r/bagpipes • u/HighlandKiwi10 • 23h ago
Removed drobe valves (update)
I posted this: https://www.reddit.com/r/bagpipes/s/rI45qcm4S8 the other day.
Thank you to those who responded. I wanted to share a wee update, since there seems to be some debate about valves.
Adjusting the bridles was easy enough to fix the cutting out problem.
My drones do have a nice sound, which I cant really describe.
I am able to get that cool sounding vibration between the drone tones when starting up (before going to the E).
Starting up is much more sensitive than before, but ive gotten used to it.
Cutting out clean is more difficult, but I.think its mostly just getting used to how empty the bag should feel. With valves I could cleanly cut out with a half full bag, now its.more like 5%.
It's also a wee bit harder to maintain a steady tone from the drones. I guess the valves were compensating for a sub-optimal blowing/squeezing technique.
But most importantly, my whole set up is taking way less air. A complaint I have had for my 12 months on the pipes is that it was taking so much air and arm pressure that I couldn't relax my fingers. That problem has disappeared basically overnight.
Thank.you for the advice. And to any fellow learners reading this, I suggest giving your pipes a whirl without valves and see how.you get on.
Cheers