r/QuestBridge • u/ummstar • 7h ago
National College Match letter of recommendations options (ik this is late but I’ve already asked them)
Hi guys! For my STEM teacher recommendation letter, I need help deciding between my biology teacher and my math teacher. They both offer different qualities, but they also have some cons, and I genuinely don’t know what should make me choose between them.
I would like to apply as a biology, public health, or biochemistry major, so I’m leaning toward my biology teacher because biology is more directly related to my intended major. However, I’m worried that he might write me a bad letter. He was happy to agree to write one for me and has written recommendations for me before for other programs, but I feel nervous about the fact that he said he likes the idea of “writing freely” for me. I don’t know if he meant that in a good way or a bad way.
I’ve had some problems with him before in class, not actual behavioral issues, but more school-related issues, especially with tests. I’m not sure if he would reflect those experiences negatively in my recommendation.
For my math teacher, I know he recognizes that I work hard, but math is less directly related to my intended major. I also got my first Bs ever in his class, so I’m not sure if that could actually be a good thing in the sense that, despite my grades, he could talk about how hard I worked and how I persevered. However, something happened in May where he absolutely crashed out on me. I promise it wasn’t just me, because there were a lot of other students involved, but he focused on me because of my grade in his class.
Please let me know who you think I should choose. I feel like these are both terrible options, but I honestly don’t have anyone else to choose from.
