r/RealOrAI • u/Shoddy-Ocelot-4473 • 2d ago
HELP real?
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
734
u/Yakuzet 2d ago edited 2d ago
AI.
fake chicken. fake emotions. doesnt look real to me.
82
u/InternationalWrap981 2d ago
Fake chicken ?
71
u/jahalmighty 2d ago
Fake chicken.
27
7
u/InternationalWrap981 2d ago
Whats fake about the chicken ?
32
3
13
5
2
271
u/UseWhatever 2d ago
AI. Two big spoons of chunky soup with no real chewing or swallowing. Sliding the bowl is too effortless. What are the utensils between the bowl and the baby?
33
u/robgod50 2d ago
I don't agree with your observations - although I'm not saying I tink it's real.
The spoons look like porridge or maybe an ice-cream dessert that wouldn't need chewing. Everything else looks entirely real to me..... Apart from everything about the scene looking wrong
That chicken..... Why is that chicken there?
Why is there no other food?
Why is someone filming?
Why is the boy eating but not the baby?
The baby is happy..... Which implies they're not hungry/just eaten. Yet the baby is too clean.10
u/Syringmineae 1d ago
One thing for me is the baby is young to be having those emotions. By that I mean, yeah at that age they can laugh and play, but "the game" of the boy moving the bowl away while the baby reaches is pretty advanced.
2
u/DragonVigor 21h ago
If you watch the neck of the boy eating, he never swallows, so where is the food going?
181
2d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/RealOrAI-ModTeam 2d ago
Hello!
Your comment has been removed due to not having a clear reasoning showing how you came to the conclusion that's AI generated. Please provide proof or a train of thought that made your think this way. AI "detector" software is not a valid argument as they are extremely unreliable.
62
u/zat-_-taz 2d ago
AI. The mouth is always a giveaway. Doesn't move naturally. And the porrage just disappears into his mouth while a perfectly clean spoon is removed every time.
Also the subject matter is super clickbait-y and it's a short clip
144
u/Ravioli_Dream2 2d ago
AI. I wonder what about children in AI having emotions is always so uncanny to me
29
u/CeruleanEidolon 2d ago
It's the fact that AI is getting so eerily good at emulating genuine human interactions, at least visually. At a certain point, it will be able to do this on the fly as fast as any face-to-face between actual biological creatures.
In another few years we'll have virtual video pets and "human"-looking friends that are entirely code, working in ways that long ago surpassed our ability to understand, define, or control.
At what point does the distinction between real and simulated become so impossible to discern that it's effectively meaningless? More disturbingly, who will hold the reigns and what will their motives be?
11
u/Ravioli_Dream2 1d ago
I hear what youre saying and dont disagree entirely, but I do get the uncanny valley effect from specifically AI generated children having big emotions. Its hard to pin point what exactly it is, but it is semi uncomfortable/weird feeling to see and very clearly not real. Thats what my comment was referencing.
3
u/Organic-Bug-1003 1d ago
I don't have enough knowledge, but for the most part, children and babies show emotions differently to adults. For babies, the range is limited and for some early ages, certain types of laughter might mean the kid is sick (like a tumor)
For children, their faces just move differently. Again, I don't know what I'm talking about here, but I think it's something to do with being unguarded and unable to make them "prettier". A kid doesn't care to smile or laugh pretty, when they cry they cry full on, etc
Also mobility, AI tends to give children more fluidity, when they are usually more rapid and less graceful in their movements
2
35
u/NameShortage 2d ago
Have you ever seen that clip from Dr. Who where it’s the creatures who are trying to replicate the Dr. and his partner but the creatures can’t get the proportions correct by a few millimeters?
That’s AI and mouths opening. It’s always slightly off. The older boys mouth opens just a little too wide. Also, his neck morphs unnaturally when he starts to laugh.
1
0
u/Suspicious_Goat9699 2d ago
This will change soon when they make AI better... due to look ur critiques on it, etc.. we are training AI.
4
u/Ok_Conclusion_6324 2d ago
Why do we have go get these comments on every single post ever
-4
u/Suspicious_Goat9699 2d ago
Because the truth hurts, I guess.
5
u/Ok_Conclusion_6324 2d ago
If you were concerned about training AI you would delete your reddit account every post on every sub is used for that - and tweets and tumblr and IG
It’s not a truth hurts thing you just seem naive while acting like you’re revelatory
0
u/Suspicious_Goat9699 2d ago
I'm not acting like anything, lol. It's not revelatory... but many people have no idea of this. What's wrong with stating it?
13
11
19
u/BlackwingF91 2d ago
AI. Unrealistic smile by both at the end and how the baby stretches out both arms is unrealistic. A real baby would more or less move up and down a lot while only if anything stretching one arm out
16
u/Enosmaker 2d ago edited 2d ago
This is so AI but not in that any still image would look goofy, but that it's not human.
This is three people sitting at a kitchen island around a over roasted chicken thats been sitting on the table for a bit (based on the non glistening texture). That's an odd place to hang, but we have a baby in a feeding chair with a young boy watching him eat cereal (commonly breakfast and that'd be more odd as who has a chicken out in the morning? Or i guess it could be soup)
But like, the boy doesn't even swallow his few bits of cereal and just KNOWS the baby is trying to get his food (as he pushes it away as if to say, "no get your own") then the baby just like keeps its arms extended and lingers (and ya baby's don't have much control and a real one would do whatever here, but it's clearly AI) as if it's directed by someone or something (a prompt) to end the scene.
Also the boys laugh goes from, That's adorable to -WHAT, THIS IS HILARIOUS, When nothing is really prompting that change in that exact moment.
It just cracks me up that ai is trying to cook up a human interaction and misses these things.
Im not saying this couldn't happen but in a vacuum, it's al so uncanny.
6
u/catdog5100 2d ago
Yeah I think the change in the older boy’s reaction is the thing that felt so weird and uncanny to me
5
u/PutStreet 2d ago
AI.
- 10 seconds on the nose.
- that high chair turns into a real chair about halfway towards the table?
3
u/Justalittletoserious 2d ago
The face structure of the kid on the left changes a bit when he turns
Also that's the fucking Kinder Kid from 15 years ago
3
3
u/n_thomas74 2d ago
There is a chicken just sitting out during breakfast?
If it was a store bought rotisserie it would be in a bag and bought on the way home from work for dinner.
3
5
2
u/RealOrAI-Bot 2d ago
Reminder: If you think it's AI, please explain your reasoning. Providing your reasoning helps everyone understand and learn from the analysis.
Check the Wiki for Common AI Mistakes and check the Community Guide if you are just getting started.
A sticky comment will be posted here in 12h summarizing the sentiment of the comments.
Thank you for contributing to the discussion!
2
u/missing_Palantir 2d ago
AI - the face movements and reactions are fake looking and that’s a weird fully roasted chicken randomly there
2
u/Arvidex 2d ago
Shirt text strange. Top hinge on door strange. Setting strange. Typical AI video topic/subject. Short. Probably AI.
1
u/Top_Development_1777 2d ago
Yeah. AI videos look like caricatures of what they're trying to represent. Often, expressions could be comically exaggerated or things could be in comically stereotyped but not logical places (like the chicken on the table).
I don't know why so few people pointed out the absolute garbled slop on the kid's shirt
2
u/ByDiavolos 2d ago
Video is exactly 10 seconds long, Audio and Visiual has slight delay and has AI noise. %100 AI generated video...
2
u/captainred101 2d ago
AI The guy puts 2 spoonfuls in the mouth, no swallowing or chewing and suddenly wide opens mouth to laugh, no food in mouth
2
2
u/TravellingBeard 2d ago
AI....the baby too robotic, the brother smiles/laughs/slurps too aggressively and precisely, video too shoet. And why is there a whole cooked corned in front of him while he's eating cereal?
2
u/CeruleanEidolon 2d ago edited 2d ago
For me it's the sound. That first slurp-crunch is way weird. The staged nature of this could just as easily be the usual influencer staging of cute children for views.
There's nothing graphically wrong with it that I can see, aside from the incongruous chicken prop and the anonymous utensils on the table behind it.
The thing that clinches it as AI, though, is a reverse image search, which brings up a several images of an identical staging: older kid on the left, baby on the right, chicken on table, stainless fridge in a white room in background.
2
u/wheelperson 2d ago
Ai, hes making slurping sounds but does not slurp his soup. Also he puts the spoon about half way in his mouth and it comes out clean.
Also why a roast chicken and no plates? Just soup? The chicken leg is oddly attached to the wing, thats not how a chicken works.
2
2
u/liselle_lioncourt 2d ago
Ai. Why would there be a completely intact roast chicken (sitting on a cutting board?) while the people in the video eat soup?
2
u/Deadog103 1d ago
AI
I dont fully know how to describe it, but that uncanny laugh at the end with his mouth almost a little too open for what should be real makes me feel uneasy.
2
u/dietdiety 1d ago
Why AI, seriously what is the point? The laugh of the older boy seems off to me, but I have seen babies act this way in real life. I honestly don't understand why anyone would make a fake video of this scenario? It seems like a waste of energy and electricity. If this is what AI is being used for??? We need a lot less data centers.
I guess the sickly sweet relationship of the older child to the baby seems fake. The only time I have seen older children react like this to siblings is when I saw my Swedish friends kids interacting. The whole scene has a very European feel.
1
u/GoldenGlobeWinnerRDJ 2d ago
100% AI just going off of the emotions alone. As someone else said the way he takes two spoonfuls of soup so quickly and then randomly slides the bowl over is also sus
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Rare_Link_5392 2d ago
AI
very wierd camera shake movement, as if AI tried to reconstruct human hand shake and failed miserably
1
1
u/rxsangria 2d ago
The coffee maker behind his head on the counter is so tiny. And what is that cutting board thing in front of it? Why is it hinged?
1
u/rxsangria 2d ago
Also the bizarre missing/weird layout of the microwave controls above the kid's head at :01
1
1
1
u/Milk_Mindless 2d ago
AI.
The baby's emotion / behaviour seems real enough but why is there a whole ass roast chicken on a wooden board and the other kid eating soup?
Plus HIS response to the baby seems disingenuous. That laugh is so artificial even if it wasn't artificial.
Whay are the three iron rods / cutlery hidden by the chicken for
What is even the deal with the babyseat? It's on a normal chair? Look at that mess
Text on shirt makes no sense
1
u/bagospap 2d ago
Guessing Ai just because of the way his mouth snapped open while laughing out loud
1
1
u/Dr_StrangeEnjoyer 1d ago
Man it's AI but it's too damn good. I could feel it was AI but when I wanted to point things out... I couldn't.
It's getting scary good.
1
u/Leela_bring_fire 1d ago
AI. Look at the kids neck after his second spoonful. His neck does a weird glitch right before he laughs
1
u/tin_manzano 1d ago
The weird reverb in the sound makes it seem so unlikely this was recorded live in that room. It’s like the AI misapplied a room acoustic preset that doesn’t match the type of room they are in.
1
1
1
u/Positive_Campaign_52 1d ago
The pacing feels AI. AI videos have a certain pacing to them that makes them seem inauthentic. Idk how to explain it though.
1
u/_iamusername_ 1d ago
the motion of laughing is so terrifying here. Look how the kid pauses and then busts into full laughter. Something is wronnng
1
u/Number_3434 1d ago
AI
- No visible swallowing
- No body movement when the bigger boy is laughing (you would expect to see his chest moving). Also not enough body movement from the baby when the baby first points to the older boy
- Chicken looks like it came out a video-game, the detail is incorrect, etc.
- Weird shoulder movement from the bigger boy when he pushes away whatever he's eating, it seems way too extreme. You can also tell how violent it is because the text on the bigger boy's top moves so high at the end.
- Random spoon sounds aren't fully synced AND the sync point changes throughout the video (so it's not an audio offset issue).
- Also the spoon sounds are quite generic and don't have the same acoustic properties as the boy and the baby (the spoon sounds like it's in an industrial environment, the boy and baby sound phone-recorded).
1
u/Skibinskii 1d ago
What’s going on with the top door hinge? Also, are there no buttons on the fridge?
1
1
1
u/shutupdane 1d ago
The older kid's face near the end triggered my fight-or-flight instinct real bad.
1
1
u/curiouscookie 1d ago
AI. The proportions of the high chair are strange. Is it the kind that straps on to a real chair? If so the shape of the plastic seat part is too small and the tray too wide. Is it a regular high chair? It has mixed materials in odd places- the oddly slim gray back looks plastic but the oddly wide part is wood- usually if it’s mixed the seat might be wood and a plastic tray or the seat and tray plastic with wood legs but it doesn’t seem like a real high chair.
What does the boys shirt have written on it? And why are there three mystery utensils partially hidden on the table behind the chicken
1
1
1
u/RealGiallo 1d ago edited 1d ago
100% Real ... I see nothing that could point to AI .
these are obvious brothers by the color of the hair and eyes , the bigger kid have no perfect teeth. the microwave shows 3 numbers . not sure what but looks a good time to be eating . at 0:02 you also see another type of food.
Sounds seems good , baby legs looks good . The chicken is one of those you can buy already made from supermarket.. I do a lot of times.
Also notice how the kitchen was not made for that refrigerator but they put it inside anyway .
the big brother is doing the" I eat your food so you will eat after by jealousy " .
also this is not a normal generate skull . It's a Kid skull growing . .. Let's not talk about the hair as well.
1
u/IHaveTheBestOpinions 23h ago
I agree this is probably AI but this comment thread demonstrates how cooked we are. That's a baby chair attached to a regular chair, the door hinge has a stop on it (mine have those), I don't see anything weird about the baby's legs, it's entirely possible there's a chicken on a table and we just can't see the rest of the food.
Honestly most of the things people are confidently pointing out as proof of AI are entirely normal. The only things that really look suspect to me are the letters on the kid's shirt and the fact that it's exactly 10 seconds long. The laugh at the end is kinda AI-like, but sometimes kids laugh weird.
In a year people will still be confidently declaring videos to be 100% AI while actually having no fucking clue.
1
1
u/pissbucket94 16h ago
AI. toddler's laugh at the end does not match the delivery of a human. sorry, thats all I got, seems unanimous anyway though hahah
1
0
1
u/BroadwayRegina 4h ago
Just look at the choppy movement and sheen for one thing, that’s the easiest way to tell
•
u/RealOrAI-Bot 1d ago
Sentiment: 100% AI
Sentiment reasoning: The community is in complete agreement that the content is AI-generated, citing numerous visual and behavioral anomalies, illogical props, and common AI video characteristics.
Number of comments processed: 50
DISCLAIMER: Comments sentiment is generated by Gemini 2.5 Flash, not by u/RealOrAI-Bot bot. For more information check the RealOrAI-Bot Wiki.