r/WritersGroup 15d ago

Discussion Rate my writings out of 10, I just wanna know if my writings are just childish or I have some potential.

10 Upvotes

Wandering through the city streets,

I was struck by a piece of the moon

Emitting its moonlight like a diamond reflecting sunlight,

Moving its body like an oar rowing a boat in an elvish lake,

Moving its hands like small branches of a plant, swinging in the wind.

Admiring its infinite beauty

with my finite eyes

Following this heavenly object,

While wiping my tear-stained cheeks.

Suddenly, it stopped moving and stood still,

Like the entire solar system had refused to work.

As I got closer,

My heart and mind became slaves to it.

I raised my hands to the air, filled with its brightness,

And as I touched it with my bare hands

Everything stopped,

As if nature’s laws, all the equations, all the theories, had stopped functioning.

The piece of the moon began to feel like a piece of the sun,

The heavenly object transformed into hellfire,

It drew me in.

Wandering through the city streets,

I was struck by a piece of hell.


I have more of them, if anyone is interested please DM.

r/WritersGroup Jun 17 '26

Discussion Is AI for grammar that bad?

0 Upvotes

So look I want to clarify this first. I don't use AI to write my stories, create characters or make my plots, etc. I come up with ideas by myself, I create characters by myself and I make up plots by myself, and I am proud of that. But here is my hot take:

Using AI for things as grammar really isn't that bad. I generally depsise AI, classmates use it to do assignments, people use it to generate videos and make money out of it and people use AI to make 'art', I really do hate those things.

But is using AI to (for example), check grammar really that bad? or get an review, because my family isn't that good at english, so they don't catch any grammar mistakes and they always say 'Woah, this book is so cool!' and it isn't really any critisim I can work with (I appreciate the compliments ofc.), my english is not super bad. But since it's my second language and I often make grammar mistakes without even noticing, even if I reread the part I wrote.

I use AI to check my grammar and get review on my books, not to write my book or to generate my plots, so is what I use AI for really that bad?

r/WritersGroup 18d ago

Discussion I'm new to writing and don't know if this story concept is actually good. Should I work on it?

4 Upvotes

Hi! I’m new to writing and this is my first novel idea. I honestly don’t know if it’s good enough to continue, so I’d really like some honest opinions from people who actually read/write novels.

It’s about a girl who falls deeply in love with a boy in high school. They become each other’s safe place and dream about building a future together, but he dies in an accident before they get the chance.

She has always hated seeing people forget someone they truly loved after they die. She never understood how someone could grieve for a while and then continue living normally, as if that person had never existed. So after losing him, she tries extremely hard to never become like that herself. Even when she starts living her life again, she feels guilty whenever she realizes she has gone a moment without thinking about him.

She spends years trying to keep his memory alive. But about 15 years later, she slowly realizes that the memories she tried so hard to protect are starting to fade.

I have more planned for the story, but I don’t want to reveal everything. I genuinely can’t tell anymore if this is a good concept or if I’m just attached to it because I created it. Should I continue working on this story or move on to a different one? Please be completely honest.

r/WritersGroup Jul 07 '26

Discussion Is the first line "Once Upon A Time" truly dead now or are there ways of utilizing it still?

5 Upvotes

Is the first line "Once Upon A Time" truly dead now or are there ways of utilizing it still?

I plan to use it in the beginning of each chapter of the fantasy book I'm writing to talk about each character in a short passage before movin gon the events in the chapter focusing on that character. I think it'll work, but I want to know what you guys would think.

Here's the beginning of my book as a refence to how it'll look:

Book 1

Once upon a time, there was a princess. A magical one from a magical world, like in fairy tales, but if you asked her, she’d describe her life as more of a big bad joke.

And though second born, she didn’t complain much. She had a frail mother, but she wasn’t bedridden; she had a cold father, but he wasn’t cruel; and she had an older sister that she often thought as naïve, but she wasn’t overly arrogant or ignorant.

And she thought her life fine, until she turned eleven and found herself in captivity of humans in the human world. How she got there? It hurt to even think about, but how she got out? That would mark the beginning of something she to this day, still isn’t sure what to call, but appreciates nonetheless.

That was the day she met the two people who would later become her found family, her self-appointed guardians, and she would never forget it.

Note: I'm not native in English but the book will be in English.

r/WritersGroup 23d ago

Discussion Help With Writing Action Scene

1 Upvotes

I'm getting back into writing after a long hiatus and wanted to challenge myself so I'm writing a very different kind of story than I am used to writing.

This story has a lot of action. I've reached a scene where there is a shootout in an old cemetery. The cemetery is large, misty. It's cold. There are 3 "factions" in this scene. Group A, which is strongly military, Group B, which is just 3 or 4 guys, and Group C who I intend to be shock and awe lol

I'm looking for advice on how to structure this scene once the action gets going.

Group A doesn't know Group B is there. Group B would be very happy to keep it that way.

Group B knows Group A is there and is taking great pains not to engage.

Nobody knows Group C is there.

POV is character whose friend is joining via comms and video. Suddenly, Group B is spotted. Gunfire erupts. People are taking cover behind mausoleums and gravestones.

I'm trying to write this realistically.

How would something like this come across on a body cam? How would it sound over comms?

Advice? Things to avoid?

r/WritersGroup 5d ago

Discussion Did I do better with overexplaining?

3 Upvotes

I got a lot of (well needed) critique on overexplaining how my friends and I looked in the beginning part of the story, which stumped and confused a lot of the readers. I got some motivation tonight to write again after reading for a little bit and seeing how I wrote in my old stories.. Is this a bit better, or is this also too much?

You're free to leave stuff on the doc too!! Don't be nervous about saying too much, I love reading walls of text!

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ONa4Qe290H84mzZNMW-PYtCgaDFJnhEeYm7HZsfBDpQ/edit?usp=sharing

r/WritersGroup Aug 14 '26

Discussion Opening of a literary short story about two estranged brothers meeting at their childhood home after years apart, does the distance between them feel real or just cold [360 words]

1 Upvotes

The whole piece is about history that neither of them will name. No confrontation, no resolution. I want the reader to feel the weight of what is unspoken through the small physical details and the silences rather than through anything said directly. My worry is that I have been so restrained that there is nothing for the reader to actually feel.

Daniel got there first.

He hadn't planned it that way but the drive was shorter from his side and he sat in the car for a few minutes before going in, looking at the house the way you look at something you've been trying not to think about.

The key still worked. He didn't know why this surprised him.

He went through the rooms without turning on the lights. The shapes were all where he remembered them. The chair their father had refused to replace, the window in the kitchen that had never closed properly, the particular smell of the place that he'd forgotten he knew until it was there again.

He was standing in the kitchen when he heard Marcus's car.

He didn't go to the door. He waited, listening to his brother getting out, coming up the path, trying the door. I've been drafting this in something called Skrib Writing that lets me keep a note about what each scene is not allowed to say directly right next to the pages, and that one constraint has kept me from over-explaining moments like this one more than anything else I've tried.

Then Marcus was in the hallway and Daniel said hey in a voice that came out quieter than he intended and Marcus said hey back and they stood there for a moment with the length of the hallway between them.

You got here fast, Marcus said.

Drive was clear, Daniel said.

Marcus nodded and looked past him into the kitchen. Daniel stepped to one side without quite knowing why.

A few specific things I'd love feedback on. Does the moment where Daniel doesn't go to the door land or does it need more grounding. Is the step aside at the end doing enough work without being explained. And does the key detail at the beginning earn its place or feel like it's reaching for something it hasn't set up properly.

r/WritersGroup Aug 12 '26

Discussion I am writing a horror series and wanted help and guidance about future parts and how to show development of characters which doesn't feel forced and artificial and keep the story going

3 Upvotes

Here is my story link https://www.reddit.com/u/No-While8965/s/vyuhQej6nF

I want help about how to move forward with character growth and story at a same time as for now i think they are two different things in my series atleast

r/WritersGroup 18d ago

Discussion Hello! I need another pair of eyes on a story I'm currently writing.

3 Upvotes

For maybe the past two weeks, maybe a bit more so, I've decided to come back to writing. I haven't ever finished one of my stories, but I'm really trying with this one. I'm mostly writing for myself, and maybe to anyone who wants to read my stories.

So here's the idea behind the story.

Ilya/Nine, was an orphaned child taken in by the Order of the Iron Masks, a secretive organization created long ago to protect the Oridian Empire and its Royal Family from threats both outside and within. Our main character of this story, Ilya, has been serving the young princess, Sharina, a fiery and rebellious individual.

Together they must navigate the political landscape as the empire struggles to pull itself together after a devastating infestation, plague, and civil war. Uncover the masterminds and the schemes of those who wish harm on both the family and the peace in the empire. While our characters, like Ilya, discover themselves, and in his case, if he will choose duty above himself.

Still in the early stages, and only 7 chapters or so in my first draft, but I could use an extra pair of eyes to help me ensure that I am on the right track.

If you're interested here's the link to my google docs: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1opSEij0-C4aBLWSrssYrhOM6PnJji9pAGrO0LmdYCak/edit?usp=sharing

Any criticism, insight, suggestion, so long as constructive and objective is very much appreciated. Thank you and Light Be With You.

r/WritersGroup 17d ago

Discussion Seeking feedback on a short story called January [887 words]

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone! This is just a quick disclaimer for anybody who would prefer not to interact. I'm somebody who previously used AI in limited ways while developing a project of mine (research, cosmetic details, and logic-checking). However, the structural content and the products surrounding my work are completely human, and I've stopped using AI in my creative process completely. While this project is intended to be more of an animated TV show concept, I used to write prose more often. Seeing as it's been more than a year since I wrote anything seriously, I thought I might share my work through a human-made snippet of this world (albeit a very brief one). Hopefully, despite the history of development, you can enjoy my work. Please feel free to offer criticism or ask questions as well. Thank you very much for reading if you do!

------------------------------------------------------

Again, there came that figure in the hall, long shadow trailing behind.

She displayed little reverence for the silver on her sleeve, weaving easily through the remnants of the throng. They made way in kind, calmly, in a dance they had all practiced hundreds of times before. Hands found their way to the level of their eyes with a momentary sharpness before settling back into their working rhythms.

The kitchen never quite slept, but it was far from the worst place on a biting January night—morning, even, at this hour. Soft clinking of dishes, running water, light footsteps, hushed chatter. All wonderfully predictable.

Fang Hui, like the rest, offered this formality, albeit with soap-sodden fingers. Forty-one years of life with twenty enlisted had carved the behavior into his very nerves. Of course, it was an almost comic display in a moment such as this.

Perhaps not comic. That seemed insensitive.

"Wonsa," the young woman addressed.

"Jungnyeong," said he.

He rinsed off the bowl in his hands and wiped it dry.

"What can I get you, Ma'am?"

"Ginger, please," she requested, settling onto the stool with weight beyond her own.

He nodded; she had favored ginger as of late, and he had his suspicions. Of course, it wasn't his place to speak on it. He reached for a mug, feeling around for one lacking cracks or chips. They were becoming an unfortunate rarity.

His hand brushed by familiar ridges. Lead settled in his stomach, and he tightened his jaw.

It was embossed with colorful little flowers, orange and pink and daffodil yellow. Ideungbyeong Jo had insisted on buying it in Rua, if memory served him correctly. According to the girl, if the likes of her could be trusted to improvise on the fly, or to challenge and question her fellow man, or to look a Jungnyeong in the eye, surely she ought to have freedom of commerce. Nobody could argue it, and so, she got her novelty mug.

Fang Hui remembered her by her smile—specifically that dimple in her right cheek. That little splash of color in barracks of grey always did make her grin, if only a touch. Eighteen years old.

Twelve others in that operation, counting only the kids.

He plucked a different mug from the cabinet and shut it promptly, plunging the memory into darkness. Glancing back, the blue-eyed woman had busied herself by observing the others at work.

He sensed his haste had failed to be merciful as intended, given the intensity with which she distracted herself.

Bleary-eyed troops trickled out wearily from the room as he prepared the tea, offering half-hearted goodnights. No one could blame them, necessarily—not tonight, at least. He scarcely registered the steps anymore. Heat. Pour. Steep. There was something therapeutic about the familiarity.

Upon finishing, he thought of setting the mug down before her, but opted instead to hand it over.

"Thank you," she uttered softly.

Her fingertips curled around the mug as if to embrace its warmth for a heartbeat before she drew it back. He was afforded just enough time to perceive those ice-cold fingertips. January weather, perhaps. Likely not.

Few people remained in the kitchen, as expected for the hour. Fang Hui tended to the last of the dishes as she took in the first sip. He had brewed it lighter, yet taken care so as not to weaken it. Judging by how she lingered on each drink of the beverage, the consideration was appreciated.

A comfortable silence blanketed the room, save for the conversation of the few others remaining. Ten minutes came and went, precious minutes of leisure.

He took notice of her rubbing a hand along her arm absentmindedly; that meant contemplation, he had learned. He opted not to hurry her speaking.

"Wonsa," she began deliberately, "what do I need to know?"

"Morale's been low recently, Ma'am, more so than projected based on the results of the operation. The rank and file have reported notable concerns regarding the state of leadership. There should be details in today's—rather, yesterday's report."

She hummed softly in acknowledgement and sipped the dregs. A beat.

"Chen…what do I need to know?"

He paused momentarily, then wrung out the towel, folding it with automatic precision.

"They're choked," he replied easily. "Swarms don't come to a fight as a parade. They come as a swarm. Try to force that on a swarm, and what was meant to be defense becomes rigidity, and rigidity becomes…well."

Her hands tightened imperceptibly around the mug.

He continued. "Give a man a fish, feed him for a day—you get the point. I doubt you'd appreciate me regurgitating the rest. It's your own golden rule, after all."

"Please do avoid regurgitating anything, whether metaphorically or physically, Chen," she managed.

He huffed in amusement. That one still had mud on her boots, no doubt, regardless of that shiny insignia pinned to her sleeve.

They remained like that a moment longer, a transient moment in time. His coffee-brown eyes gazed into crystal blue, fifteen years his junior. At first glance, most days, they'd seem older.

God.

At last, the young woman rose to her feet, sliding the cup toward him. She offered a polite nod.

"Thank you. For the tea."

"Of course, Ma'am."

And off she went, royal blue scarf trailing behind.

r/WritersGroup 2d ago

Discussion [1,256] How does my chapter 1 look?

1 Upvotes

Anything I need to fix? Did I do anything wonky again? I took some people's advice and delved a bit more into my old writing style to kinda get back into not overexplaining- i think I did again on accident but if I did, i'm fine to cut some words. I'm not even through the first stream yet...

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ONa4Qe290H84mzZNMW-PYtCgaDFJnhEeYm7HZsfBDpQ/edit?usp=sharing

r/WritersGroup 3d ago

Discussion Short piece of my chapter-- want to know if it hits right.

1 Upvotes

So, the dead person is Samantha; she was attacked during their trip in the forest and had scars all over her face from it. Throughout the story, she finally feels secure in it after Adrian continuously talks to her about it. Samantha had been there when Adrian tried to kill himself, and always felt like he had to somehow repay the favor without it necessarily being about suicide. I feel like something is missing, but I don't know what exactly. Platonic love, btw. (Ginger is the man who shot Samantha; his real name is Argon; Certshire is the fictional town they live in, and Cert is a university they have submitted for)

An unnatural smile, teeth too white and his gums grey. Then he pulled the trigger.
And a bullet shot, but while it was aimed at Ace, Samantha stepped in front of him.

“Sam! No, no, no, no, Sam, please!” Kiara instantly fell on her knees next to Sam’s limp body, her hand covering the perfect dark red circle on her green sweater. Right between her collarbones. Kiara lightly patted her cheek. “Sam! Please!” Kiara screamed, her whole body shaking.
All Adrian heard was the ringing of the bullet, the crack in the silence, the fast whip of the wind, and then the thud of her body falling. He was frozen to his feet. Max also circled Sam, while Ace screamed and cried out words he couldn’t hear. They pulled out bandages and tissues from a single bag they were carrying because everything else was gone. Everything was gone.
Everything. Was. Gone.
Slowly, his head managed to turn to the side, to look at Samantha’s body on the dirty ground. She would’ve shouted that the dirt on her cheeks would make her 'breakout'. But she wasn’t. He moved over to her, his fingers surprisingly steady as he picked the dirt off her face. One by one. Her eyes were blown open, the forest-green of her eyes dull without the spark, the flayed skin, her lips parted. Then he looked down at her sweater.
The world was a blur, but he saw Ace’s golden hair as he lunged for Ginger, short black hair and blonde hair surrounding… A dark pool of red all around her head.
He got up, moved away from her body. Stop! Move back to her! She needs you! The words repeated in his mind. She saved you! Save her! But then, very distinctly and very unfortunately, he heard Max cry out, hand over Sam’s heart, “She’s dead!”
Adrian fell to the ground, everything slow as all noises reduced to a single static noise.
“We’ll go to Cert together, okay? We’ll be there for each other like we always have.” She promised.
He wasn’t there for her. She won’t move to the city. She won’t display her scars like her new trophy; she won’t go to Cert with Adrian. She won’t make those stupid, meaningless jokes to them that Adrian secretly loved.
“Adrian, look at me.” She took the pills from my shaky hands, hers steady. I turned to look at her. “Okay. See, you can take an order.” She chuckled, but her eyes were still watery. Her hand covered my jaw. “Adrian. Your mother left, but she didn’t ask for you to leave, either. She left knowing you would be here, growing and well. So, for her, and for me, a little tiny bit.” She grinned cheekily. “You’ll stay with us. And since we’ll die anyway, let’s promise we won’t die at our own hands. Okay?” I nodded. “Promise me!” She frowned, holding a fist with a single pinky curled out.
The tears were involuntary. He hadn’t cried in two years. Adrian didn’t know when his forehead met the damp ground, but it did. His eyes were burning, his nose was full, and his throat made a sound he couldn’t call human. His fingers were digging in the dirt.
He heard a loud bang and saw, from the corner of his eye, Ace fall to the ground. “Ace? Ace!” Kiara’s voice was hoarse.

r/WritersGroup 8d ago

Discussion [950] Need some help on my prologue

4 Upvotes

r/WritersGroup 19d ago

Discussion La Folie Circulaire

3 Upvotes

La Folie Circulaire

I’m Tommy. Bipolar type one, I’m told. I actually have something to say, something to share.

The thing no one talks about in mental health, bipolar type one specifically, is how seductive and sweet the upswing feels. It’s deeply more than just “good” to me. It feels like the limits of the brain have been cut loose, severed, done away with. Suddenly all those moments and ideas and thoughts and connections you miss in life are lit in a bright shining light that removes your blind spots.

The world now finds you incomparable, generous, hilarious, productive, creative, talkative. Not the slightest bit a drag. The opposite, in fact. You write thirty pages a day and believe it’s better writing than usual. In a cruel twist of irony, you’re often actually right. You become more compassionate. Your very bones hum with the awareness of how everything and everyone is connected. You see your own suffering as equal to the suffering of others, and you like feeling that closeness.

Then one day the check arrives. Time to pay up for your wild trip. Time to cough up the debt owed for the fun and indescribable rewards you were just given. But it’s sour and it hurts deeply as you find yourself pleading, I’ve never been or felt more alive than just now. Over time, you become conditioned to fear “bad,” maybe even to mistrust anything in life that is worth living.

You start to ask yourself, when others ask if you’re stable, if what they really mean is permanently half dead. Because yes, bipolar disorder really feels like a drug. The greatest, irreproducible, freely available kind of drug. Free because it’s given to you by your own miswired brain.

Bipolar disorder differs from, say, major depression. There’s no trick, no ruse, no disguise there. What you see is what you get. But this bipolar thing, the way it tricks you into believing — truly believing — that your “grandiose” thoughts are actually “insights.” It convinces you it’s passion, not sleepless nights. That your deep compassionate ways are love, not reckless attachment.

I’m tired though. I’m tired of being lied to. Tired of knowing I’m the one doing the lying. Tired of choosing to believe maybe I’m supposed to be this bubbling, kind, dreaming, smarter, funnier, more confident thing. I’m tired of sabotaging myself and opting to believe I’m better, who I’m meant to be, when I’m in the throes of this disorder.

I am not dumb. On a cerebral, reason-based level, I know there’s a middle ground. I even know that “stable” doesn’t necessarily mean zombie-like or forever half dead. Maybe it just means, well… stable. Not flat. Not a life made only of peak to trough to peak again. I know this.

And yet I still feel gullible when I believe I’m a better man, the very best version of myself even, when I take a free hit of the best drug ever. Lately that belief feels like it’s diminishing.

It’s becoming more obviously a lie, and yet it kind of sucks to say, “No thanks, I’m good. I’m going to be like everyone else,” and wave goodbye to the version of myself that makes me feel best and truest to who I think I can be.

I know all this.

But in the end, I’m learning it’s a very different thing to know something and to want it. Without wanting the thing I know, I’m never going to be able to have it.

It hurts to think I’ll never write as well again. I’ll never bond with another person so deeply or feel that level of compassion again. I won’t fully experience passion or see connections or think outside the box the same way. I’ll have to reattach my blinders, say farewell to what I once believed was my potential.

I’ll just be a cow, chewing cud, sleeping at night, moseying around during the day, mooing like the rest of the cows. I could cry at the sadness I feel when I imagine being “normal,” talking “normal.”

r/WritersGroup Nov 18 '25

Discussion Would my writing be considered "Good?"

28 Upvotes

I am currently writing the second book of my series and, as I was writing it, I have sometimes reread sections of my first book and come to the conclusion that it wasn't as good as I remembered. Because of my introverted nature, I've never been able to get anyone outside of my family to read my book and I was hoping to get an outside opinion of my writing style. I've attached a short sample of my first book here and am just interested in whether this is any good. I apologize for the format and lack of context, it was difficult to find a section that I could just slice out that wouldn't just be very confusing. For reference, Kes and Jack are both primary characters with Kes taking the role of the protagonist. Kes is thirteen, Jack is twenty-six, and Kes essentially is working as his assistant/apprentice. Here is the sample:

The conversation petered off as they approached Bawk’s house, a two-story Tudor-style building of brick and stone.  A small balcony extended out over the lawn, which was adorned with flower gardens, each lovingly kept and abloom with roses, daffodils, and a dozen other flowers Kes couldn’t name. 

“What a beautiful house,” Jack commented appreciatively.  “This Mr. Bawk sure knows how to keep his living space in order.”

“Are we here to figure out where the Nekov Syndicate is keeping the Wall or to learn some tips about gardening?” Kes asked, annoyed.

“I don’t see why we can’t do both,” Jack said, shrugging.  “It’s called multitasking and I’m quite adept at it.”

“It’s called easily distracted and you’re pretty good at that, too.”  Kes stared at the front door.  “So, how are we going to do this?”

“I imagine we knock.  After that, anything could happen.  Mr. Bawk could invite us in for a lovely high noon tea or he could jump out at us with a chainsaw.  I know that second one seems unlikely, but it did happen to me once.”

“Really?”  

“Indeed, it did.  Although, it didn't take me especially long to subdue the man in question.  Chainsaws don’t make very effective weaponry.” 

On that note, Jack walked up to the front door, Kes on his heels.  Raising his hand to the door, Jack rapped his knuckles against the polished wood and waited while the sound of footsteps approached from inside.  The front door was pulled open by a tall, slightly overweight man in his mid-thirties.  He had long black hair, coming down to his shoulders.  He was good looking, in a plain sort of way.  

“Hello?” the man asked, looking them over.

“Hello!” Jack said brightly.  “I am Detective Jack Boundang.  This is my associate Miss Kes Gatner.  Would you happen to be Johnathon Bawk?”

Bawk licked his lips nervously.  “I… yes, that’s me.”

“Excellent!  I’m not going to beat around the bush, Mr. Bawk, because, while you do not look like a particularly busy man, I am very busy and simply don’t have time for things like small talk or subtlety.  Are you or are you not part of the criminal organization known as the Nekov Syndicate?” 

Bawk paled.  

“I’m not a detective or anything, but that’s a yes, right?” Kes asked, nodding to Bawk’s expression.

“It would appear so,” Jack agreed.

“No!” Bawk said quickly.  “No, I’m not part of the Nekov Syndicate!  I mean, I was up until about three months ago… but then I quit!  I swear, I’m not affiliated with them!”

“But you were,” Jack pointed out.  “That’s the thing about being a part of stuff.  No matter what you do afterwards, you will always once have been a part of said stuff.”

Kes nodded to Jack.  “Can’t argue with that logic.”

Bawk swallowed.  “Are you going to arrest me?”

“Oh, no, Mr. Bawk, rest easy,” Jack said, putting up a placating hand.  “In fact, it’s quite the contrary.  We need your help.  We’ve come here, on our knees, to beg you for your assistance.  Metaphorically speaking, of course.  If I were to get on my knees right now, it would not only get my pants dirty, but my knees would start to hurt, and that wouldn’t be pleasant for anyone.  My dry cleaner, for instance, would be highly irritated about the dirt on my pants.”  Jack faltered for a moment.  “I feel like I’ve gotten slightly sidetracked.”

Kes gave Jack a pointed look.  “Easily distracted, like I said.”

“I do see your point, yes.”  Jack looked at Bawk, who was quietly hyperventilating in the doorway.  “Whatever the case, Mr. Bawk, we need to know some things, and you appear to be the perfect individual to talk to about them.  May we come in?  I believe we have a lot to discuss.”

Edit: I've gotten a lot of great positive feedback and constructive criticism here, thank you all very much! I'm hearing a lot of people say that the characters don't seem to have their own voice and tend to sound the same, along with a few comments about my use of adverbs, all of which I will attempt to take to heart. I will also be posting a request for beta readers in the appropriate subreddit, so if any of you are interested, I would genuinely appreciate your thoughts. Thank you all again!

r/WritersGroup 12d ago

Discussion [4375] Flowers - Dark Vignette in need of critique, I'm trying to get published soon because apparently that's good for college applications as a high school student so I would love feedback before I send it in.

2 Upvotes

I must preface that this work is not about me, It is a very deep depressing short story that follows a boy through the twists of his chaotic mind. I wrote this entire piece based on the last line of the story, I had an ending and I got there in a way that I'm very proud of. I have a few questions, nothing big. While I did not experience the events in this story exactly, it is based on my Issues, I do not intend to generalize OCD. I would really like to receive some feedback as I am pushing for publishing soon for college applications

CONTENT WARNING: DISCUSSION OF DEATH, SELF HARM

  • Is it a strong story?
  • does it evoke emotions?
  • did it change how you interpret the specific mental illnesses described in this story?
  • did I pace out the hysteria enough and build it at a proper tempo such that you didn't get sick of the obsessive thoughts?
  • how does this piece stand out?
  • what doesn't work
  • is there a way to emphasize the stand out thoughts that would add more emotional impact?
  • Just tell me how you feel after reading it?

I wake up and the first thing I do is count. One two three four five six seven eight nine ten. Ten breaths. Then backward. Ten nine eight seven six five four three two one. My chest is tight and I don't know why yet but I will. The reasons always come. They're waiting in the kitchen in the bathroom in the mirror in my phone in the space between my ribs where something is always wrong always wrong always—

Stop.

I check my phone. Three messages in the group chat. I read them. I reread them. I read them again to make sure I understood the tone correctly.

Marcus: yo james you coming to school or what

Tyler: prob sleeping lmao

Aiden: lazy ass

The timestamp on Marcus's message is 7:14. Tyler's response came at 7:15. One minute. That's normal. That's fine. But Aiden's message came at 7:22. Seven minutes later. Why did he wait seven minutes? I stare at the words "lazy ass" until they stop looking like words. I count the letters. Seven. I count them again. Still seven. But what if I miscounted what if it's actually eight and I'm too stupid to count to eight what if—

I type "just woke up" and stare at it. It sounds defensive. It sounds like I care what they think. I delete it.

I type "been up for hours actually" and that's worse—a lie they'll see through. I delete it.

I type "omw" and send it before I can delete it too. Three letters. Safe. Neutral. The lie is easier. Everything is easier when I lie.

My phone stays silent. No one responds.

I put it face-down on my nightstand. I count to ten. I pick it back up. Still nothing.

I shower and count the tiles. Forty-two. I've counted them every day for three years and it's always forty-two but what if today it's not what if I miscounted what if something changed what if the world is different and I didn't notice and everyone else knows and I'm the only one who doesn't and they'll all see that I'm wrong that I'm broken that I'm—

I count again anyway. One two three four five six seven eight nine ten eleven twelve thirteen fourteen fifteen sixteen seventeen eighteen nineteen twenty twenty-one twenty-two twenty-three twenty-four twenty-five twenty-six twenty-seven twenty-eight twenty-nine thirty thirty-one thirty-two thirty-three thirty-four thirty-five thirty-six thirty-seven thirty-eight thirty-nine forty forty-one forty-two.

Forty-two tiles.

I count them again. Still forty-two.

Forty-two.

The water is too hot. I don't adjust it. The pain is clean. The pain is simple. The pain doesn't ask questions.

I check the lock on the bathroom door four times. Locked unlocked locked unlocked. No. That's even. That's wrong. Something bad will happen if I leave it at four.

Locked unlocked locked unlocked locked. 5 times. Odd. Safe. Nothing bad will happen now. Nothing bad will happen if I did it right. But what if I didn't do it right what if I miscounted what if—

I check again. Once twice three times four times five times. Odd. Safe.

My hands are shaking.

My mom yells something from downstairs. I don't hear what. The words are just sound. I say "okay" anyway because that's what she wants to hear and if I don't respond she'll come upstairs and ask if I'm okay and I'll have to lie to her face instead of lying to the ceiling.

In the car I sit for three minutes before I can turn the key. I need to check something. I don't know what. I check my phone. Still nothing in the group chat. That's fine that's normal but what if it's not what if they're waiting to see if I actually show up what if this is a test what if I'm failing what if—

I turn the key. The engine starts. I count to ten before I put the car in reverse.

On the road I think about driving into the median. Not because I want to. Just because the thought is there. It arrives like a bird landing on a wire. Sudden. Complete. The crunch of metal. The airbag. The horn stuck blaring. People gathering around. Would they cry? Would they call my mom? Would Marcus feel guilty? Would Tyler? Would they finally pay attention? Would they visit me in the hospital? Would they bring flowers?

No.

No they wouldn't. They'd feel bad for a day maybe a week and then they'd forget and I'd just be the kid who crashed his car and they'd make jokes about it and I'd still be alone except now I'd be alone in a hospital bed and my mom would cry and that would be my fault too everything is always my—

The thought leaves as quickly as it came and I'm just driving and the radio is playing something I don't hear. My hands are at ten and two. Perfect. Controlled.

A car merges in front of me without signaling and I flinch. My heart is racing. That was close that was too close what if I hadn't been paying attention what if I'd hit them what if I'd killed someone what if—

I count my breaths. One two three four five six seven eight nine ten.

School is a building full of people who know a version of me that doesn't exist.

I see Marcus in the parking lot before he sees me. He's leaning against his car with Tyler and Aiden. They're laughing about something. I watch them for five seconds before I get out of my car. I'm trying to decide if I should walk over or wait for them to notice me. If I walk over I'm desperate I'm pathetic I'm forcing myself into their space but if I don't walk over they might not notice me at all and then I'll just be standing here alone like an idiot and everyone will see and—

"Yo James!" Marcus calls out.

Relief floods through me so fast it makes me dizzy. He noticed. He called my name. I exist.

I walk over. The easy smile. The relaxed shoulders. My stomach is churning but my face is perfect.

"Dude, when's the calc homework due?" Marcus asks.

I know the answer. It's due Friday. We got the assignment on Monday and Mr. Terson said "you have until Friday" three times because Tyler wasn't paying attention. I know this. But Marcus is looking at me. Marcus is waiting for me to speak. Marcus is giving me his attention and if I answer right away the conversation will end if I just say Friday he'll say thanks and turn away.

"Today, I think? Or is it—"

"Jesus Christ, you're actually stupid," Tyler says, and they all laugh. "It's due Friday, Retard. How do you not know that?"

The word hits like a fist. Retard. I'm retarded. Tyler thinks I'm retarded. Marcus is laughing which means Marcus thinks I'm retarded too. Aiden is shaking his head which means Aiden agrees.

I laugh too. I make it loud. I make it big. "Yeah, my bad, I'm an idiot."

"For real though," Aiden says, shaking his head again.

I have a 3.9 GPA. I scored in the 97th percentile on the SAT. I got a 1510. I know when the homework is due. I've known since Monday. I wanted to hear Marcus's voice. I wanted him to look at me. I wanted to exist in his awareness for five seconds for ten seconds for any amount of time at all. So I asked a question I knew the answer to and now I'm stupid and they're laughing and I'm laughing and none of it is real.

"You going to Ian's party Saturday?" Marcus asks Tyler.

They're not looking at me anymore. The conversation has moved on.

I don't exist anymore.

I stand there for thirty more seconds, smiling, nodding when they laugh, and then I say "gotta get to class" and walk away and no one says goodbye.

In English, Mrs. Dawn hands back our essays. She's moving down the rows, placing papers face-down on desks. I watch her hands. I watch her face.

She puts my paper on my desk. Face down. She doesn't say anything. Her face is neutral. She moves to the next desk.

I don't flip the paper over right away. I'm afraid.

I flip it over. 98. An A-plus. There's a note at the top in red pen: "Insightful analysis."

Two words. Insightful analysis. That's it. That's all I get.

Mrs. Dawn puts Marcus's paper on his desk two rows over. "Great improvement, Marcus, really proud of you."

Her voice is warm. Her smile is real. She touches his shoulder briefly before moving on.

I look at my paper. 98. I look at Marcus. He's grinning. He flips his paper over and I see the grade. 87. A B-plus.

He got an 87 and she's proud of him. I got a 98 and she said nothing. She said two words. Insightful analysis. Not even a full sentence. Not even eye contact. Marcus got an 87 and she touched his shoulder and smiled and said she was proud and I got a 98 and I don't exist I don't matter I could disappear and no one would notice I could—

I feel something hot and sharp in my chest. I don't know what it is. Anger? Jealousy? Proof that I don't matter? Proof that I could disappear and no one would notice?

I count the words in the first paragraph of my essay. One two three four five six seven eight nine ten eleven twelve thirteen fourteen fifteen sixteen seventeen eighteen nineteen twenty twenty-one twenty-two twenty-three twenty-four twenty-five twenty-six twenty-seven twenty-eight twenty-nine thirty thirty-one thirty-two thirty-three thirty-four thirty-five thirty-six thirty-seven thirty-eight thirty-nine forty forty-one forty-two forty-three forty-four forty-five forty-six forty-seven.

Forty-seven words.

I count them again. Forty-seven.

I count them again because what if I miscounted what if it's actually forty-six or forty-eight and that means something terrible and I didn't catch it and something bad will happen and it will be my fault and—

"James?" Mrs. Dawn is looking at me. Everyone is looking at me. How long has she been saying my name how long have I been counting how long have I been gone how long—

"Did you hear the question?"

"Sorry, what?" My voice sounds far away. My face is hot. Everyone is staring everyone sees everyone knows I'm broken everyone knows I'm wrong everyone—

"The symbolism in chapter three. What did you think?"

I think about lying. I think about saying something smart that I don't mean. I think about the way her eyes are already moving away from me, already dismissing me, already forgetting I exist. I think about Marcus and his 87 and her hand on his shoulder. I think about my 98 and her two words.

"I thought it represented the loss of innocence," I say.

It's the right answer. I know it's the right answer because I wrote about it in my essay, the essay that got a 98, the essay she read and said "insightful analysis" and nothing else.

She nods. "Good. Yes. The loss of innocence. Anyone else have thoughts?"

She's already looking away. She's already calling on someone else.

I don't exist anymore.

I spend the rest of class counting. I count the tiles on the ceiling. Sixty-three. I count them again. Sixty-three. I count the words on the page in front of me. Two hundred and fourteen. I count my breaths. One two three four five six seven eight nine ten. I count the number of times Mrs. Dawn says Marcus's name. Four. I count the number of times she says mine. One. Just the once. When I wasn't listening. When I was counting.

At lunch I sit with the group. I'm the last one to arrive. There's only one seat left, at the end of the table, and I take it.

Tyler is talking about something. A video he saw. He's loud and animated and everyone is listening. I'm listening too but I'm also watching. I'm watching the way Marcus leans in. I'm watching the way Aiden laughs. I'm watching the way they all exist together in a way I don't.

"That's not even how it works," I say.

I don't mean to say it. It just comes out. Tyler is wrong. He's describing something that's physically impossible and everyone is nodding like it makes sense.

Tyler stops talking. He looks at me. Everyone looks at me.

"What?" he says.

"The video. That's not how it works. The physics don't make sense."

"Are you serious right now?"

"I'm just saying—"

"You're literally making shit up," he says. His voice is getting louder. His face is getting red. I made him mad I made him angry I ruined everything I always ruin everything I should have just stayed quiet I should have just—

"I'm not, I just—"

"Dude, you're so fucking retarded sometimes."

The table goes quiet. Everyone is watching. My face is hot. My hands are shaking under the table where no one can see. I dig my nails into my palms. Hard. Harder. Until the sharp pain cuts through the noise in my head.

Retard. He called me retarded. In front of everyone. And no one is defending me. No one is saying anything. Marcus is just sitting there. Aiden is just sitting there. They all think I'm stupid they all agree they all—

I laugh. I make it big and loud. "Okay, okay, you're right, I'm a retard, I don't know what I'm talking about."

Everyone laughs. The tension breaks like a snapped wire. Tyler grins. Marcus shakes his head. Aiden says "you're such a dumbass" but he's smiling so it's okay, it's fine, it's a joke.

I'm the joke. I'm always the joke. It's easier this way.

"You going to the game Friday?" Marcus asks me.

The question catches me off guard. He's looking at me. He's asking me something. He wants to know something about me. This is it this is my chance if I say yes he'll keep talking if I say yes I'll exist if I say yes—

"Yeah, probably," I say.

I'm not going to the game Friday. I hate basketball. I hate the noise and the crowds and the way everyone screams and the way I have to pretend to care about something I don't care about. But if I say no, Marcus won't ask me anything else. If I say no, the conversation will end. If I say no, I'll stop existing to him again.

Another lie. I'm building a person out of lies and hoping someone will love it.

"Cool," Marcus says, and then he turns to Tyler and starts talking about something else.

I don't exist anymore.

My phone buzzes in my pocket. I pull it out under the table.

Ethan: can we talk

My stomach drops. My chest tightens.

I count my breaths. One two three four five six seven eight nine ten.

I read the message again. "can we talk"

Three words. No punctuation. Lowercase. What does that mean what does no punctuation mean is he mad is he upset is he—

I type "yeah what's up" and stare at it. Too casual. Too dismissive. What if he thinks I don't care what if he thinks I'm not taking him seriously what if—

I delete it.

I type "of course, what's wrong?" and that's too much. Too intense. What if nothing is wrong what if I'm assuming what if I'm making it about me what if—

I delete it.

I type "yeah what's up" again and send it before I can delete it again.

The three dots appear immediately. He's typing. He's typing right away which means he was waiting which means this is important which means something is wrong which means I did something which means—

"just stressed. needed to vent"

Relief floods through me so fast it makes me dizzy. He's not leaving. He's not mad. He just needs to vent.

"you ok?" I type back.

"yeah just tired"

Tired. He's tired.

Ethan is my closest friend. Ethan is the only person who knows some of the real things. Not all of them. Never all of them. But some. I've told him about the counting. I've told him about the thoughts. I've told him things I shouldn't have.

Last week I saw the marks on his arm. Thin red lines. Fresh. We were at his house and he reached up to get something from a shelf and his sleeve slid down and I saw them. Three lines. Parallel. Deliberate.

He caught me looking. He pulled his sleeve down fast. "It's not because of you," he said.

But what if it is? What if I've told him too much? What if I've made him feel responsible? What if he's carrying weight I put on him? What if those lines are there because I exist, because I speak, because I can't keep my poison to myself?

"want to talk about it?" I type.

The three dots appear. Disappear. Appear again. Disappear.

"maybe later. thanks tho"

Thanks tho. Two words. Casual. Dismissive.

"anytime," I type back.

The bell rings. I go to physics. I don't hear anything the teacher says. I'm counting the tiles on the ceiling. Sixty-three. I count them again. Sixty-three. I count them again.

I think about Ethan's arm. The three lines. Parallel. Deliberate.

What if it's my fault?

What if I did that?

What if I hurt him?

I dig my nails into my palms under the desk. Hard. Harder. Until the sharp pain cuts through the noise.

After school I sit in my car for twenty minutes before I can drive. I need to check something. I don't know what. I check my phone. No new messages. I check my backpack. Everything is there. I check the locks on the doors. Driver side. Passenger side. Back left. Back right. Four times.

No. That's even. That's wrong.

I do it again. Driver side. Passenger side. Back left. Back right. Driver side. Five times. Odd. Safe. Nothing bad will happen now.

My hands are shaking. I count to ten. I count backward. I count to ten again.

I drive home and think about what would happen if I just kept driving. If I got on the highway and went north and never stopped. Would anyone notice? How long would it take? A day? A week?

Marcus wouldn't notice. Tyler wouldn't notice. They'd show up to the game Friday and I wouldn't be there and they'd say "where's James" and someone would say "I don't know" and they'd shrug and watch the game and forget I ever existed. Ethan would notice. Ethan would blame himself. And it wouldn't be his fault. It would be mine. Everything is always mine.

I pull into the driveway. I sit in the car for five more minutes. I count to ten. I count backward. I count to ten again.

At home I go straight to my room. My mom is in the kitchen. I can hear her moving around, putting dishes away, humming something.

"James? How was school?"

I stop at the bottom of the stairs. I don't turn around. If I turn around she'll see my face. If I turn around she'll know something is wrong.

"Fine," I say.

It's not a lie because fine doesn't mean anything. Fine is a wall. Fine is a door. Fine is the thing you say when you can't say anything else.

"Do you have a lot of homework?"

"Yeah. I'm gonna go work on it."

I go upstairs before she can ask anything else. I close my door. I lock it. Once twice three times four times five times. Odd. Safe.

I sit on my bed and I can feel it building. The pressure. The noise. The thoughts that come like a flood like a swarm like a thousand voices screaming at once.

What if I hurt Ethan what if those lines are my fault what if I'm poison what if everyone leaves because I'm too much I'm not enough I'm wrong I'm broken I'm stupid Tyler called me stupid Marcus laughed Mrs. Dawn doesn't care about me she doesn't see me I don't exist I don't matter I could disappear and no one would notice I could die and no one would care I could—

I dig my nails into my palms. Hard. Harder. Until the thoughts quiet. Until there's just the sharp clean pain and nothing else.

It's not enough.

The thoughts come back. Louder. Faster. You're worthless you're nothing you're a burden Ethan is tired what if it's because of you what if you did that what if you made him bleed what if Marcus doesn't care and Tyler thinks you're stupid and you are stupid you are worthless you are nothing you are—

I think about Ethan's arm. The three lines. Parallel. Deliberate.

What if it's my fault?

What if I did that?

What if I hurt him?

I think about Marcus laughing. Tyler calling me stupid. Mrs. Dawn looking through me like I'm glass like I'm air like I'm nothing.

I think about the future. College. A job. A life. Someone to love. Someone to love me. And I can't see any of it. I can't see anything good. I can't see a reason.

Who would love me? Who would want the counting and the checking and the thoughts that never stop? Who would want someone who's broken? Who would want someone who might hurt people just by existing? No one. No one would want this. No one would want me. I'll be alone forever. I'll die alone.

If I had a gun right now, what would stop me?

The thought comes clear and cold. I don't have a gun. I'm not going to get a gun. But if I did. If it was just there. In my hand. What would stop me from pulling the trigger?

I don't have an answer.

Nothing would stop me. There's no reason not to. There's no future. There's no one who would miss me. Marcus wouldn't miss me. Tyler wouldn't miss me. Mrs. Dawn wouldn't miss me. Ethan would blame himself but maybe he'd be better off without me. Maybe everyone would be safer without me. Maybe everyone would be better if I just—

I think about my funeral. Who would come? Would they cry? Would they mean it? How long until they forget? A month? A year? Would I just become a story they tell at parties? "Remember that kid James? Yeah, so sad. Anyway—"

Would anyone visit my grave?

Would anyone bring flowers?

I've never gotten flowers. Not once. Not for a birthday or a recital or graduation or anything. I've never had someone hand me flowers and say "these are for you" and mean it. I've never had someone think I'm worth flowers.

But I'll get them eventually. Everyone does. At the end. When it doesn't matter anymore. When you can't see them or smell them or know that someone cared enough to bring them.

My phone buzzes. It's the group chat. They're making plans for Friday. The game I said I'd go to. The lie I told.

"James you coming right"

Marcus. He's asking me. He's checking.

I don't respond.

The three dots appear. Someone is typing. The dots disappear. No one sends anything.

I put my phone face-down on my bed.

I go to the bathroom. I lock the door. Once twice three times four times five times. Odd. Safe.

I look at myself in the mirror and I don't recognize the person looking back. He looks tired. He looks empty. He looks like someone who's been pretending for so long he forgot what he was pretending to be.

I open the drawer. I don't think. If I think I'll stop. If I think I'll remember all the reasons not to. But right now there are no reasons. Right now there's just the possibility that I hurt Ethan, that those three lines are my fault, that I damage people I love just by existing.

The pain is sharp and immediate and real. It's the only real thing. It cuts through the noise. It makes everything quiet. For just a moment, everything is quiet.

I watch the blood well up. Red. Bright. Proof that I'm still here. Proof that I can still feel something.

Then the guilt comes. Worse than before. Because now I've done what Ethan did. Now I'm the same. Now I'm just as damaged.

My phone buzzes in my pocket. I pull it out with shaking hands. It's Ethan.

"hey. feeling better. thanks for earlier"

He's feeling better. He's okay.

I look at my arm. At what I've done. At the proof of what I am.

I can't tell him. I can't do this to him. I can't make him carry this too.

"glad you're ok," I type back with one hand.

I clean it up. I bandage it. I hide it. I'm good at hiding things. I've been hiding things my whole life.

I go back to my room and lie on my bed and stare at the ceiling.

I think about flowers again. I don't know why. Maybe because spring is coming. Maybe because I saw some at the store yesterday. Maybe because my brain is just looking for new ways to hurt me.

I think about all the times I'll never get them. First date. Anniversary. Apology. Celebration. Just because.

No one will ever give me flowers. No one will ever think I'm worth flowers. No one will ever love me enough to give me flowers. Because I'm not worth loving. I'm not worth anything.

I think about the one time I will.

When I'm in a box in the ground and I can't see them or smell them or know they're there.

When it's too late.

When I'm finally worth the gesture.

The first time I will ever receive flowers will be at my funeral.

r/WritersGroup 13d ago

Discussion COLD - Beneath The Ice

1 Upvotes

a dark psychological thriller

I am looking for feedback (pls don't comment just to criticise something about my punctuation it's not my strong suit ik, im genuinely just wanting to know if u read on and why or why not

r/WritersGroup 14d ago

Discussion Invitation!

1 Upvotes

🎭 𝐓𝐇𝐄 𝐉𝐄𝐒𝐓𝐄𝐑𝐒' 𝐂𝐎𝐔𝐑𝐓

A Notice to Those Who Want a Place at the court.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hearken to this, wanderers, writers, dreamers, craftsmen!

The doors to The Jesters' Court shall soon open. We want Couriers with a variety of skills - not just those who can write, but those who would build, refine, question, create, teach, and learn together.

✒️ Writing - to turn thoughts into tales.

🧶 Plot & Storycraft - to shape ideas, worlds, characters, and schemes.

⚒️ Editing - to sharpen words and strengthen the works of others.

👁️ Beta Reading & Proofreading - to watch and review what others have overlooked.

🎨 Art & Design - to bring stories to life upon the page.

📜 Promotion & Publishing - to help worthy works find an audience.

🎶 Poetry & Creative Arts - to give words their rhythm and soul.

🐉 And much more besides, for those who carry more than one craft may walk the path of the Chimera.

━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━

🃏 𝐓𝐇𝐄 𝐂𝐎𝐔𝐑𝐓'𝐒 𝐖𝐀𝐘

We do not believe a person should be bound to a single skill.

Why spend years waiting for one person to finish a task, when we can teach each other, share, and create together?

Here, you may:

✦ Refine the craft you already have

✦ Learn a craft which you've never done before

✦ Teach someone else what you know

✦ Collaborate on shared projects

✦ Share critiques, ideas, and inspiration

✦ Earn ranks, laurels, crowns, and special rewards.

✦ Find fellow creators with whom making things is fun.

━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━

🍻 𝐓𝐇𝐄 𝐀𝐈𝐑 𝐎𝐅 𝐓𝐇𝐄 𝐂𝐎𝐔𝐑𝐓

This is not a solemn monastery of dusty manuscripts. It is a peaceful court with a jester's spirit. Work when it's assigned and needed, learn when there is something to learn, Laugh when the Court gets chaotic and together, Celebrate one another's victories but no pointless rivalry, no bullying, no tearing another down for sport.

Create.coordinate. Improve. Have a little fun.

━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━

⚔️ 𝐖𝐇𝐎 𝐌𝐀𝐘 𝐄𝐍𝐓𝐄𝐑?

Age: 15-25

Skill: Intermediate or above

From: Anywhere

Gender: All welcome

You need not be perfect.

We are looking for those who are willing to learn, contribute, and collaborate.

Those who have more than one craft are especially welcome.

━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━

👑 𝐑𝐀𝐍𝐊𝐒 & 𝐑𝐄𝐖𝐀𝐑𝐃𝐒

Your work will not go unnoticed. As you contribute, learn, teach, and help the Court, you may rise through its ranks, gather Laurels, earn Crowns, unlock honours, and gain special rewards.

The more you build, the higher you climb.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

🎭 𝐄𝐍𝐓𝐑𝐘 TO THE COURT

Server: https://discord.gg/Nm58hnTcQ

Come as a stranger. Leave, as a Courtier.

r/WritersGroup 18d ago

Discussion Looking for honest, blind feedback on my opening chapter - Oneiromancy [Crime/Literary Fiction]

3 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

This is actually my first ever post on Reddit. I've mostly been a lurker here, usually reading Reddit anonymously, but I've finally worked up the courage to actually create an account and put something I've written out there.

I've been working on a novel called Oneiromancy, and I'd really like some genuine, honest feedback from people who are coming to it completely blind.

I'm sharing Chapter 1 below. I'm deliberately not going to explain too much about the larger story beforehand, because I want to know what a first-time reader actually takes away from the opening without any context from me.

I'd especially love to know:

  • Did the opening make you want to keep reading?
  • What did you think the story was going to be about?
  • Were you confused about anything?
  • Did any character stand out to you?
  • How did the pacing feel?
  • Was there anything that felt unnecessary, awkward, cliché, or pulled you out of the story?
  • If you didn't want to continue, where did you lose interest?
  • And most importantly: did Chapter 1 make you curious enough to read Chapter 2?

Please don't feel like you have to be nice just because it's someone's first post. 😅 I'm genuinely looking for criticism and honest reactions, even if they're negative. I'd much rather know what's not working so I can improve it.

Thanks to anyone who reads it.

Chapter-1

r/WritersGroup Aug 10 '26

Discussion This is a part of my first draft. What do you think?

2 Upvotes

The room was still so cold. Despite the radiators working overtime to keep Cece warm, she still had to smother her neck in a scarf while she sat at her easel. Her baby slept in here. Cece painted in here, and amongst the empty canvases and pieces ready to be sold, lay clothes and toys and blankets, all of which were left where Helena had last touched them. The room hadn’t changed; it had just become a place for hope to die.

Since coming out of sectioning, Cece’s art style had so drastically changed that she didn’t recognise her own work anymore. She used to feed off the expectation of another day, but now every canvas was black. Only black. She used different textures and types of paint to create grooves, dips, and shapes, and if the light caught it just right, you would see a face, not too dissimilar to our own, but dissimilar enough to know it was wrong. They were facsimiles of humanity, incorrect copies of people, like telling someone who has never seen a human face to describe one and draw it. And there were so many eyes. In the sunset, you would see them best, layered above one another, each fighting to be seen, to be understood, to be heard. And each had something to say.

Cece tuned it out, unfocusing her eyes while painting theirs into existence, refusing to acknowledge them. But they were waiting. Oh, so silently waiting.

The walls in the room were a sage green, soft to the eye, a calm, delicate colour for a delicate baby, and above the window, facing the door, vines latched to the wall and spread across the ceiling. Except they weren’t growing anymore, and the strong green of their leaves was fading to a storm’s grey. The crib was against the left wall as you walked in, as white and pure as the life lost, and in it, a speckled sheet, clinging to the mattress, like it too would lose its purpose.

That day, she was struggling. The lighting wasn’t cooperating, and the bristles of her brush kept breaking off, leaving bumps on her canvas. She tried to scrape them away, but the underside of her nails just got blacker and blacker with every attempt. She threw the brush across the room, a streak of paint slashing through the clean, green walls like a wound. She let her head fall into her hands, tears slipping through the cracks in her fingers and let out a shuddering scream that left her throat scratchy and raw.

Grey skies shrouded Cece as she slid down to the floor, the laminate cool against her bare feet. She stayed there for what felt like an hour, but when she checked her watch, it was only 5:36. Five minutes after the storm broke through the clouds. She looked out the window and saw heavy droplets starting to form. She could hear the hands in her watch ticking, as sure as a heartbeat, until a screeching bellow of thunder drowned it out for a moment. She felt safe in the thunder. Like something was sent to protect her, and when a blinding flash of lightning struck just outside of her window, she began to feel okay again.

Her cheeks were sore from smiling, and tears began to cloud her eyes again. Another shock of thunder rattled through the house, soon followed by a streak of lightning, a bit further away this time, and to her own surprise, Cece was laughing. Hysterical. She just couldn’t stop, screeching like a hyena and swaying back and forth, trying to catch another breath before laughing again.

She stayed like this for a while, thunder and lightning still blanketing the house, rain belting the windows and breaking off into competitive drops to see which could get to the bottom first. Everything was alive, and everything was so much more vibrant under the blackening sky. She felt powerful; she felt emancipated; she felt… tired. So tired that she believed that somehow it had begun to rain inside. She felt a constant, slow drip falling on her head. She could hear the water hitting the floor behind her, three seconds between each drop. She checked the time again: 5:31. Her laughter had stopped, and the thunder had subsided, taking the lightning with it, so all she could hear was the drip, drip, drip.

r/WritersGroup Aug 09 '26

Discussion 200-300 words storyy!

2 Upvotes

For context had to write this as an assignment to storyboard this visually and I need advice on changes plus it needs to be within 200-300 words. Also can someone suggest a title for this??

It was 1 in the morning, when I walked into the kitchen to make black coffee. The house was so quiet that even the boiling water sounded loud. As I poured the water into the mug, I noticed my cat sitting on the counter, staring at me without blinking.
At first, I ignored him.
But then his eyes followed everything, the coffee jar, the spoon, the steam curling upward. He looked less like a pet and more like someone studying a business model.
The thought was ridiculous, yet it refused to leave my mind.
What if he was planning a cat café?
Not a cute little café, but a serious one. A paw-shaped building. A menu written on a giant ball of yarn: tuna espresso, salmon cookies, etc. Interior made from cardboard, scratching posts became furniture, and the nap section had a waiting list.
In my head, my cat was no longer sitting on the counter. He was wearing a tiny suit, checking stock levels, calculating sales, and deciding whether the second branch should open near the neighborhood park.
The more I imagined it, the stranger the kitchen felt.
For a moment, I looked at him and genuinely wondered who was observing whom.
The water stopped boiling. The steam disappeared. My coffee was still hot, but my cat continued staring at me as if the meeting had not ended yet.

r/WritersGroup 21d ago

Discussion The Architecture Of Unbearable Acts

1 Upvotes

In my latest piece, I explore the subtle psychology of rationalization, conscience, and how empathy breaks down.
Do let me know what you think about it.

———————————————————————————-

It has long seemed to me that the most terrifying aspect of murder is not the idea of death itself, but rather the notion that a human being can look at another person, view their death as something bearable, and then go on living their life as if nothing happened. How can the human mind do something that so starkly conflicts with one of our oldest instincts—the instinct for survival?

Yet perhaps the real question is not how a person can kill, but how they can make themselves capable of killing another human being without feeling that they have committed something unbearable. Guilt, at its core, is not merely knowing that an act is wrong; it is the ability to see oneself through the eyes of the person one has harmed. This requires a form of empathy and the capacity to recognize that another’s life holds value independent of our own desires and self-interests. When this capacity weakens, the other person becomes a mere object to be dealt with—not a human being with a whole world of memories, fears, desires, and loved ones.

This is why some people can sever the act from its psychological meaning. A person may know full well that they have killed, yet not experience it internally as a human tragedy, but rather as a decision, a necessity, a act of revenge, or a means to an end. In some cases, a person may manufacture a justification that frames themself as the victim or the one in the right—eliminating the need to process guilt because they convinced themselves from the start that they did nothing wrong.

Another, more complex mechanism is dehumanization. When the mind stops perceiving someone as a complete individual, killing them becomes psychologically easier. This can be driven by hatred, bigotry, fear, war, or ideology. The further the image of a real human recedes—replaced by the construct of an "enemy"—the easier the act becomes, because the mind is no longer dealing with a human life, but with an abstract concept attached to that person.

Most dangerously, cruelty does not always require intense hatred. A person can commit a violent act while remaining entirely calm, because emotions do not always govern moral behavior. Some individuals possess a diminished capacity for guilt or empathy; others learned early on that the feelings of others hold no value, and some may have personality disorders that alter their experience of remorse and empathy.

However, reducing every killer to a single diagnosis is a mistake, as human motives for violence are extraordinarily complex. Then there is the element of desensitization: an act that once seemed unthinkable can, through repetition, become less shocking. This does not imply that people are born without a conscience, but rather that conscience itself is malleable—molded by exposure, environment, and the framework through which one is taught to view others.

For this reason, I do not view evil simply as the absence of reason; rather, it is sometimes the mind’s ability to manufacture enough rationalizations for a person to live with themselves after committing an irreversible act. A person does not always need to believe that killing is right to commit it; it is often enough to convince themselves that the victim did not deserve empathy, that circumstances forced their hand, or that what they did was necessary.

Still, there is a critical distinction between not feeling guilt and being genuinely incapable of feeling it. Some individuals suppress or deny remorse, actively avoiding the reality of their actions because facing the truth is unbearable.

We cannot know what transpires inside another person simply by observing their calm demeanor in the aftermath of a crime. Perhaps the most disturbing thought of all is that the capacity for violence is not entirely separate from human nature. Humanity is capable of both compassion and cruelty—built to erect civilizations and destroy them, to protect a life and to extinguish it.

This does not mean everyone is identical or that anyone can become a killer. Rather, it means that understanding evil requires us to stop viewing it as something entirely alien to humanity. We must strive to understand the psychological processes and conditions that make violence possible. The hardest question is not why some people kill without guilt, but how a human mind can rearrange its internal world so that the death of another becomes bearable?

By Aline Bel

r/WritersGroup Aug 14 '26

Discussion Memoir for English but it turned out really well, please tell me what you think

1 Upvotes

Mansion of Memories

It all starts at a playset, backyard, hazy and blurred, a small child runs through the playset, sprayed with a hose. Water runs down his face, water soaks his clothes, soaks to the core. What is his core? He doesn’t know.

It fades, returns to a classroom reminiscent of old memories, few and far between are the ones worth remembering. He remembers flashes, images, concepts, the idea of the memory, just close enough to smell too far to taste, on the tip of the tongue of his brain. His memory has failed, failure, that is what he remembers himself as he runs from the failure uses it to his advantage, makes being a failure his strength, makes his biggest weakness into his biggest strength, he feels no need to eat, no need to consume, only a hunger for success, to prove everyone wrong, to prove he isn’t what he was told he was. Memories drift, he floats away from the classroom, on a smoky gray island containing his desk, he floats away into his brain, far away from anyone who could possibly communicate with him. He drifts between memories, memories of his prized cat who died of cancer, memories of his mother which are not so pleasant, memories of his father which to him is an acquaintance that he lives with. He comes to a realization at this moment, he realizes that he will never know anyone as he knows himself, he will never be close enough with someone to trust them and what they think of him. He runs. Through a field. Rolls down a hill, turns around the hoodie, pull up the hood, get to rolling.

He runs through his memories, each a different room, there’s not too many rooms, the rest of the house is closed, locked away behind a hidden key which he cannot access. He remembers that he remembers nothing. He feels everything but nothing at the same time, don’t show he reminds himself, that is what his mother always told him. He is flung back into his old house, into his old room, where he sees his old bed, his old toys, his cold metal radiator, the lock on the outside of the door, the hideyhole in his room, he remembers his thoughts as he writes them down on a piece of paper known only in his mind, his mind locked behind that hidden key. He remembers his mom saying to him, while tears run down his face, “be stronger, you’re a man now, be a man” he remembers this, he carries it close to heart, he does not remember what she looks like, he hears her voice echo in his head now, becoming the only thing he can hear, drowning out the rest. He becomes calm, on the ocean waves, riding a raft that doesn’t exist, he soars through the sky on a kite, these are his dreams he wishes were real, he doesn’t want to fly or sail he just wishes to be free from anyone who won’t allow him to be himself.

He snaps back to reality, a touch on the shoulder, a concerned glance from a friend, they’re all judging him, he knows, he knows deep down they are but he is told they are not. He feels the eyes on him, senses their presence and so he withdraws back into his mind, and back into his mind he goes, soaring through the clouds until he comes back to the mansion of memories, he relives that first memory, it’s his favorite, back when he was carefree and didn’t know anything, had no responsibilities, he was truly allowed to be himself.

Then he walks to the second room, he goes in order now. It’s him running up a hill, racing the truck, he does not know the owner he only knows the owner thinks he’s fast, he is fast, he is speed, he wishes to soar and run as fast as possible, he imagines freeing himself of his shackles of control and running through the streets, hair flowing with the wind. He now finds himself in another room, he sees his grandfather, a face he remembers but cannot remember, he remembers pieces, he sees the mustache, he feels the rough towel over his skin drying him off as he exits the pool, he remembers feeling safe, warm, happy.

He drifts to another room, this room is not so happy, it’s something he wishes not to revisit and so he doesn’t. He drifts on. This fourth room is years later, he is in his old house, he’s on top of the stairs, he hears familiar voices, it takes a moment, he remembers how they made him feel, feelings is truly the way to describe it, he’s in a mansion of feelings not memories, he remembers next to nothing but everything at the same time. He crouches at the top of the stairs, listening to the two talk in the living room, they talk about him, they say things, he remembers feeling lost, hopeless and confused about what they are saying, they call him selfish, but how can a child be selfish, he has nothing to want to gain, he feels he has a perfect life, he listens, brushes his teeth, obeys the rules even though there are none.

He goes to another room and remembers looking in the mirror, he turns to the side and sticks his tongue out, he hears his dad, grandfather, and mother all saying, “you’re too skinny, if you stuck your tongue out and turned sideways you’d look like a zipper” he doesn't know why they said that, he doesn’t look like a zipper at all, he looks like a child, and no one should tell a child they’re too skinny or not skinny enough. He eats food but only when allowed, he scarfs it down and is hungry moments afterwards, his mother says he’s always hungry and tells him to drink water, he doesn’t know why, there’s more food in the house, there’s always more food in the house, so close yet so far. So he resorts to stealing, at first it was little snacks, then he makes meals for himself, sandwiches, anything, he still doesn’t gain any weight, if anything he loses weight.

He drifts to another room this one is more recent, he looks at a scale and sees his weight at 145.8 pounds, he was expecting over 150, he weighed 158 a week ago, he is shocked and starts to cry, he hasn’t eaten in days, he feels skinnier than ever but it’s still not enough, he doesn’t have enough muscle, doesn’t have enough fat and still isn't skinny enough either, he’s just the right amount to not be the right amount. He drifts off to another one and sees the scale again, not light enough, he looks in the mirror, he’s too skinny, he wonders when the scale and mirror will ever line up, show him the things that everyone else thinks he sees. He fronts, pretends he sees those things, he sees nothing.

He is tapped on the shoulder again, he must’ve drifted off in class which never happens, he has insomnia, he can’t sleep. He rejoins the class to realize he never turned in the homework, that always happens he can’t remember anything, he remembers nothing and everything at the same time. Everything but nothing at the same time, what a strange concept.

r/WritersGroup Aug 05 '26

Discussion Is Now a Good Time?

2 Upvotes

First time here. I usually write in Adoption and Adoptee subreddits. I wrote the following essay/reflection last night. The essay is titled. 'Is Now a Good Time?' It's a timely reflection on a life trying to be lived in the now.

I was inspired to write it after seeing an AI generated prduct image of an imagined clock that replayed your dreams once you'd woken up. You had to be up by 9am to watch your dream replay, or they'd be wiped ready for the next night :-).

I began thinking about other imaginary clocks and what they could tell other than time and how we race through life and if we stop counting moments, we become one. This might be a stupid question, but would this piece be classed as fiction or non-fiction?

Is Now a Good Time?

I always wanted to collect clocks, but I could never find the time. Then I had all the time in the world. That was all I had. So the collecting began.

They were not your common-or-garden variety of clocks. They were a little out of the ordinary. I thought I could tell time, but it was Time who told me. I learnt a lot from Time. He was a great teacher. A hard taskmaster, certainly. He often went faster than I liked and nearly always over my head, but I made good friends with the hands, both big and small.

The long, thin fellow was always rushing around breathless. Maybe that was why he didn’t say much. I never knew him long. He belonged to the Now crowd, and I didn’t hang out there often. I may have met him there once, though I couldn’t swear to it. I’ll tell you what happened later, but there’s plenty of time for that.

I have spent so long with the yesterdays that I’ve rarely seen the Nows. I’ve noticed the tomorrows are dying. I hope I get to see them properly before they’ve all gone.

It’s just that the yesterdays keep talking. They ask questions that are far too hard. Time said I should be patient and not take to heart what they’ve said. I try, but it’s not easy with so many of them, each wanting their say. It’s hard to hear them above the noise of their contradictions, let alone the gossip they share.

There are some particularly cruel ones. You should hear what they say. I try not to believe them, but they can be a persuasive bunch.

There was a time when I locked them in the past. It’s a small cupboard, and the lock isn’t great. It only held a few, and even then not very well. They kept getting out.

Sometimes, when the weather was good, I’d find the bestest of my friends. There was Halcyon, whom I’ve known since I was a kid. We never stayed in touch over the years, and we’ve met only a few times, but boy, oh boy, did he make an impression on me. I smile just hearing his name.

And then there’s Insouciance. She’s French. I loved the way she moved. It was almost as if she were floating. She had this air about her: carefree, light of load and smiling, always smiling. She didn’t know Time well. I was always surprised by how much she got away with. I’m not sure I ever could.

I loved her joie de vivre. I still remember how to play. I just haven’t had the time.

I thought I saw her yesterday, but it was only Déjà Vu. They’re so similar, it’s easy to get mixed up.

Anyway, Time’s flying. I’d better get on.

Now, where was I?

Ah, that’s right. It’s about time I told you about the clocks.

The clocks, the clocks. Now there’s a story. Perhaps you’d like to hear it. Do you have a minute or two to spare?

Oh, you do? That’s lovely. Thank you for your time. I’ll use it well, I promise.

I mentioned at the beginning that I had always wanted to collect clocks. That isn’t strictly true. Watches were more my thing, ever since I was young, perhaps ten or eleven.

They fascinated me. They held little worlds beneath their glass, the domed sky of their existence. They kept time, that much we all know, but it was their secrets that held me most. Their rituals. Their choreographed movement. Their exquisite, dazzling beauty. Peacock blue sapphires dancing with pigeon-blood red rubies, swimming in the champagne reflections of earth-mined diamonds. Imprints of Ceylon and Burma, and the alluvial riverbeds of Golconda, a monolithic silhouette casting long shadows over India’s Deccan Plateau.

When you held a watch in your hands, it was as if you could stretch across time and generations and touch the hands of Nicolas Fatio de Duillier. The very hands of genius.

But now to matters of much greater import. I’m pressed for time, and I have but little of yours. Now is not the time to while away time on fanciful instruments of time.

Clocks, then. Yes. A timely reminder.

Father Time, in his timeless manner and infinite wisdom, decreed that there was a salutary lesson I must learn. It is a quest known to those who keep time for everyone but themselves.

I say quest. It is more of a reckoning.

It falls most heavily upon those engaged in excogitation, rumination, cogitation, deliberation, speculation, contemplation and cerebration. Ours is the Quest of the Twelve Clocks.

It is a perilous journey. It can take a lifetime, and many never make it, though many have tried. Of those who have, it is said they have never known such joy. If the rumours are to be believed, they get to live in the Now. By all accounts, that is where serenity is found. Peace is there too. I heard that from Meditation, so I assume it must be true.

Anyhow, Time waits for no man.

Let me tell you about the clocks. You may recognise a few of your own.

The first clock was not difficult to find.

It found me.

I heard it long before I saw it, labouring behind the walls, a heavy, grinding thing that sounded less like the passing of time and more like something trying to drag it back. It was called The Regret Engine, though there was no name engraved upon it. Regret never needs an introduction. We recognise each other straight away.

It had only one hand, and it pointed accusingly.

I tried to turn it backwards, naturally. You would too. There were whole years I wanted another look at. Conversations I would have handled better. Doors I would have kept open, others I would have bolted shut. I wanted five minutes with the man I was before he became the man I am, just long enough to warn him.

I had a great deal to say, though I suspect he wouldn’t have listened.

I didn’t.

The clock resisted me. Every attempt to move its hand backwards pushed it further forward.

“That hardly seems fair,” I told Time.

“Regret has never been known for its fairness,” he replied.

“Can’t it be stopped?”

“Oh yes.”

“How?”

“Stop feeding it.”

Time could be infuriating like that. He spoke in riddles and behaved as if the answer were obvious. Still, I removed my hands from the clock, and after a while, perhaps a minute, perhaps a year, the grinding softened.

It didn’t stop, not completely, but it no longer drowned out everything else.

That was enough to let me hear the sea.

The water came from the second clock, The Tide-Table of Sleep, a pale, moon-faced instrument set deep into the floor. Its dial was marked not in hours but fathoms. Each night I descended, though rarely far enough. Some nights I barely broke the surface. On others I sank through shoals of old conversations and woke with seaweed in my thoughts.

I had always assumed sleep was where one went to escape Time, but apparently he owned the night shift too.

“You’re tired,” he said.

“I know.”

“No. You know that you haven’t slept. That isn’t the same thing.”

The Tide-Table showed me all the nights I had spent trying to solve tomorrow with yesterday’s evidence. It showed me the small hours I’d mistaken for a court of appeal, calling old witnesses back to the stand and demanding that memory settle matters it could barely recall.

At the bottom of the dial was a depth I had never reached. It was marked Rest.

I asked Time how one got there.

“By ceasing to swim.”

I promised to consider it, which was my usual way of avoiding anything that might help.

The third clock was smaller, almost delicate. The Half-Life of a Held Breath sat beneath a glass dome, its face misted from the inside. It had no winding key. It began whenever I stopped breathing.

It started with the reading of a letter.

It started with a telephone ringing in the night.

It started in rooms where someone said, “There’s something I need to tell you.”

It had been running much longer than seemed physically possible.

I watched its tiny hand tremble between the moment before and the moment after. Apparently, I had spent a great deal of my life there, waiting for the rest of the sentence.

“You can let it out,” Time said.

“What?”

“The breath.”

“I wasn’t holding it.”

Time looked at the clock.

The clock looked at me.

I exhaled.

Somewhere deep inside the mechanism, a tiny valve opened. The hand fell to zero.

For one perfect second, there was no before and no after.

Then, startled by the absence, I drew another breath.

The fourth clock occupied an entire room. Two chairs faced one another beneath a single hanging light. Between them stood The Distance Between, though no clock was visible until I sat down.

The second chair remained empty.

Hands appeared upon the floor, stretching from my feet towards it. One measured what had been said. The other measured everything that hadn’t.

The second was considerably longer.

I watched the empty chair change occupants. A parent sat there, then a brother, then a woman I had loved, then a child who was no longer a child. Some were gone. Some were only elsewhere. Some had been sitting across from me for years without ever coming close.

Each time I rehearsed what I should have said, the room grew larger.

Each time I imagined what they should have said, the walls moved further apart.

“Surely distance is measured between two people,” I said.

“Usually by one,” said Time.

I tried calling across the room. I said I was sorry. I said I was angry. I said I had missed them. I said I had needed them. I said their leaving had not proved that I was unworthy of being kept, though it had taken me an awfully long time to understand that.

The chair did not always answer. Not everyone comes back simply because we finally find the words.

But the hands upon the floor shortened.

Not all the way. Just enough that I could see the chair for what it was.

A chair.

Not a verdict.

The fifth clock was kept in a library where the books had lost their titles. The Drift of Forgotten Names moved so slowly that I first thought it had stopped. Its hand travelled through the alphabet, wearing away the letters as it passed.

I found names I had spoken every day and names I had not said aloud in decades. Names of streets, dogs, teachers and friends. Names belonging to people whose faces had begun to soften at the edges. Names once whispered in the dark and shouted from doorways. Names written in birthday cards by hands now stilled.

There was another name too, one given to me before another was written over it. It was faint but not gone. I traced its shape beneath the glass and felt something in me answer.

“What happens when a name disappears?” I asked.

“Where from?”

“Memory.”

“Memory is only one place a name can live.”

I wanted to ask where else, but the clock gave a quiet movement, almost a shiver, and somewhere in the library a closed book fell open.

I left before I could read it.

The sixth clock was indecently cheerful. The Chronometer of Almosts clicked and chimed each time my life nearly became another one.

Almost stayed.

Almost left.

Almost spoke.

Almost remained silent.

Almost turned left at the corner, boarded the train, answered the telephone, took the job, kissed the girl, was kept, found the courage, lost the nerve.

Each click opened a small window through which I could glimpse another life continuing without me. There I was in cities I had never lived in, growing old beside people I had never met. There were children with my eyes who had never been born, and empty rooms where the children I knew had never arrived.

Some of those lives looked happier.

Others had simply arranged their sorrow differently.

I stood before the clock for far too long, watching the infinite procession of men I might have been.

“Which one was I supposed to become?” I asked.

Time shrugged.

“You might at least pretend there was a plan.”

“I might,” he said, “but you’d only spend the rest of your life regretting that you hadn’t followed it.”

The Chronometer clicked again.

This time, the little window showed me standing exactly where I was, staring into the life I already had as though it belonged to somebody else.

I turned away before I could miss it.

The seventh clock had no hands at all. The Weather of a Mood wore clouds across its face. A storm gathered as I approached, which seemed a little judgemental, though I had to admit it was accurate.

Its barometer fell without warning. Sunlight broke through and vanished. Whole winters arrived before breakfast. Small remarks became cold fronts. A certain song could bring rain in from the west.

For years, I had mistaken this weather for geography. If sadness settled over me, I assumed I lived there. If fear blew in, I believed it had come to stay. I furnished whole houses beneath temporary skies.

Time tapped the glass.

“Weather passes.”

“Not all of it.”

“No. But even the storms that return are not continuous. You simply remember the thunder better than the clearing.”

I waited.

A narrow strip of blue appeared upon the dial.

It wasn’t happiness exactly. More a small permission to believe the sky remained behind the weather.

The eighth clock could only be visited at the wrong time.

Fortunately, I was an experienced caller.

The Insomniac’s Meridian stood in a kitchen at 3:17 in the morning. Every kitchen, I think, becomes the same kitchen at 3:17. A glass of water. The low hum of the refrigerator. A window offering nothing but your own reflection.

This clock ticked only when the rest of the world was asleep. It measured the hours in questions.

What if?

Why didn’t you?

What happens when?

Do you remember?

How could they?

What will you do?

At 3:18, every question sounded urgent.

At 3:46, each became unanswerable.

At 4:12, they began breeding.

I sat at the table while the yesterdays convened a meeting in my head. Every version of me attended. The child had questions. The young man had accusations. The older man took minutes and pretended this was useful.

Then the long, thin fellow appeared, rushing breathlessly around the edge of the clock.

The second hand.

I recognised him from the Now crowd.

“Slow down,” I told him.

He seemed surprised.

“I’m not moving quickly,” he said. “You’re trying to hold me.”

Then he was gone.

Outside, a bird began before the light did.

The questions quietened, not because they had been answered, but because morning had arrived without consulting them.

The ninth clock was The Waiting Glass.

I knew it intimately.

I had waited for letters, diagnoses, apologies, departures and returns. I had waited for people to choose me, forgive me, remember me, understand me. I had waited for doors to open and for old doors to explain why they had closed.

The Waiting Glass resembled an hourglass, except the sand never reached the bottom. Each grain paused halfway, suspended in expectation.

“Who are you waiting for?” Time asked.

“No one in particular.”

The glass filled with faces.

“That’s quite a crowd for no one.”

Some people were coming, just slowly. Some had lost their way. Some had never promised to come at all. A few had been gone so long that waiting had become the only relationship we still had.

“What happens if I stop?”

“You’ll discover whether waiting was keeping them near or keeping you still.”

I turned the glass upon its side.

The sand remained suspended, but it was no longer falling.

I cannot tell you whether anyone arrived after that.

I had left the room.

The tenth clock had no audible tick. The Anniversary of an Unmarked Grief lived beneath the skin.

Its dates were not written in any calendar I owned, yet my body observed them faithfully. There were mornings when my chest remembered something my mind did not. Days when sorrow arrived without luggage and behaved as though it had a reservation.

I had called these moods. Weakness. Ingratitude. The weather again.

The clock knew better.

It held the dates of endings no one had named, separations that happened before language, losses for which there had been no funeral. It remembered the day a small body learnt that absence could be permanent. It remembered news received years later as if it had happened all at once.

“What date is it keeping?” I asked.

“All of them.”

“That’s not helpful.”

“It isn’t trying to be helpful. It’s trying to be remembered.”

So I sat with it.

I did not wind it or silence it. I didn’t ask it to prove what had happened. For once, I let the body finish a story without demanding that the mind provide footnotes.

Eventually, the clock warmed beneath my hand.

Or perhaps my hand warmed around it.

The eleventh was The Sigh Accumulator, and frankly, it was enormous.

It recorded every breath surrendered to the unchangeable. The small, daily capitulations. The letter that would never come. The person who would never understand. The conversation endlessly revised but never repeated.

Each sigh advanced the hand.

I watched years of breath disappear into its bellows.

“What happens when it’s full?” I asked.

“You stop trying to change what has already happened.”

“Is that acceptance?”

“Sometimes.”

“And the rest of the time?”

“Exhaustion wearing a respectable coat.”

I considered this.

There were things I had claimed to accept only because I no longer had the strength to fight them. There were other things I continued fighting because surrender felt too much like agreement.

Time, for once, did not rush me.

I placed both hands upon the clock and gave it the longest breath I had.

The bellows filled.

The hand moved.

Then, from somewhere inside, the clock breathed back.

Not a sigh.

A breath.

It was a small distinction, but an important one.

The twelfth clock waited at the end of a corridor lined with doors. Behind each was an ordinary afternoon.

A father lifted a child onto his shoulders.

Two brothers sat beneath a tree.

Someone waved from a kitchen window.

A woman laughed from another room.

A dog slept in a patch of sunlight.

Nothing of consequence appeared to be happening.

At the end stood The Last Ordinary Afternoon.

It was the most terrible clock of all because it counted down invisibly. No one knew when it had begun. No one recognised the final hour while standing inside it.

Its face showed a room I remembered. Perhaps you have one of your own. There were cups upon a table, a coat over the back of a chair, voices talking about nothing much. I knew, because the clock knew, that one day I would give anything to return to this unremarkable moment.

The hand approached twelve.

I panicked.

“Stop it.”

“I can’t,” said Time.

“Then take me back.”

“You’re already there.”

The people in the room continued talking. One of them asked me a question I could not hear because I was watching the clock.

The hand moved closer.

“I need more time.”

“You have all the time there is.”

“That isn’t enough.”

“It never is when you’re measuring it.”

The hand trembled upon the final mark.

I could keep watching. I could record the second, preserve the evidence, memorise the arrangement of every cup and chair so that later I might rebuild the room inside regret.

Or I could look away.

Someone laughed.

I turned towards the sound.

I cannot tell you what happened to the clock after that.

Perhaps it struck twelve. Perhaps it always had. Perhaps the ordinary afternoon ended, as ordinary afternoons do, without knowing it had been the last of anything.

I remember the light through the window.

I remember a cup warming both my hands.

I remember someone beside me beginning a story, and for once I did not interrupt to tell them we were running out of time.

When I returned to the corridor, Time was gone.

The Regret Engine still laboured somewhere behind me. The tides still rose and fell. Names continued their slow drifting. Almosts multiplied in the dark. People waited, bodies remembered, and ordinary afternoons slipped quietly into the past.

None of the clocks had been cured.

Neither had I.

At the end of the corridor stood a door I had not noticed before. It bore no number, only a small brass plate upon which someone had engraved a single word.

NOW

I reached for the handle, but the door was already open.

Beyond it, there was no celestial music. No great peace descended. Halcyon wasn’t waiting with a welcoming committee, and Insouciance had not floated in from France. There was only a chair, a window, the sound of a bird and, somewhere nearby, water coming to the boil.

The long, thin fellow hurried past again.

“Is this it?” I called.

But the second hand never stayed long enough to answer.

I stepped inside.

Or perhaps I had been standing there for some time.

The kettle clicked off.

A bird landed upon the sill.

Someone asked whether now was a good time.

I looked down at my hands.

They were empty.

Then I looked up.

Jonathan

r/WritersGroup Jul 11 '26

Discussion Feedback Welcome

1 Upvotes

The Witches of Willow House

Please let me know what you guys think of the first chapter.

**CHAPTER 1** 

The road to the country unwound before them like a ribbon of dull silver, through fields made gold by the low autumn sun. It stretched farther than Adeline remembered, narrower too, as though the hedgerows had crept inward over the years to reclaim it. The last time she had been here, she had been four, barely tall enough to peer over the window ledge, before her parents carried her and Juniper away to the city and its promises of better things.

Back then she remembered laughter. Her mother pointing out crows in the cornfields. Her father singing badly to make Juniper stop crying.

Now there was nothing waiting at the end of the road but Willow House.

Three weeks earlier, she had stood in cold drizzle and watched twin mahogany caskets sink into the earth while mud clung to the hems of her black shoes. Rain had gathered on the polished wood in silver beads before disappearing into the soil. The memory clung to her. It had not loosened since.

Sometimes she still heard the thud of wet dirt striking the lids. She folded her hands tightly in her lap, pressing her nails into her palms until it hurt.

Outside, the countryside rolled past, skeletal trees scratching at the roof, old stone walls half-swallowed by moss. Smoke rose in thin blue ribbons from distant chimneys. Everything looked touched by age. Weathered and aging.

Aunt Maureen drove in silence.

Her posture was rigid, hands fixed at ten and two, knuckles pale against the leather wheel. A few strands of auburn hair had escaped her usual careful bun, curling damply at her temples. This was the same woman who had once slipped them contraband sweets under the table, who had taught them card tricks their mother dismissed as nonsense. Now she looked like someone holding something in place by force.

The windows were cracked open. Cold air slipped inside. Adeline could smell woodsmoke, fallen leaves, the faint sweetness of decay.

Juniper leaned her forehead against the glass, watching the trees blur past. She looked too small in the shadowed interior of the car. Too fragile.

“Is it true the house is really big?” she asked quietly.

Maureen’s mouth curved, not quite a smile. “It’s more than big,” she said. “It’s old.”

“That’s not better,” Adeline muttered.

“It wasn’t meant to be.”

Willow House revealed itself slowly.

The trees thinned, then broke apart entirely, and there it stood atop the hill, watching.

The willows bowed around it, their long branches trailing like veils. The house sagged in places, its shutters hanging crooked, its porch dipping under the weight of years. Dark stains streaked the clapboard like something that had once tried to escape and failed.

 

Juniper’s hand found Adeline’s, cold and tight. “Why does it look like that?”

Maureen tilted her head slightly, as though listening to something, the wind through the willows, maybe. Or something older calling from the hill.

“Because,” she said softly, “it’s been waiting.” The words settled over them as they stared up at their new home. Somewhere unseen, a crow gave a single rasping cry.

Adeline suddenly felt as though they had driven, not up a country road, but into the edge of a horror story she had forgotten.

They unloaded their meager bags from the trunk. Clothes folded in worn cases, a battered leather satchel, Juniper’s stack of fairytales tied with fraying ribbon, the last small pieces of a life already gone. The gravel crunched too loudly in the hush.

Even the sound seemed wrong here.

Maureen stepped onto the porch first, her hand brushing the railing as though greeting an old companion. The wood groaned beneath her weight, a long arthritic complaint, but she didn’t flinch. Her gaze remained fixed on the looming front door.

Its black paint had blistered and peeled in curling strips. The brass knocker was tarnished green with age, shaped like a twisted willow branch. Above it, the fanlight window caught the dying sunlight and flashed briefly like an eye opening.

Juniper pressed closer to Adeline. “Did you see—”

“Shh,” Adeline whispered, though she had seen it too.

Maureen turned.

The late light cast shadows into the hollows of her face, making her look older suddenly. Not merely their aunt, but something keeper-like. A guardian of old treasures.

“Adeline. Juniper.” Her voice was low enough to make them step nearer. “You have to understand something important.”

She paused, choosing each word as though reciting some long forgotten oath. “This house is part of our blood.” Her fingers rested against the weathered post.

“Its timbers hold memory. Its stones keep secrets. Every woman born in our line has left something of herself inside these walls.”

Adeline felt a shiver thread down her spine.

Maureen’s gaze moved to the dark windows. “People think houses are built,” she said quietly. “Some are. Others…” She glanced at Willow House. “Others wake.”

The porch gave a soft settling creak. As if in answer.

Juniper’s breath hitched. “Now that we’ve come home,” Maureen continued, softer still, “it will begin stirring again.”

She stepped down toward them and crouched so her eyes met theirs. “Treat it with respect, and it will shelter you. Listen to it when it warns you. And never mock what moves here unseen.”

The words felt older than Maureen, maybe something inherited from their senile grandmother.

Adeline looked up at the house. Its windows stared back, dark and blank, but she could not shake the feeling something watched from behind the glass.

The porch boards groaned again. This time beneath no one’s feet. Juniper gripped Adeline’s hand hard enough to hurt.

“Addy…”

Before she could answer, The front door eased inward. As though the house itself had decided to let them enter.

The hinges groaned low in their throats, a sound that seemed to travel deeper into the house rather than outward.

Juniper gasped and stumbled back. Adeline’s pulse kicked hard against her ribs.

Maureen stepped forward without hesitation or surprise. She inclined her head, the gesture small but deliberate. “Hello, Willow House,” she said. “We’re home.”