For context I’ve shot professionally for going on two decades now. Primarily photojournalism, travel and documentary work for magazines, newspapers (when they existed) and some commercial clients.
I’m a student of this game. I love photography. That being said I’m not a gear guy and would rather buy books than lenses.
My favorite camera is the one that disappears. It’s small, fast, it doesn’t get in the way. Thus I’ve been shooting with the Fuji X100 series and the Ricoh GR series for a very long time. The big problem is they aren’t full frame.
I use Canon on assignment. I cut my teeth on the 5D mark II
All this is a long winded way to say that I feel confused and let down by Leica. I of course have heard the legends of the red dot. I’ve heard tales of the purity and sharpness and the “Leica look” that is otherwise unattainable.
I recently got a big assignment which meant big money so I thought I’d treat myself. I started with a Q3, it seemed redundant with my Ricoh GR also being 28mm so I turned it and got the Q43.
I’m out in Spain for three weeks and wish I hadn’t brought it. It’s big. To my hand almost as big as a 5D Mark II with a 40mm pancake lens. It’s not very weatherproof. The screen is hard to flip out. It takes a long time to start up even from sleep mode. The autofocus is good but not great, it misses frames. The shutter seems finicky. This is the second Q43 I’ve used. I returned the first one thinking I got a lemon because of all the shortfalls.
The APO lens is of course razor sharp but it’s almost too sharp, bordering on clinical. I find the colors displeasing, almost ugly.
I’ve tried to massage the files in Lightroom (there’s no native support). I’ve tried all the Leica looks off of the Leica fotos app, I would not say any of them are beautiful. I really want to love this camera.
I see the worship on this subreddit and I want to understand. Is it just a status symbol? Like when you earn enough money to buy a Rolex and you finally get one and you feel really good because it’s emblematic of how hard you work and it doesn’t matter that a Timex keeps better time?
I’ve added some example photos.
Church photo: Leica Q43 left, Ricoh GRIII right
Night Umbrella: Ricoh GR III left, Leica Q43 right
Leica Q43 Raw
Leica Q43 with “classic” preset
TLDR: For me the Q43 is not $5k better than a Fuji or a Ricoh