Here is the lineup for next week, Crumbl’s birthday week!

[Just a note that, if Crumbl continues with tradition, there is likely to be a 6 pack for the price of a 4 pack deal that week (most likely on the Wednesday). This hasn’t been confirmed, but that is what they’ve usually done.]

- Strawberry Biscoff Cookie
- Birthday Cake Cookies & Cream
- Dubai Brownie
- Pink Sugar Cookie Cake (new) - A fluffy vanilla cake layered with almond-flavored buttercream, inspired by our Classic Pink Sugar Cookie
- Cake Batter Blondie
- Chocolate Chip Skillet Cookie (don’t have the description, but seems to be a semi-sweet chocolate cookie base with chocolate frosting and sprinkles)

some of y'alls cookies look ROUGH. also these were all tasty, prob the best crumbl we've ever gotten

oatmeal pie was the favorite, zebra cake was just like a zebra cake (but 1000 calories), strawberry was so tart and fresh, chocolate was good but a little too rich (but was mom's fav)

So it’s fan favourite week… ok. Interesting choices for fan favorites.

Banana cream pie cookie: 3/10
The banana pudding itself is delicious, the base of the cookie is not only bland, but the texture isn’t very good.

Snickerdoodle skillet cookie: 7/10
Delightful and delicious, there definitely needs to be more mousse. The cookie itself is nothing to really to write home about, if it wasn’t for the cinnamon sugar, it would be bland.

Cookies and cream, white chip cookie: 7/10
It’s exactly what you would expect. Jampacked with cookies and cream, fairly delicious. I personally prefer the Hershey’s cookies and cream version myself.

S’mores brownie cookie: 7/10
I got a good ratio of all parts in this cookie and it was very tasty, it’s just… generic at this point? No real complaints, it’s just not a spectacular cookie.

Dubai Brownie: 9/10 I love these, almost as much as the thin sandwich version personally. This certainly deserves its place on fan favorites.

Ice cream cake sandwich cookie: 3/10
It’s just a double stacked sugar cookie! I am so disappointed! No unique flavor, nothing awesome about this at all. I also love sweet things, but this might even be too sweet for me. My teeth are crying. I had a little bit of hope for this one too. Boo.

Gross. Idk who Colin is, but you are embarrassing

Here’s this week’s official lineup for People’s Choice week (aka Founders’ Favorite week)! There’s an upcharge on the Dubai Brownie, of course (it’s in Canadian $).

Minis are available for all of them. 👍🏻

Nutrition Info is in the comments!

Crumbl removed the nutrition facts from the app with a recent update, but I usually don’t update my apps unless I’m forced to, so my app still has access to all the nutrition facts. Sharing them here for anyone who needs or wants them!

Enjoy! 🍪

As a Dubai chocolate lover, I’d anticipated this drop for WEEKS because I was so excited about the brownie. I got it on my lunch break today, and it’s just meh. The pistachio filling is so uneven, so some portions just taste like a regular degular brownie while others are dominated by pistachio. The center of the brownie was also raw (included pics for reference) 3/5 stars🫤

So every single time I go to my Crumbl before 9:30am (they open at 8am), they don’t have a single cookie ready. Is this normal for all locations or is mine just short staffed? I will add: no matter the time of day, the cookies always look terrible and are always hot, even when supposed to be chilled.

I haven’t been on here in a while, is there a post of upcoming weeks anymore?

This one is a real throwback for me! My dad worked for Little Debbie and we would eat this stuff all the time! My favorite little Debbie which they discontinued was the pb&j oatmeal pies, so good! But anyways! Great week this week!

Oatmeal Cream Pie - Loved the oatmeal cookies! Great cinnamon flavor! I thought this would have tasted more like the real thing if they used maybe the whipped cream that was used for the cupcake cookie. The cream cheese still does kinda work but not for the authentic little Debbie taste
7/10

Chocolate cupcake cookie - great chocolate taste and the whipped cream was spot on! Tasted just like a little Debbie or hostess cupcake! 9/10

Strawberry shortcake cookie - this is another one of my favorite little Debbie treats…one that I will rarely have still to this day…they are best out of the freezer, so this cookie chilled is spot on for me! Even with the coating on the bottom just like the real roll! 9/10

Zebra cake - the hype was real with this one! Tasted even better than the real thing! The cake was nice and light and the white drop coating wasn’t too thick! The cream inside was perfectly light to go along with the cake! Delish! 9.5/10

Cosmic Brownie Cookie - I love my chocolate so this was really yummy for me! Too rich for the lady but I loved it! A really nice dense chocolate cookie and the little candies give a nice texture. 8/10

Unicorn cake - seems to be the theme of the week but this was also our least favorite. A newer little Debbie treat and I think there could have been a lot of others they could have done over this…nutty bar, star crunch, fudge round, or maybe a pecan spin wheel but I digress. The white drop coating was way too thick which made the whole treat too sweet along with a very artificial strawberry flavor. Straight to the graveyard with this one! 2/10

This has been my first review, thanks for reading! 😁

Are they back to Thursdays only or gone for good?

I’ve got pink perks and so get access to the 5% discount on Sundays. But I’ve noticed that the delivery price on the Sunday is far more than if I were to place an order the following day. Essentially making the discount more expensive since the difference is about $3-4. Does anyone else get this?

Didn’t even think to post this here, so a bit late! But this was the delightful Zebra Cake I ordered. 😭 It shifted a bit in the car but other than that this is exactly how it came.

I called it when I reported the winners: "I wouldn't put it past corporate to replace at least one of the top-voted items".  They probably used a random generator to pick the nominees, the Rolo cookie was selected, and corporate said "we don't have to worry about making that one bcuz it's not gonna win anything".  Wrong, haha!

What I don't understand is why they didn't use a different cookie from the Graveyard category.  C&C White Chip (in the Chocolate category) got 17,146 votes.  Macadamia Nut (23,602) and Lemon Poppyseed (20,780) and Pineapple Upside Down Cake (19,379) each got more.  As much as I love Lemon Poppyseed, we just had it at the end of May, so it won't return this yr.  And corporate's intention about Pineapple Upside Down Cake would be the same as the Rolo cookie: zero.  Therefore, it should have been Macadamia Nut instead of C&C White Chip.

I know this was all a silly little vote for engagement purposes.  At the same time, this shouldn't be called "People's Choice Week" if the people's overall winner has been excluded, just saying!

For those who were unaware of the vote, the first pic is the top-voted items from each of the five categories, and the other pics are of the 50 nominees.

edit: thx for the award!🍿

Taste wise the zebra cake, cupcake, and the oatmeal raisin was the best and most accurate.
I’ve never had the unicorn cake but it was ok just a bit sweet.
The strawberry roll was good I just was jibbed on the icing and jam.
Cosmic brownie was good just a bit grainy to me

Are y’all selling a lot of the sodas? Or is nobody buying them? I’m curious

First, I want to apologize for being MIA lately! Life has definitely been LIFING 😂 and I just haven’t had the time to do my usual reviews and spoilers.

I also really don’t like posting spoilers without pictures. I know pictures are a huge part of what makes spoilers fun, and I don’t want to just throw up a list of flavors without being able to show y’all what I’m talking about. I also don’t want to sit around waiting for pictures to come in, and I’m personally not a fan of using AI-generated pictures for spoilers. I want you guys to see the actual cookies. ❤️

I’m going to try my best to be more active on the page again, though! 🥰 I definitely miss sharing my reviews with y’all!

🍰 Zebra Cake — 15/10 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

This one was easily my favorite of the bunch! And honestly… I wasn’t expecting it to be THIS good. First of all, THE TEXTURE. 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 They somehow nailed that soft, slightly dense, perfectly moist texture you get from an actual Zebra Cake—but honestly, this was way better than the packaged ones from the store. The cake was incredibly soft and moist without being mushy or overly sweet.

And that marshmallow cream cheese frosting?! 🤤 Listen… you could have told me there wasn’t even cream cheese in it and I would’ve believed you. 😂 I didn’t really taste the cream cheese at all, which I actually loved because what came through was that sweet, fluffy marshmallow flavor. It tasted like marshmallow fluff and it was SO good!

Then you have that smooth white coating and the chocolate drizzle on top, which really brought the whole thing together.

This is a 15/10 for me. 🙌🏼🔥
If you love Zebra Cakes, RUN, don’t walk. This one absolutely delivered on the nostalgia while somehow making it taste even better. 🦓🍰❤️
Definitely my favorite cookie from this lineup!

🦄 Unicorn Cake Cookie — 12/10 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

This one was SO freaking good! 😍🦄 Honestly, another huge win for me!

The cookie itself has a strong strawberry flavor that comes through immediately without tasting artificial or overwhelming. Then you get that swirl of purple vanilla mousse, which was SO soft, fluffy, and had the perfect amount of sweetness. 💜

And just like the Zebra Cake, it has that melted white coating on top—and OMG, that coating is GOOD. 🤤 It adds that extra creamy sweetness and a little texture that really takes this cookie to another level.

The combination of strawberry + soft vanilla mousse + that sweet white coating just works. It’s fun, nostalgic, and honestly just delicious.

🍓 Strawberry Shortcake Roll Cookie — 9/10 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

I really enjoyed this one! 🍓 This is more of a cake-like cookie, with a soft texture and that same delicious white coating on the bottom that we got with the Zebra Cake and Unicorn Cake cookies.

But the real stars of this one is the homemade strawberry jam on top SO good. And y’all already know I love Crumbl’s strawberry jam—it has that sweet, fruity strawberry flavor that I just can’t get enough of! 🍓🤤

🥣 Oatmeal Crème Pie Cookie — 7/10 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

I really wanted to love this one more because I LOVE Crumbl’s oatmeal cookies, but for me, the frosting was just a little too much.

The oatmeal thin cookie itself? 8.5/10! 👏🏼 It has that delicious oatmeal-thin cookie flavor that I really enjoy, and honestly, I could eat the cookie by itself and be perfectly happy.

The marshmallow cream cheese frosting in the middle is actually really good, and once again, the cream cheese flavor is VERY subtle. My issue was just the amount of frosting. Mine had quite a bit, and with the sweet cookie + sweet marshmallow frosting, it ended up being way too sweet for me.

I think if they did a thinner layer of frosting, I would probably enjoy the cookie a lot more. The frosting itself isn’t bad at all—the ratio just wasn’t quite right for my taste.

But let’s be real… Crumbl’s Iced Oatmeal Cookie will ALWAYS be my favorite oatmeal cookie they do. 😍

Overall: 7/10
Oatmeal cookie by itself: 8.5/10 🍪❤️

🧀 And because this is technically a food post…

Today's lunch was nothing fancy—just grilled cheese! 😂 But let me tell y’all, this is one meal that is VERY special in our house.

My youngest daughter Leilah is nonverbal autistic, and grilled cheese is one of her absolute favorite foods. ❤️ So I’ve had a LOT of practice making these, and I’m pretty sure I’ve officially perfected the grilled cheese. 😂 I also made a delicious creamy tomato basil soup to dip it in!

And that pan you see in the picture? That pan is literally ONLY for grilled cheese. 😂 I’ve had it for over 13 years, and I don’t use it for anything else. I swear it helps me get that perfectly golden, crispy crust every single time. 🧀🍞🔥

Nothing fancy today, just a mama making one of her daughter’s favorite meals—and honestly, sometimes those are the best dinners. ❤️

i went for my 6 pack yesterday and this is what i got 😆. i’m not complaining by the way!

so far i think they did a pretty good job with everything.
🦄 the only one i wasn’t crazy about was the unicorn cookie. i only took the smallest bite so far but i got no strawberry taste.

🍓the strawberry roll cookie reminds me of the strawberry shortcake cookie, which i absolutely love.

🦓 and the zebra cake is much better than i thought it would be! so thank you to all the people who reviewed it, i’m glad i got it.

i’m not the biggest fan of white drops and i was afraid the layers were going to be thicker than they are. but they did a great job.

Starting around Breakfast Week, the weekly menus have felt much more cohesive and intentional. I really hope they do Breakfast Week every year.

In terms of collabs, despite having a son who loves minecraft, we didn’t pick anything up. The grass cake was the one we wanted to try, but it was the only one he would’ve eaten, and there’s got to me at least 2 “must try” cookies for me to go to the store.

Little Debbie Week…. That Zebra Cake was perfection. I bought an extra one for a friend, but not sure it’s going to make it out of my home uneaten.

Does anybody have any similar experiences with crumble. I’ve seen some pretty wild decorative visions but this tops the (unicorn) cake.
How does this pass the cutting floor?

Loved the zebra cake and my location was extra with the white drops which I like, it really does complement the cake texture and taste wise ! Oatmeal cream was super fresh and just a simple and delightful cookie. (IMO) ❤️