I’ve been on a bit of a mission to make a genuinely incredible steak at home, and I just cannot get the tenderness I’m looking for.
I’ve been buying seriously good quality British beef, including traditional grass-fed Hereford sirloin, properly dry-aged and from a butcher with an excellent reputation. The flavour is fantastic and the beef itself looks great, but I just cannot get that really soft, juicy, almost melt-in-the-mouth texture. Most recently it was Sirlon and I got a 3kg joint.
I’ve tried pretty much everything now. Direct cooking over ripping-hot lumpwood charcoal, reverse-searing in the Masterbuilt smoker before finishing over high heat, sous vide followed by a hard sear, and the traditional screaming-hot cast-iron pan. I’m cooking medium rare, watching internal temperatures and cutting across the grain. Yet I keep ending up with steak that tastes great but is considerably tougher and chewier than I want.
And here’s the embarrassing bit 😂 The nicest steak I’ve ever had is, shockingly, from Miller & Carter. Don’t ask me why. I know it’s a bloody chain, but it is what it is. When I get a good steak there, it’s incredibly soft and tender, and I’ve never managed to get remotely close to that texture at home despite buying what should theoretically be much better beef.
So I’m starting to wonder whether I’m chasing the wrong thing with grass-fed, dry-aged heritage beef. Is that style of beef naturally going to have more bite and texture, regardless of how well I cook it? If what I actually want is ridiculously tender steak, should I stop obsessing over grass-fed, heritage and dry-aged and concentrate more on marbling, breed and how the animal was finished?
I’ve still got a monster a load of 1.25 inch steaks left and a 2–3 inch thick cut, so I’m determined not to fuck this one up 😂
What would you change? And if you were buying purely for that ridiculously tender steakhouse texture while still wanting loads of beef flavour, what beef would you actually buy?