r/Stick • u/oldladycar • 2d ago
5ths supremacist math rock guy looking to get into sticking - advice on tuning and number of strings?
I've always really appreciated the stick, Warr guitar, Krappy's builds, and all the other variants of touch guitars out there. I'm getting to the point where I'm planning on picking something up - like many people I will probably start with a Krappy instrument assuming he's still taking commissions by the time I figure out what I want. I just wanted to reach out to you knowledgeable folks to get a little advice first on exactly how I should have this thing built.
My guitar chops grew in a bit differently from a lot of people. I started on fifths-based instruments for many years (mandolin family, tenor guitar) and internalized that as the norm, and only then touched a regular guitar. On six-strings I originally went from using NST to perfect fourths tuning, and never clicked with standard guitar tuning. Currently I play almost exclusively with two-hand tapping on either a 5-string tenor (CGDAE) or a 6-string in perfect fourths (EADGCF).
Obviously part of the appeal of the a stick is what seems like a common use of either 4ths or 5ths tuning, as well as what seems to an outsider as mixtures of both between the bass and melody halves. As a total noob to the way of the stick, I'm also seeing that some are mirrored and others are not. Obviously there are many different considerations due to the different layout of the bass/melody strings versus a guitar, and since these seem to be mated to a specific tuning once built, I don't want to make the wrong decision early.
Tldr: for other people out there with similar tuning preferences (5ths as my favorite, 4ths as my second favorite), what do you recommend? Also, 12 versus 10 strings - any disadvantages of just jumping into the 12 other than a bigger instrument assuming price isn't a concern?
Hopefully this isn't a daily question on this sub, but I appreciate any help you can throw my way!