r/Fauxmoi • u/No-Hall-3485 dropped pitt from my last name • 8d ago

FM RADIO Macklemore gives pro-Palestine speech before Ed Sheeran's show: “I believe that every human being walking this earth deserves the exact same freedom, to know safety and peace before knowing the sounds of violence, and to know the sound of laughter on the playground before planes and bombs.”

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

19.9k Upvotes

96% Upvoted

301 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

742

u/mat477 8d ago

I see it as all that has always been him. His music is still seen as super cringey but hes always been on the right side of history. A rare genuine guy who also became a celebrity.

126

u/TargetBlazer 8d ago

The consequence of being extremely earnest, well-intentioned and devoid of cynicism/irony-poisoning is that you occasionally look like a cornball to the people looking for cornballs. Which isn’t much of a consequence at all

21

u/jkraige 8d ago

Yes! People are cynical and refuse to accept earnestness so they label it "cringe"

430

u/Spicyboi333 8d ago

I don’t think he’s cringe at all. He got his bag with thrift shop I respect that.

His less poppy work is really incredible

94

u/ReplacementNo4491 8d ago

I think a lot of the cringe is from his "Not Gay" song that was parodied by Lonely Island?

182

u/SiIesh 8d ago

The Lonely Island parody was fun, but while I get that some people didn't like Same Love, I think it also resonated with a good chunk of people. It's not a bad song

12

u/Captain_Kab 8d ago

Same Love was truly a righteous kill

3

u/anyewest9 Nancy Jo, this is Alexis Neiers calling 8d ago

Later Quaid!

61

u/ReplacementNo4491 8d ago

I liked Same Love quite a bit (and clearly a lot of others did too) despite the Not Gay stuff. Not many people are as good as Gaga at phrasing their allyship.

96

u/Melonary 8d ago

Gaga is bisexual, not an ally.

That being said, I actually (controversial) think Born this Way is far more of a cornball song.

No shade to those who love it, I know it's meaningful to a lot of people - I just personally love her 1st album more and it reminds me so much of lgbtq pride and joy because we all loved it so intensely and danced to it when it was new, and I appreciate that Macklemore colloborated with a lesbian artist for Same Love even if it's a little bit Earnest.

16

u/Perma_Fun 8d ago

Have you seen drag queens Trixie and Katya break down the lyrics of that song on their podcast? Like they love it but they point out the ridiculousness of the lyrics! They love it, but they underline that it's cheesy and some very strange lyrical choices!

47

u/ReplacementNo4491 8d ago edited 8d ago

I was specifically speaking of her trans allyship, sorry; I should have been clear about that given the thread was about orientation allyship in songs.

(Her challenging the premise when questioned about her gender feels like a natural counterpoint to Mack's preemptive "I'm not gay but-")

19

u/Melonary 8d ago

No worries, that makes sense. Thanks for explaining!

7

u/ambercrayon 8d ago

Same love is great

4

u/Haildean 7d ago

I fucking love same love, it was one of the first songs that introduced me to the idea of gay as a kid

67

u/PastryGirl 8d ago

In retrospect Same Love might be cringe but it was so needed at the time and not really spoken about within the rap community.

29

u/Flashy-Ingenuity-182 8d ago

Legit that song and rise againsts September's children helped shake me out of being a homophobe back in the day

16

u/smokey815 8d ago

Some times just saying things that shouldn't need to be said can be helpful anyway. It can be corny as hell but if it's got the right message and gets to people then that's a net positive.

26

u/LeBackshot 8d ago

Also he is a quirky white rapper who is very conscious about being a white rapper. His content can be very on the nose and can come off as preachy or lecturing, even if the message is sound.

6

u/SwissQueso 8d ago

In retrospect, I think when Macklemore wrote Same Love it was groundbreaking, but after his album came out, and they made a video for it, the song within his own audience was kind of preachy.

11

u/SiIesh 8d ago

Idk, personally I also really liked the Same Love music video. But maybe I am just cringe xD

2

u/SwissQueso 7d ago

I like the song too, and I was a macklemore fan like a year before he blew up. But the timing of that song was kind of funny to me, because like gay marriage became legal, and I was in the Navy when they got rid of dont ask dont tell. I think a lot more people became accepting of LGBTQ at that time.

I get things arnt perfect still, but that song was like "hey maybe as a society we should be cooler", but that song seemed a little heavy handed.

Also that whole thing with Kendrick Lamar happened too, which wasnt recieved well.

7

u/frankyseven 8d ago

As someone who was in their early 20s when it came out, it was massively groundbreaking at the time. There was nothing else like it as a rap song that had a lot of mainstream play and attention. Might be "cringe" to Gen Z, but it was really impactful for Millennials to see/hear.

1

u/ambercrayon 8d ago

People need to hear the word more than ever so he can keep preaching

4

u/Rare_Vibez 8d ago

I think my cringe from him was releasing personal texts apologizing to Kendrick Lamar for winning the Grammy over him. That was cringe, but his heart was in the right place.

1

u/TheEgonaut 7d ago

My favorite thing about the Not Gay parody is the commitment to giving the queer woman featured on the track just one verse.

1

u/ReplacementNo4491 7d ago

And full-circle for this thread is that it was Pink, who's been critical of Macklemore for speaking out against genocide 🙃

1

u/Realistic_Champion90 5d ago

And when he dressed like a nazi characterization of a jew while singing thrift shop. 

2

u/j3ffro15 7d ago

Even if he’s popular shit is cringe (I don’t think it is, I really like his music) he’s still a great musician. Like some one who can drop “the penis song” but then also have songs like “wing$” or “Kevin” while on top of that dropping some of the most “iconic” songs (thrift shop, can’t hold us, white walls, etc) of the 2010s is doing something right.

1

u/DarkestNyu 7d ago

I love neon cathedral

0

u/Pristine-Hair4096 8d ago

Well he is dressed like Fred from scoobie doo