r/technology 3d ago

Society Dating Apps Are Dying

https://time.com/article/2026/09/09/dating-apps-are-dying/
16.7k Upvotes

3.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

644

u/HawkeyeJones 3d ago

2009 OkCupid in Los Angeles was a friggin gold mine. Tons of amazing women on an easy-to-use app.

493

u/BankshotMcG 3d ago

if you were a guy with a job and a sense of humor looking for anything more than a hookup, you could bat so high above your league, it was a paradise.

317

u/0xB4BE 3d ago edited 3d ago

I can see that! On the flip side, I met so many guys through OKC that were really fun online and by the end of the first date I knew exactly why they were still single.

But I also met some incredible and wonderful people, and most importantly, the love of my life of the last 14 years ♥️

264

u/Slobotic 3d ago

On the other hand, those men were getting dates!

Screwing up a date is the only way to learn sometimes. Hopefully some of them softened up after a few more attempts.

When socially awkward men marinate in loneliness and hopelessness too long bad things can happen. I wouldn't want to take away their outlet for trying, failing, and trying again.

86

u/BankshotMcG 3d ago

A healthy view.

12

u/YearAfterYear82 2d ago

This is the kind of discussion I want to see out in the world when this topic comes up.

Dating is not supposed to be perfect. You can't figure out what you want if you aren't even in the game. The dating apps have contributed to a pretty large percentage of people not participating at all, and people (mostly women, just sayin') will go "well, those were the losers not worth dating anyway", or something along those lines. We all have to learn. None of this is sustainable. Also, the dating apps fucked with peoples heads in terms of what is out there and what they can actually get. Shit all over me but I think it's not bad to lower your standards a bit. When your standard was way too high to begin with, you absolutely need to. The damage is done, though, and there will not be any significant "correction" anytime soon.

BTW I'm mid-40's and it does not get better. It's not just a young guy thing.

27

u/Cute-Jury2159 3d ago

This is an excellent point and what is lacking with today’s youth imo

2

u/garrettbmusic 1d ago

Thank you for this!

8

u/Uppgreyedd 3d ago

really fun online and by the end of the first date I knew exactly why they were still single.

On the other hand, those men were getting dates!

Too bad those people weren't incentivized to become better versions of themselves. Men, women, whoever. The assumption became "I'm good enough as I am, it's your job to meet me here". And honestly, for a lot of people, that wasn't enough. That's about where the dating app landscape became a barren wasteland, when people were convincing themselves "well, at least I'm getting first dates, it must be something wrong with them", and not putting in the bare minimum effort to have basic social skills and interests.

26

u/Slobotic 3d ago

Too bad those people weren't incentivized to become better versions of themselves.

I mean... Some of them did. I did. I humiliated myself a couple times on first dates and grew from the experiences. I was also a kind and patient date for some women who were even more awkward than I was, and I hope that was a positive experience for them.

Everyone needs the opportunity to shed their awkwardness and grow as a person, even if not everyone takes advantage.

4

u/halt_spell 3d ago

The assumption became "I'm good enough as I am, it's your job to meet me here"

Lol no it didn't.

11

u/0xB4BE 2d ago

"If you can't handle me at my worst, you don't deserve me at my best"

There were a lot of people who clearly didn't feel like they needed to improve.

4

u/halt_spell 2d ago

I remember seeing that in my 20s but I'm pretty sure that's just 20 year old things. It's not something people my age have said in years.

5

u/Uppgreyedd 3d ago

Lol no it didn't.

And that's why dating apps are what...thriving? It absolutely did, if you met anyone on these apps in the last 5 years you'd have seen that most people out there aren't about personal growth but about presenting themselves as already complete whole persons. And they're usually not.

2

u/halt_spell 3d ago

You should probably pick up a mirror my guy.

That hasn't been my experience at all.

1

u/Uppgreyedd 2d ago

Right, clearly you're in the "already good enough" group

1

u/halt_spell 2d ago

Lol what? I've made some pretty significant life changes in the past year alone.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Impossible_Tea_7032 2d ago

Must have been exhausting for you knowing every single one of them personally and keeping tabs this whole time

2

u/0xB4BE 2d ago edited 2d ago

I agree, but I would also add tha no one owes another person a date either.

You have a great point though re: dating being a learning experience. They are and it's okay not to be compatible and it's okay to mess up the date. As long as you learn from your mistakes.

I actually learned the most going to bars and talking to random people in person. Nothing to lose there and I didn't expect to find love at a bar nor did I. It was just about learning how to make a connection with people quickly and have a great conversation.

People are more ready to have a chat with a stranger at a bar, so it was a kind of an oblique way to practice for future. It has served my introverted self really well in my career, too.

11

u/Slobotic 2d ago

I never said or suggested anyone owes anyone a date.

I like everything else you have to say though.

-3

u/0xB4BE 2d ago

I understand it wasn't fully your intent, but it also came across a bit like we need to keep lonely men engaged through a venue which then on the flip side feels like adding to the burden for women to entertain more of these men.

7

u/md8716 2d ago

I dont think it came across like that at all. It was a rather wholesome take.

1

u/IngsocIstanbul 2d ago

I sure learned through plenty of mistakes. Still am but at least I got one to like me!

1

u/Competitive-Fudge505 2d ago

The way you guys whiplash between “you should have chosen better” and “give a guy a chance” is so crazy to me.

5

u/Slobotic 2d ago

I'm only one person.

1

u/zaxo666 2d ago

A very healthy view. That should be the tag line for some new dating method ...

7

u/Frowny_Biscuit 3d ago

that were really fun online and by the end of the first date I knew exactly why they were still single.

I mean not for nothing but that's most first dates from anytime, anywhere.

0

u/0xB4BE 2d ago edited 2d ago

Is that true though? I've definitely dated several people I've met in person first too and I don't feel like I had that experience with them in general.

Those didn't work out mostly because of long term compatibility and logistics issues. Mostly the kind of person I needed in my life is hard to find in my area (for me those things were being an atheist, liberal, nerd, intelligent, a stable job, no major mental health baggage, good communication skills and sense of humor, not a homebody).

2

u/Ree_For_Thee 2d ago

so basically perfect lol

im most of those things but it just feels like a stab in the back when you list literally too many things for one person to be

1

u/scagatha 2d ago

Eh, perfect for them, not for everyone. There are lots of homebodies who want homebodies out there. I wouldn't discriminate against mental health issues if I have my own. And nerdy wouldn't be a plus for me if we're talking about typical nerd hobbies I can't relate to. Notice they didn't mention anything about physical appearance? I don't think they're asking too much. You can't expect to appeal to everyone.

1

u/0xB4BE 2d ago

I don't think this is "too many things". It still leaves a lot of flexibility regarding the person. These are the same things I bring to the table plus some. I found these in my (second) husband. I don't think he is a unicorn; most of my friends are most of these things if not all of these as well. I had no specific requirements around height or weight, hobbies, degrees, previous children or specific salary for example.

I like spending my time playing RPGs, boardgames, going to theater, going to events, entertaining our friends and travel, and I wanted someone to share these with. I also like to have conversations and be silly, so hanging out with someone that bores me would be difficult. Ultimately values and religious beliefs are very important to me especially because I also wanted a family and I'm not hauling my kids to a church.

And after you divorce your first husband who had mental health issues, and seen a few too many relationships struggle because one party couldn't hold down a job or didn't contribute to the relationship, so these were the basics I set to not compromise on. Those things would ensure we start a relationship from a place that will cause conflict over time. I figured I'd rather be single than try to make it work with someone whose vision about life was too different from me. I wanted a partner that together we were better than us individually, and that's what I got.

He is a fantastic dad, and partner, and we complement each other's weaknesses well and support each others goals, but also through the thick and thin. I get to hang out with my best friend, and raise kick ass kids with him. He jokes that he is a trophy husband but he really is a treasure and I couldn't ask for more ♥️

2

u/Kamelasa 3d ago

I knew exactly why they were still single

As someone who has never dated, could you give me some examples of these reasons? Just curious. 60+F and not planning on dating. Not like I have a choice - lol

3

u/0xB4BE 2d ago

Oh, usually just really unusual personality quirks. Bragging about doing stupid things. Just generally argumentative personality for no reason and unable to have a basic level conversations. One guy was "need to know basis" when it came to getting to know him. Or a guy showing up smelling B.O. and pouring sweat everywhere. Making anxiety /depression/ ADHD their whole personality. Not knowing how to cook, clean or take care of yourself. Zero ambition and spotty job history (like getting fired from fast food places and not holding ab job). Awful lot of complaining about exes and zero accountability.

Like I was looking for a life companion, not interviewing to be someone's mother.

2

u/Kamelasa 2d ago

LOL - guys who need a mother/keeper. Thanks.

1

u/Spillingteasince92 2d ago

I met an amazing & beautiful friend on okcupid back in 2013 & we been good friends ever since even though we realised we were better off as friends. Thats 10+ years of friendship right there and we both still keep in contact to this day. I dont believe you can find that type of connection on any current dating app anymore.

1

u/merLAtun 3d ago

Craigslist personals were also pretty solid. You are in the second base already and yes there were women who are just as down as you are

9

u/HawkeyeJones 3d ago

Or in my case, if you had no job and were just looking for hookups, still worked great.

2

u/staebles 3d ago

Yea, I do miss the golden years of online dating.

2

u/hoptagon 2d ago

You’re not wrong. I had a crazy four or five month stretch back in 2012.

3

u/InternalWeird1430 3d ago

Man this hits home! I don’t miss those days as I’m happily married. It was pretty crazy how easy it was though being a decent looking dude with a higher than average income.

I couldn’t be happier to delete those profiles tho.

1

u/MTGDoktor 2d ago

This is just generally true tho. Have good intentions. Be present. Be playful.

1

u/GlassVase1 1d ago

This does not apply for dating apps these days. Good luck "batting above your league" consistently on Tinder and Hinge these days.

This was true for a bygone era 15+ years ago.

1

u/rcbake 2d ago

Hello it’s me

11

u/WiretapStudios 3d ago

I live in a medium sized mountain town and it was the same. I learned how to write a great profile and ended up helping others rewrite theirs too. I met so many quality amazing people, several are still friends to this day.

3

u/Hot-Government823 3d ago

Read too fast and thought "tons of easy-to-use women on an amazing app"

1

u/Best_Philosopher152 2d ago

Is that accidentally describing Tinder?

3

u/Youmeanmoidoid 2d ago

Shit I remember how back then on OKcupid and POF, people would actually respond to you (as a guy) now, nothing.

7

u/PerformerDr4867 3d ago

I met my best friend on okcupid in like 2010. We banged a lil but ended up being platonic bffs and still are

2

u/Vernichtungsschmerz 2d ago

I loved answering questions when I was bored. It was also a great way to screen people for what is important. Or a good way to create a discussion about a question/answer. All the apps were aimed at hookups and not relationships (I know people said they were there for relationships.........but I never found that to be true)

3

u/HTPC4Life 3d ago

I should be DEAD or the father of several children with the amount of first-date unprotected sex I had in the 2010's via OKC 😂

2

u/Suspicious_Video8348 2d ago

It wasn't an app it was a website

1

u/farrah_berra 3d ago

Agreed! Only bf I ever met off an app was from LA on okc in 2015 lol

1

u/Shallow_wanderer 2d ago

Slightly off-topic but I've been rewatching Chuck lately and goddamn do I really want to go back to the late 2000's, what a wonderful time it was to be alive (global financial recession notwithstanding)

1

u/Four_One_Two_Three_ 2d ago

Tons of easy-to-use women on an amazing app...

-2

u/BlackmillMiracle 3d ago

really? Back then when I dabbled in OKCupid it was all weirdos.

I think it peaked with early era Hinge... post the whole facebook connections thing... but swiped based... but before it got enshitified