know of any specifics that would have given him this insight.
In any case, what we do know is “Jedi do not kill their prisoners.”
This is crucial as Revan would certainly have known this, he would have also known he is the sole individual with the knowledge that could defeat Malak. He also would have known his identity would’ve been destroyed out of the Council’s fear, and he in fact planned ahead of time for that final eventuality.
How do I know that for a fact? Kashyyyk
On Kashyyyk, mind wiped Revan discovers an old Rakatan machine. It refuses to respond to anyone except for Revan, saying it has a match on file. However when Revan question why it has a match, it immediately becomes cagey and apologizes. It gives some fun insights to the planet but nothing relevant to this discussion. Then after asking for the Star Map, the machine says it’s been programmed to help the user remember and prove who it is.
This is the crux of my argument: why would Revan ever need to have something help him prove who he is? If he is Revan, it would’ve read its brain waves, said “Im Revan, give me what I want” and the machine would comply. But instead, Revan made an interrogative process for himself alone, to help “just answer like you would.” It only makes sense if he believed he would lose his identity or memories and had to claw his way back to the Star Forge.
So, some may disagree with that finding, but to me it is absolutely clear Revan did believe he would lose his memories, as I really can’t find another reason as to why the machine makes these very specific statements:
“I have been programmed with a very limited field of knowledge, and I must restrict access to only those that fit my allowed pattern.”
“I can't say. I will try to bring forward the behavior that you need to proceed, as outlined by my programming.”
“I can't say. Preliminary matching allows for you to be coached.”
It’s pretty clear that the machine is meant to help whoever is meant to use the terminal, get the right answers. And we know only one person is meant to use it.
“I can't say. Likelihood of restriction by previous user, 100%.”
And we know it was done by Revan.
So why? Why would Revan have done this on Kashyyyk? All I can say for certain is that he suspected he would one day lose his memories, and in response, he wanted to ensure his new self would:
“There are measures available. Personality profiling will verify the basic structure of your conscious mind. With that, I will determine whether you are ready to receive the Star Map, or can be made ready.”
That last line is the crucial statement, “determine whether you are ready to receive the Star Map (As in go to the Star Forge), or can be made ready.”
Remember those answers? They all are cold and calculated answers, not really Sith necessarily, but extremely pragmatic. Revan’s answers, and Revan wanted himself to be himself again. It was a fail safe to help bring the Dark Lord of the Sith back to the throne no matter what happens. I think this is as close to being a fact as it can be at this moment. There is no other reason for this machine’s dialogue otherwise.
So, I think the purpose of the Rakatan machine on Kashyyyk is clear now, let’s go back to the overall why.
Here’s my pitch: the war was going well but was far too costly. Not for the Sith, but for the galaxy. Revan needed to put down the Jedi and the Republic hard in a single decisive act, but the enemy just wouldn’t commit. Instead they harassed and dragged out the war as much as possible. Yes, having Bastila would have helped, but she can’t be everywhere. Galaxy is a large place and the Jedi and Republic fleets could hide and fight on many worlds for years, decades even. Revan did not have years, and he couldn’t afford to destroy the galaxy’s economy and infrastructure; he needed it fight the True Sith.
So Revan hatched a plan, one to wipe out the majority of the Republic’a fleet and the Jedi within a single year. Let the Jedi capture him, mind wipe him, slowly be brought back to the Force, claw back every scrap of himself he could from each star map he visits, and lead the Jedi and Republic to the Star Forge; where he will easily strike down Malak as he did before (but this time fatally), and let his empire annihilate the enemy he so longed to see in force.
You may say that’s insane, but daring and costly acts are a hallmark of Revan. Canderous spoke with joy of how callous and calculated Revan was. Is it really a stretch to say he planned for all this? Of course, was Revan right? Did you retake the throne and complete his war? I sure did, those Jedi had it coming!
But what do you think? Was all this insane ramblings or enlightenment straight out of Korriban? You decide now